Rate the signature (Update to rules: 1/8/12)

[Jagged Little Pill]

@Swram: Now that's just plain gross. (6)
@way too pro: OMG MAMOSWINE HUG ME (8)
@Purple: That looks like Bernkastel from Umineko/Rika from Higurashi. (8)

 

[Skiyomi]

@ Purplepassion: 7/10 - I like the colors in the banner and the art on it is pretty cool. But I don't like the glow effect around the art. It kinda makes it look like it was poorly extracted. Also, I know the black-orange gradient = Halloween, but since the banner is much more magenta it kinda clashes.

@ way too pro: 8/10 - I like the transparency effect. The icy brushes around Mamoswine look really cool. The one thing I could say is that the whole thing might do with some more contrast to make it less flat looking.

@ Flyingpichu64: 6.7/10

 

[Mr. E Goods]

Signomi- 6.5/10 I have seen you make better. Not too fond of the text underneath. In the spirit of Halloween I give you a higher rating for it. I would feel as though a black based background would look better.

Flying Pichu- 7/10 The black on the right side is a bit big.

 

[lindsy95]

@Mr E goods : 6/10 nice banner, I just dont really like it for some reason.

Skiyomi: 7/10 rather funny! but there is quite a bit of text there.

FlyingPichu: 5/10 Cute banner, I have no idea what its for though.

 

[Mr. Joker]

Skiyomi- I love the banner, but I dislike the text, the font doesn't fit it and neither does the textography. 7.

Goods- The pink coloring kills my eyes, although I love Sabrina's banner. 10. +points for being bias for Destiny ;3

lindsy95- lolzy, but nothing really. 5.

 

[ShinySandshrew]

Mr. Joker: The animation is nice and smooth but the sig could have a little more in it. 6/10

 

[Zhanton]

@Shiny Sandshrew: I'm sorry, but lame animation is lame. I don't mean that in a bad way, I just think it would be much much better to hand the Bible verse as just an image. Also, the colours are clashing everywhere. I'm a Christian so I have no problem with your verses but yeah. 3

@Mr Joker: It's minimalistic, yet I like it. 8

@lindsy; Umm, I don't get it. 3

@Mr E Goods; Pink text burns. It burrnnnnsssss! The heart on Mamepato's chest is awkward too, haha, but I like the banner. Yay for shameless advertising for Destiny. 6

 

[pikalax]

@ShinySandshrew: Very original with the bible verse thing, and I like your signature gag. In some cases, it's true.

@Zhanton: Witty blurb and comical image, combined with a non-intrusive layout, make your signature pleasant to look at.

 

[Jagged Little Pill]

@pikalax: It's just plain and that trophy looks amateurish. (6)
@ShinySandshrew: Well, I'm not a big fan of Bible verses, even though I'm Roman Catholic. (7)
@lindsy: Man that looks amateurish again. (6)

 

[SmartD]

@Flyingpichu64: It looks pretty good (9/10)

 

[junpearl63]

SmartD Too plain for my taste, but your dex record is impressive 3/10
zhanton Love NL's banner xD You always have good sig :3 9/10
Pikalax How long have you been using the sig? No ofense though, but maybe a little change? 4/10

 

[The_Boss_Giygas]

pikalax: 2/10
Just some sprites, messy text, and a lot of text.

SmartD: 5/10
Image looks fine, but just an image, maybe center your youtube link.

junpearl63: 7/10
Not bad, the photography work is nice.

 

[Zhanton]

I think this will be the last time I get this sig rated. New sig time haha.

~~~

@junpearl; I really like the colours in both the banner and the text. 8

@SmartD; plain sig is plain. 2

@Pikalax; you know the image with the text with the two Pikalax's? I can't read the text - it's all fuzzy and strange and yeah. It's very old and I think you need to change it or radically spruce it up. 2

 

[Mr. E Goods]

Joker:-- POKEMON DESTINY <3 <3 And wiggle that arse Zekrom! 10/10

Giygas:- 8/10, Shandeera is adorable! Red text under the pic burns though

Junpearl:-- 7/10 Not a fan of the band nor of photography sigs, but the text under is win styling~`

 

[EzzPeon]

@zhanton
LOL, nomnomnomnom (9/10)
@junpearl
i'm not fan of the picture but still, nice (8/10)

Ugh

 

[Skiyomi]

@ EzzPeon: 4/10 - It's kinda lacking in punch without a real focal point and it lacks cohesion. I don't really like smilies in sigs. But this one is very well organized.

@ Mr. E Goods: 7/10 - The art on the banner is really cute. I think your text is a little loud though for such a muted banner.

@ junpearl63: 8/10 - I love the color effects on the banner.

 

[Mr. Joker]

Goods- 10 like last time
EzzPeon- 4 like Skiyomi said
Skiyomi- 10 i love this one

 

[Zozo1999]

Mr. Joker: 6/10 Neat and organized, but sorta plain

I have a suggestion: What if you changed your sig, then can you post before 5 people post? It's sorta aking the thread dead, cause only a few certain people are playing

 

[Shiny Glameow]

9/10
Nice and organized.

 

[Shadow_Lugia_XD001]

Glameow: 5/10 lolzy trufax banner, not much else though. Text could be formatted better aswell.