3.5/10 This is probably too harsh and I don't have much room to speak, as my signature sucks, but your signature is too simple. :c I really loved your elaborate banners you did a bit ago, but this one is just too simple, and the "merry Christmas" on it is hardly noticeable. Maybe if the text in your sig was done up a bit more or something it'd go along better with the simple banner but it's not much so the whole thing just comes off as not enough. Lucky Star is cute though.
Fffff, I've contradicted myself so much once I look back at my bland sig. ;__;