• Hi all. We have had reports of member's signatures being edited to include malicious content. You can rest assured this wasn't done by staff and we can find no indication that the forums themselves have been compromised.

    However, remember to keep your passwords secure. If you use similar logins on multiple sites, people and even bots may be able to access your account.

    We always recommend using unique passwords and enable two-factor authentication if possible. Make sure you are secure.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

SPPF Superlative Manga Voting Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Atari

Atari

Did it on 'em
Reminder: Look, I don't know about the ballot counting, but I can't do it tonight. I feel like an idiot for keeping it up for longer than expected, but now it seems like it should stay up longer. If anybody has any input/help count votes, anything will be appriciated. Voting is currently open.
 
S

Solar Crimson

A Crimson Tide
Best comedy- Bobobo-bo Bo-bobo
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo)- Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative-
Best original art in any book- Hikaru no Go
Best storyline- One Piece
Best action/adventure- Hunter x Hunter
Best fighting- D. Gray-man
Best science fiction- D. Gray-man
Best historical-
Best horror- [Death Note[/i]
 
H

Hakajin

Obsessive Shipper
Best comedy- Azumanga Daioh
Best Romance/Fantasy (Shoujo)- MeruPuri
Best Artistitc/Alternative- Do downloads count? If so, then Music of Marie. If not, Lament of the Lamb
Best Original Art- Fuguruma Memories of Lament of the Lamb
Best Storyline- Again, downloads? Music of Marie or Inu-Yasha
Best Science Fiction- Chobits
Best Horror- Uzumaki
 
G

Goth_Guy

Volcano Trainer
Best comedy: Ranma 1/2
Best romance: Marmalade Boy
Best artistic/alternative: Pokemn Special/ Pokemon Adventures
Best original art in any book: Chobits
Best storyline: Fullmetal Alchemist
Best action/adventure : Naruto
Best fighting : Cowboy Bebop
Best science fiction : Galaxy Angel
Best historical : Inu-Yasha (Time Travel)
Best horror : the manga remake of William Peter Blatty's Novel "The Exorcist"
 
K

Kirsty_

Indecisive||
Best comedy: Love Hina
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative: Fruits Basket
Best original art in any book: -
Best storyline: Fruits Basket
Best action/adventure: InuYasha
Best fighting: InuYasha
Best science fiction: Chobits
Best historical: -
Best horror: Hellsing
 
S

Super-Staff

Turnabout Pokemon
Best comedy - Bobobo
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo) - Sailor Moon
Best artistic/alternative - Shaman King
Best original art in any book- One Piece (for shonen) and Fruits Basket (for shoujo)
Best storyline - Full Metal Alchemist
Best action/adventure - One Piece
Best fighting - Bleach
Best science fiction - Black Cat
Best historical - Samurai Champloo
Best horror - Hellsing
 
Last edited:
U

umbreloom

I can fly!
Best comedy : Bobobo!
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Ichigo 100%
Best storyline:Naruto
Best action/adventure: One Piece
Best fighting: Dbz
Best historical: Rurouni Kenshin
Best horror:Death Note
 
A

Aika

Member
Best comedy: Fruits Basket.
Best Romance/Fantasy: Tricky, but Fruits Basket again.
Best artistic: Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle.
Best original art: Full Moon wo Sagashite.
Best storyline: Fruits Basket.
Best action/adventure: Naruto.
Best fighting: Full Metal Alchemist.
Best Science Fiction: Chobits.
Best Historical: N/A
Best Horror: N/A
 
T

Tsubasa

Member
Best comedy: Ouran High School Host Club (It's hilarious)
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Fruits Basket
Best artistic/alternative: Gunslinger Girl
Best original art in any book: Gunslinger Girl
Best storyline: Bleach
Best action/adventure: Hunter X Hunter
Best fighting: Naruto
Best science fiction: Gundam Ecole du Ciel
Best historical: N/A
Best horror: The Ring
 
H

honey_clover112

tsundere full force!
Best comedy: Ranma 1/2
Best romance: Fushigi Yuugi
Best original art in any book: XXXHolic
Best storyline: Naruto
Best action/adventure : Naruto
Best fighting : Full Metal Alchemist
Best science fiction : Galaxy Angel
Best historical : Samurai X
Best horror : HellSing

;006;
 
O

Outlawz

I'm a slasher!
Best Comedy: FLCL
Best Romance: Fushigi Yuugi
Best Original Art: Hellsing
Best Storyline: Berserk
Best Action/Adventure: One Piece
Best Fighting: Bleach(Even though nobody ever dies, the fights are still fun to watch)
Best SciFi: N/A
Best Historical: N/A
Best Horror:Hellsing, This was tough it was between either Hellsing or Death Note. I mean Hellsing has the blood an vampires, but can you think of anything scarier than a killer notebook? But, Death Note is more psychological so I give it to Hellsing.
 
A

Anzua2

Well-Known Member
Best Comedy: FLCL
Best Romance: Fushigi Yuugi
Best Original Art: One Piece
Best Storyline: One Piece
Best Action/Adventure: One Piece
Best Fighting: Bleach
Best Horror:Hellsing
 
N

Namikaze

The One and Only
Best Comedy: FLCL
Best fighting: Naruto
Best Action/Adventure: Bleach
Best Horror: Hellsing
 
N

Nuriko55020

Dharc The Incubus
Best comedy:Naruto
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo):Fushigi Yugi
Best artistic/alternative:Naruto
Best original art in any book:Fruit Basket
Best storyline:Naruto
Best action/adventure:Naruto
Best fighting:Naruto
Best science fiction:Fushigi Yugi
Best historical:Fushigi Yugi
Best horror:Naruto
Mostly Naruto.
 
A

ak47madden

Berserk
Best comedy: Not many mangas focus on comedy but If I had to pick it would be Bleach
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo): Lol N/A
Best artistic/alternative: Vagabond
Best original art in any book: Berserk
Best storyline: Naruto
Best action/adventure: Naruto
Best fighting: Naruto
Best science fiction: Gantz
Best historical: Berserk
Best horror: Berserk
 
E

Edward_Elric

Non-Trainer
Best Comedy: AzuManga
Best Romance/Fantasy: ...
Best Artistic/Alternative: ...
Best Original Art In Any Book: .Hack G.U.+
Best Storyline: Fullmetal Alchemist
Best Action/Adventure: s-CRY-ed
Best Fighting: Bleach
Best Science Fiction: .Hack and the Legend of the Twilight Bracelet
Best Historical: Rurouni Kenshin
Best Horror: The Drifting Classroom​
 
S

Sailor Girl91

Member
Best Comedy:The Wallflower
Best Romance:Sailor Moon
Best artistic: Rozen Maiden
Best Original Art:Pita Ten
Best Storyline:Tokyo Mew Mew
Best Action/Adventure:Shaman King
Best fighting:Shaman King
Bset science fiction:Chobits
Best Historical:(none)
Best Horror:Death Note
 
M

MapleRoses

Jaejoong is HERO
Best comedy- Crayon Sinchan <- is this counted as a manga?
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo)
- Hana Yori Dango
Best artistic/alternative
- Oh My Goddess
Best original art in any book
- Detective Conan(Case Closed)
Best storyline
- Bleach
Best action/adventure
- Detective Conan(Case Closed)
Best fighting-
Inuyasha
Best science fiction-
Detective Conan(Case Closed)
Best historical
N/A
Best horror
Death Note
 
Cutty

Cutty

Forever now
Best comedy- Crayon shinchan
Best romance/fantasy(Shojo)- Candy candy
Best artistic/alternative- Death Note
Best original art in any book- Yugi-Oh!
Best storyline- I like GTO
Best action/adventure- Shoot me, One Piece (I can list LOTS of others if I want, really).
Best fighting- Tomorrow's Joe
Best science fiction- Blame! (more b/c I dont understand it)
Best historical- Sanzoku Ou, maybe.
Best horror- Le Portrait de Petit Cossette

Do I sound old?
 
S

ShinyPichu4Ever

Eye of the Storm
Best comedy: Ouran High School Host Club
Best romance/fantasy (Shoujo): Cardcaptor Sakura, XXXholic, and Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicles sequence (yes they are all corelated so I put them together)
Best original art in any book: FullMetal Alchemist or One Piece
Best storyline: FullMetal Alchemist or Soul Eater
Best action/adventure: FullMetal Alchemist
Best fighting: FullMetal Alchemist or Katekyo Hitman Reborn
Best science fiction: FullMetal Alchemist
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top