Biggest disappointment: Spain getting knocked out. I thought they were overrated at #1, but i didn't expect them to get knocked out of the group stage. Definitely a surprise and major disappointment.
Biggest shocker: Brazil getting roflstomped by Germany. Honorable mentions: Costa Rica exceeding expectations, Spain getting thwomped.
Best goal: James Rodriguez against Uruguay. Honorable mention: Schurrle goal against Brazil to put Germany up 7-0.
Worst reffed game: Colombia vs Brazil. To the refs' defenses, they weren't nearly as bad as Byron Moreno.
Best goalkeeper: Manuel Neuer
Best defender: Mats Hummels
Best scorer: Muller Honorable mention: Rodriguez
Biggest controversy: The vampiric Uruguayan.
Biggest surprise: Costa Rica. Honorable mentions: Brazil making it as far as they did with that team, Spain getting stomped.
That's my award list.
Very pleased with how this World Cup turned out. However, i can't say what things will be like after the World Cup fever has run its course. I expect a lot of upset Brazilians over the state of their country reappearing en masse protesting across the country (though technically they never really stopped the protests, they just died down a little during the World Cup.). Regardless, coming from someone who's watched every World Cup since South Korea, i definitely thought that this particular World Cup had the most fantastic "storyline" if you will, of any World Cup. If i could've wished anything different, i would've liked to have seen England make it through and i would've liked to see a greater effort from the Asian teams that made appearances.