Along the lines of paranormal related games:
For DS; Lunar Knights is one of my favorite games, standard monster killing with puzzles. It’s based on the Boktai series, which you may be able to find for GBA if you’re lucky. Boktai was both awesome and annoying for the same reason, the weather affects your ability to slay vampires.
You may also be able to find Another Memory (um I forget the American name) for DS, where you play as a girl who tries to find her father aided by a ghost with amnesia. Lots of puzzles there. Touch Detective has some paranormal jokes if you’re keen enough to spot them, like that your butler is a vampire. Of course, that game is more craziness than anything else.
I’ve played Silent Hill 2, 3, and Shattered Memories all the way through (more than once), and have played part of 4 and 1. I won’t be able to get all the way though 1 until I get a PS1 card or a marathon party.
Owl Waxer does a bizarre youtube series on the Silent Hill games where thon shows thon’s gameplay footage with funny voiceovers and commentary on the wrongness of what is going down, “There’s a shot of my leg for you ladies out there.”
Ghostmaster (PC game) is also one of my favorite games, where you play as the ‘master’ of a group of ghost who go haunt different locations to achieve different goals the ‘ghost council’ sets for you (such as scaring everyone off, or revealing a secret without scaring anyone off). Um, it’s not as lame as it’s sounding... It’s kind of like pokemon in a way. You get to pick a group of ghosts to take in each haunting with you, and each one has certain powers which you can customize later on. There’s a lot of movie references as well, some of which are fairly funny.
Startopia is a fun PC game too, if you can find it. Not scary and only paranormal if you’re the sort of person that counts aliens as such. You run a space station with the help of VAL, catering to various alien races.
- Oh, and how about board games? I have Vampire Hunter, a fairly simple board game which you have to play in the dark because the light from the tower changes the board, cards, and dice, depending on if it’s night or day in game. We’ve never not had a good time playing that!