Serris
Specialist Operator
Hmm. Wrageel..
As GoldenOza stated, the uniform style of the fire is displeasing to look at; it makes it seem like a bunch of paper mache spikes.
It's meant to look thin, and I tried basing the style of fire on Typhlosion's as it seemed the most suitable style to try and make it look thin.
The spots are also depressingly uniform. Nearly all of them are just 4x4 circles and don't follow the tubular contours of the body.
I had trouble with making each spot look individual to it's position on the body, and it looked better them being the same than trying to make them all look different.
The tail is shaded as if though it were super thin. I'm not sure if this is something you tried to do, but if it isn't, it needs more circular shading.
The tail is meant to be super-thin; it's an eel. Although it has to have some body for the bone structure, it would need to be thin to help it swim.
There's some weird pillow shading on the bottom of its jaw, not to mention an excessive highlight shade on its head, as well. The eye (is it an eye?) doesn't look like one. I do like the way you did the mouth, though.
The pillow-shading is a problem, I see that now. Imagine the high-lighting as an internal luminescence. Although, I can always take out the brighter shade. And I'm glad there's at least one thing you like in the sprite.
In general, the design is a bit lacking and doesn't really look very Pokemon-like as it's lacking features (horn, flippers, fins, I dunno.)
Any design could be made to look like a Pokémon. People said stuff like that for 5th Gen, so why are people's fakemon any different? THere's always room to experiment with different looks. Rather than giving it fins, I gave it the fire to form the fins, and help with it's Dark/Fire typing. The holes along it's body pump out steam. The designs of Pokémon are very different, and some could say weird in 5th Gen, so I don't see why the "look of Pokémon" should fall into anything about deisgn. Unless the design is generally horrible. Then you can say what you like about the design.
THere's my responses in bold. Thank you the crit. the pillow-shading will be worked on. And I'll try and do something about the holes along it's body.