1. We have moved to a new forum system. All your posts and data should have transferred over. Welcome, to the new Serebii Forums. Details here
    Dismiss Notice
  2. We are to experience downtime on Monday September 21st to bring the forums up to the latest version of the software. As this is a big forum, it'll take multiple hours to transfer and then rebuild the styles. We apologise for the inconvenience. In the meantime, you'll still be able to chat in the Serebii Discord
  3. Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
    Dismiss Notice
  4. If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders
    Dismiss Notice

Refusing a battle?

Discussion in 'General Pokémon Discussion' started by TeeterDance, Oct 8, 2009.

  1. Selfdestruct Togepi

    Selfdestruct Togepi Fangirls Beware!

    I always battle every trainer I see on my way thought the games, never waste a chance to gain exp I aways say.

    STICKTOPIA Well-Known Member

    I find it very annoying but that's how your pokemon get strong;)
  3. umbreon4ever

    umbreon4ever Dark Trainer

    I like the idea.

    But it will get anoyying very quick.
  4. MasterCharizard15

    MasterCharizard15 Manly Eybrows!

    It annonying that they can refuse rematches!
    They shouldn't be able to say no.
    They should just be pwn by the player over and over again until they die!
  5. Mr.Ghettoangel

    Mr.Ghettoangel escuchando reggaeton

    its actually a great idea, but it would make the game too easy, and then people would get mad and insult nintendo for no reason...
    being forced into battle makes the game funbecause its preparing you for the next battle.if u cant beat the bugcatcher wat makes u think u can beat brock?
    if youre going to go on a long journey through a long cave, prepare yourself, for example if you know your pokemon aint ready for that cave train a couple of hours more, and awalys have a first aid kit..
    come on now pokemon is a strategy game.
    be smart and think ahead...
    sont take the easy way out.
  6. Flamesword12

    Flamesword12 Active Member

    I like this idea but it will become boring and annoying.
  7. Sceptrigon

    Sceptrigon Armored Legend

    It would be very relieving and might make more sense, but then the game wouldn't be as challenging.
  8. Vernikova

    Vernikova Champion

    I think it should be put into the game. If you don't want to battle a trainer then why battle them? Of course, this wouldn't include Gym Leaders, the Elite Four, the Champion, any member of the regional team, and some other important places such as Nugget Bridge or Gym Trainers.

    The random Lass or Hiker should be optional since not battling them will not have any real impact on the game. Perhaps you could pay them some money as recompense for not battling them.
  9. *green_vulpix*

    *green_vulpix* Isolated

    I'm not really sure. I like the idea but at the same time I agree with the people who say it shouldn't be included in the game. I mean, it makes it more challenging, and it's already been like that for so long. And it's not like the typical trainer is really THAT skilled...

    You should just prepare ahead of time, or save when you think you might not make it.
    But like I said, I'm still in between on this idea. It would come in handy when you just don't feel like battling (even though that's really the entire point of the game...). However, it would get really annoying, REALLY fast if you had to choose between "yes" and "no" every single battle.
  10. Ohshi

    Ohshi Banned from Club Penguin

    That would make the game too easy.
  11. dragon-dark-master

    dragon-dark-master Thanks SPPf. TTYL

    It would make the game too easy for a while, then make it extremely difficult for the rest of it.

    In my mind, skipping battles would be quicker at the start, them slow you down at the business end of the season, if you will.
  12. Bobblefighter

    Bobblefighter Relic Owner

    I don't see the problem. I lust to face those trainers in battle. I dream everyday of that beautiful exclamation mark arise on top of their heads as they shamble towards me with that glint of competitiveness in their eyes. Their defeat sustains me, my victory is my ambrosia. finding and fighting them all is a pure and just destiny that must be fulfilled. I will consent to this duty, and love all trainers that want to fight me. Fall at my feet, mortals!
  13. Batdude

    Batdude Old school

    To be fair there are a good few trainers that are easily avoidable, I can't really think of many routes where it's battle after battle to the extent that I was so far away from a Pokémon Centre (or didn't have the foresight to buy potion or whatever) that my defeat was inevitable...

    Aside from the fact that it's good exp and whatnot, there's also the matter of filling the Pokédex, at least in terms of having seen them all.
  14. Skull-Kid

    Skull-Kid Well-Known Member

    I don't really care to be honest.

    On one hand, it is appealing to be given a choice as to whether or not I would like to battle this person. It would save me getting into meaningless battles or fighting when I need to get to a Pokemon Center. Yet, I want to face the random person. It in a way adds to the experience.

    By fighting certain trainers you get to see new Pokemon(sometimes), level up your Pokemon, or advance in the story. Besides, the game would be to easy if you just said "no".
  15. Noheart

    Noheart The Abysswalker

    Yes, it is annoying most of the time. Though, I think they're there to make the game a challenge somewhat. You know, so you can't just waltz right to the end of the game.
  16. ckayer11

    ckayer11 Steel User

    I always like hearing what little story the Trainers had to say before and after they battled, so I fought everyone I could find. The EXP thing is pretty much a given.
  17. Birds of Paradise

    Birds of Paradise FireStorm

    Maybe for a few trainers, but in general, no. If we could refuse all battles then would would just waltz into town and be underleveled, thus not strong enough to defeat the gym leader.
  18. Skull-Kid

    Skull-Kid Well-Known Member

    I love the story's to! XD

    Although I think every trainer in the game is brain dead. They say the same thing everytime you talk to them. It's like they have a memory of a goldfish which is 3 seconds I believe.
  19. ckayer11

    ckayer11 Steel User

    Ahaha yeah, that amuses me to no end.
  20. Venomfrog

    Venomfrog Perpetual Observer

    Like ckayer11, I talk to every trainer and enjoy it. Battling each is a fun experience.

    Honestly, skipping trainers by choice would be incredily tiresome. How many wild Pokemon ten levels less than your own would you have to clobber before being able to beat the stronger main trainers? I need every last bit of experience just to beat Roxanne.

    In my opinion, making the trainer battles optional in Pokemon is like taking the Koopas and Goombas out of the first stages of Super Mario, and leaving only Bowser's gang. A Pokemon game is suppossed to be a journey.

    I do see the case for optional battles for some people, but for me it is a waste of time. I fight everybody anytime and I know plenty other people do as well.

Share This Page