1. We have moved to a new forum system. All your posts and data should have transferred over. Welcome, to the new Serebii Forums. Details here
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
    Dismiss Notice
  3. If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders
    Dismiss Notice

Should the 'Flying' type be replaced?

Discussion in 'General Pokémon Discussion' started by Sonikku, Apr 12, 2011.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Sonikku

    Sonikku Kanto Starter Fan

    Theres always been much discussion over Pokemon typings and how they've been fairly limited to two slots, and we would need at least triple typings so every pokemon would get the types they deserve. This shouldn't be the case.

    The best way to solve the problem would be to alter the 'Flying' type or even remove it altogether. Its the only type which seems to take the potential away from many Pokemon by taking up their second type slot, as the capability of flight is very common. Its an action, and should be considered more of an ability than anything. I wouldn't understand why flygon, reshiram and other dragons get to have their own unique types.

    ;017;

    This is why I think a suitable typing would be a 'Bird' type, given to Pokemon like Skarmory, Pidgey, Dodrio and so on, alongside the moves like gust, arial ace and tornado. It would be more obvious why the Flying type has its strengths and weaknesses in the first place, and Pokemon which don't fall into the category of Birds could then finally recieve their own unique second typings whilst still being able to levitate and have access to Bird(flying) type moves.

    Thoughts on this idea?
     
    Last edited: Apr 12, 2011
  2. Charmander#4

    Charmander#4 Dating Rosie Palms?

    Beedrill is Bug/Poison.
     
  3. Ememew

    Ememew Emerald Mew

    Beedrill is Bug/Poison anyway, not Flying. And I think "Flying" is called "Bird-type" in Japan.

    Anyway, there's more to Flying than being immune to Ground (i.e. Fighting resistance), so Flying serves it's purpose as a type. Things don't "give up" a secondary type to become Flying, they were set to be flying by Gamefreak, who wanted them to have that type combination over alternatives. I see no need to remove it.
     
  4. Sonikku

    Sonikku Kanto Starter Fan

    Mixed that up pretty bad. argument still stands mind.
     
  5. Dattebayo

    Dattebayo Banned

    ^ Flying type moves are rarely used in competitive battles, so they're useless in terms of offense, but they can be decent in terms of defense on certain types.
     
  6. Sonikku

    Sonikku Kanto Starter Fan

    Bedrill wasn't a bad example, just the wrong one. :')

    And yes, Bird-type was originally in place of Flying-type in the early stages of development. It was changed to Flying-type, because not all Pokemon with wings, like Butterfree or Charizard, would be birds, thus needed a secondary type to represent their ability to fly.

    This was back in the day of 151 Pokemon and no abilities however, so then it seemed to make sense, but if Pokemon had originated in the form of the more modern instalments, it would be a different story.
     
  7. Skull-Kid

    Skull-Kid Well-Known Member

    If you have a look at all the Flying-type Pokemon, almost(Gyarados and Tropius being notable exceptions)all of them are birds or bugs. It makes sense they would be part Flying-type. Gamefreak haven't done it to ruin a Pokemons potential. They do it because it makes sense.
     
  8. Adrexus

    Adrexus Do it the bird way!

    Actually in today's meta with the fighting types around, its not as useless as you may think. At first a lot of people dismissed Tornadus because of lacking the electric and ground typing its brethren share. But, no type is immune to flying, which means Tornadus can spam hurricane all day long in the rain without something being immune to it.

    One of the problems though, is that flying doesn't have many good users. Fly and Bounce are terrible moves because of the two turn deal. Brave Bird users are few and far between. And the ones that get moves like that usually have other problems. E.G. Staraptor being SR weak. So its not a useless type, but it is somewhat mediocre compared to other typings.
     
  9. WizardTrubbish

    WizardTrubbish Enough of that

    Hmmm... interesting thought but bird wouldn't apply to things like Zubat.
     
  10. metagrody6

    metagrody6 COMO UN JEFE

    might as well. wont make too much of a difference anyway
     
  11. lucario beast

    lucario beast Well-Known Member

    no flying is one of my fav types
     
  12. fhqwhgads

    fhqwhgads _____________

    1. Charizard
    2. Butterfree
    3. Zubat
    4. Golbat
    5. Scyther
    6. Gyarados
    7. Dragonite
    8. Ledyba
    9. Ledian
    10. Crobat
    11. Togetic
    12. Hoppip
    13. Skiploom
    14. Jumpluff
    15. Yanma
    16. Gligar
    17. Mantine
    18. Beautifly
    19. Masquerain
    20. Ninjask
    21. Tropius
    22. Salamence
    23. Rayquaza
    24. Mothim
    25. Combee
    26. Vespiquen
    27. Drifloon
    28. Drifblim
    29. Mantyke
    30. Togekiss
    31. Yanmega
    32. Rotom
    33. Shaymin
    34. Arceus
    35. Woobat
    36. Swoobat
    37. Sigilyph
    38. Emolga
    39. Tornadus
    40. Thundurus
    41. Landorus
     
  13. Satori

    Satori ʮɳȿʈɵҏҏɐɓʟɝ

    The only thing I hate about Flying types is that alot of them are Normal/Flying
     
  14. legendarypokemonmaster

    legendarypokemonmaster Well-Known Member

    Rock, electric, and steel types are.
     
  15. fhqwhgads

    fhqwhgads _____________

    You seem to think immune means resist.



    It doesn't.
     
  16. FireTypeLover

    FireTypeLover Mr. Soul Stealer

    Nope, according to Bulbapedia, Flying-type is called Flying-type in Japan.

    Anyways, I think this is a bad decision. If it's removed altogether, what would happen to Flying-types that don't look like birds like Zubat?
     
  17. Dattebayo

    Dattebayo Banned

    Same can be said with the once dominant Psychic types, and they're the better choice.

    What about Sky Drop? It's a two-turn move that prevents the opponent from switching in. Plus STAB will increase its BP to 120. Let's not forget Aer*** Ace, though Smogon users will never use it for other non-flying Pokemon like Serperior and Heracross in terms of type coverage.
     
  18. Emperor Empoleon

    Emperor Empoleon Honor of Kalos

    I think the reason there isnt a Bird type already is because there wouldnt be many differences between that and the Flying type :/

    In terms of advantages and disadvantages that is.
     
  19. fhqwhgads

    fhqwhgads _____________

    The only difference would be the 41 species of Pokemon that are Flying, but not birds.
     
  20. Blackjack the Titan

    Blackjack the Titan Gay Yveltal

    There should only be an addition to a flying type called a bird type.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page