Staryu/Starmie

[M3talHe4d]

Hello,
I've been breeding alot recently to start my FireRed over. After finding a really good charmander, I started breeding Staryus.

I got a good Staryu with nice IVs but not the best nature.

Heres the info
Staryu
lvl5
Calm Nature
Hp 18
atk 9
def 11
sp atk 13
sp def 12
speed 14

IVs
Hp 10
Atk 20
Def 20
Sp Atk 25
Sp def 20
Speed 20

I got another Staryu
lvl 5
Timid Nature
hp 19
atk 8
def 10
spatk 13
sp def 11
speed 15

IVs

hp 25
atk 5
def 5
sp atk 25
sp def 20
speed 20

Which one should I choose?
I am looking for a BF/Orre Colosseum battler..Should i keep it or keep breeding,while i wait for a reply I'll be breeding some Skarmorys

thanks alot

 

[M3talHe4d]

no help at all...only views....?

 

[Freakshow]

The second one is better. Since in 2v2 you would want a fast hitter, and Timid makes it incredibly fast. Also walling stuff in 2v2 isn't exactly a good idea, so yeah, go with the Timid one. (and Timid is one of the best natures for Starmie)

 

[M3talHe4d]

I was hoping for Modest or Timid so i do know that...im not too crazy about the low def...but at least the HP is alot better so i guess it kinda balances out,therefore having the possiblilty of 361 speed(prolly get 335 with maxed out EVs and the IV) makes it the better choice I guess, anymore ideas?

 

[SwordofAeons]

Go Timid try to get pefect ivs for sp atk and speed.

 

[magnemiteZ]

Breed for another Timid one imo.