Rate the signature (Update to rules: 1/8/12)

[Shinehollow]

7/10
Ash's not my favourite(Canadian.Deal with it) anime character,but he's up there.

 

[Reborn_Silver]

6.5/10- it's a bit messy, and the quote at the bottom seems out of place. i'd personally make it a little smaller and center it

 

[GhostlyMaiden]

9.5/10 Its very nice and the artwork is amazing. What is the character?

 

[Kuvario]

It's good and tidy now.

9.5/10

 

[GhostlyMaiden]

8/10 Too much Ash (JK) but its nice and tidy but the yellow clashes with my 'Ice Type' theme. Also that quote
I'm glad I could please you.

 

[Kitt Geekazaru]

10/10
Dragons, PASBL, and a cool pic. Nice!

 

[Wolfaotic]

8/10 I leik the pic and the dragon eggs!

 

[Murder Doll]

0/10 - The file sizes...

 

[GhostlyMaiden]

6.3/10 Pretty much the same reason as last time, but the dragons are a nice touch (hmmmmm i wonder why?), I would say putting one infenape on one side and another one on the other instead of three in a row, the Trainer card GIF still bugs me a bit. Also Henry :3

EDIT:
7/10 Your old banner was better (in my opinion) but everything has a good flow and the quote is true.

 

[Reborn_Silver]

Neat and tidy now, 8/10. As for your last post, it's Caitlyn, from League of Legends. She got a new classic skin which is outright gorgeous, so now she's my banner.

 

[Grovyl]

8/10: Everything flows nicely, goes well with your avatar, but I think it's a little bit empty.

 

[RogueMG10]

9/10 LOL wut

 

[Kuvario]

It's awesome, but I think the quote should go below everything else.

8.7/10

 

[RogueMG10]

10/10 Honestly, this is one of the best sigs you've ever had. The banner is beautiful, the quote is tear-jerking p) and I enjoy the XY season of the anime. It's *Ahem* MASTERfully crafted.

 

[Reborn_Silver]

9/10- would be 8/10 because it fits at "just above average" but i really like swampert ;u;
probs last one with this signature

 

[Schade]

Nice image, but the text didn't look very good. 6/10

 

[Kitt Geekazaru]

6/10
It's a little dark for my taste, but the colors work well on my dark-type theme.

 

[RogueMG10]

6/10 ...Ok then. I think that the redeeming factor of this sig is the final comment

 

[Kuvario]

Same as last time.

8.7/10

 

[Dragin990]

The quote is funny since I've never thought of Ash as a true pokemon master since his epic loss at the end of Sinnoh. It is a nice pic though.
8.5/10