For start i disagree with those who claim how "Misty personality sucked after OI":Now i can understand that some may have liked only Misty going on rampage 24/7 slapping people and having zero tolerance which fits her description in early Kanto days but there was much more to her personality than just that and she definitely stayed funny and interesting character in Johto and Hoenn.She was still active and quirky being full of personality with taking care of baby pokemon allowing that different sides of personality come out on surface more being full of sarcasm and competitive streak,stubborn and witty,being passionate and adamant about things she likes, along with more of her girly side being showed which was nice contrast to her temper.We also get to see nurture side being explored more which was evidenced to exist when she first started taking care of Horsea back in the day.
She went from short tempered girl which didnt had tolerance toward anything trying to cover her insecurity with temper in more mature and levelheaded character over time opening herself toward others with various sides of personality coming out on surface more aside from only temper.
Because of starting to grow this also allowed for some great character development later on with Misty gaining sisters respect,getting over Gyarados fear,improving battling skills etc growing in tough character becoming more self confident while still having charm,humor and quirky side being passionate about battling,water pokemon,hobbies etc.
I liked Misty equally both before and now having nice blend of spunky and playful yet more mature personality keeping enjoyable older traits while also being enriched with some new ones having nice mix of tomboyish and girly side.
Dont know about others but i prefer characters which doesnt stay flat and one dimensional having more to them.
Also while im not expecting anyone to agree i think Misty definitely deserves second chance in this show,being great character who was not given justice and definitely has potential to be done more with it.
Like I said, no point in trying. It's like talking to a brick wall.
Just because you think your right,doesnt mean your opinion is the only right answer.Im still waiting to hear what is wrong in having different opinion about some things not agreeing with them?
Its not to expect that people have same preference and agreement over everything.
True. I think the other problem is Misty stopped arguing with Ash during Johto. The only times I can remember is the Totodile episode and maybe one or two others.
Not really,they just argued less compared to Kanto days.Which is understandable because both Ash and Misty started to mature becoming more tolerant toward their differences.Loud arguing in Johto changed more in mocking and playful teasing with Ash usually answering back to provocations being enjoyable because you had two way interacting.However that not to say they never argued in Johto as well because there still existed tension and competitive fire between two which can be noticed in several episodes("Like when battling for Totodile,in episode about Zapdos,when entering Whirl Cup,in Fortune Hunters etc).
I understand the writers wanted Misty to calm down, but I think they went too far. It removed an aspect of the character that was funny.
Depends for who,because Misty was still fun character to me.Temper was used in smaller amount,but that was hardly only aspect of Misty which made her interesting.There is also her cynical,passionate,humorous and girly side having various quirks to her which allowed for compelling character.
But in all seriousness, I know that you highly disagree with this, Misty was a fantastic character even after Togepi leeched some personality out of her.
Togepi didnt leched anything contrary to some belief,and im surprised that some people still dont know what is character development.Misty was equally interesting character both before and after getting togepi,with lack of screen time being main problem which supressed character.
Most fans enjoyed in character in Hoenn and original series with big demand for return and fact that her cameos were among highest rated speaking for itself.
Speaking of her goal writers started to establish it better with Whirl Cup,but not much could you have expect when main writer didnt cared.
I'm my eyes at least, once they had given up on Misty as a character, her personality seemed much more.. mature.
Not really because Misty started to mature slowly already by end of Kanto and in OI.
During start and middle of Johto when Takeshi did series construction Misty fall in background(though Brock fell even more),and it did seemed like they didnt cared.
However other members of writing staff clearly proved how they cared more for Misty character than mr.Shudo did which can be evidenced by increase of focus in Master Quest doing something about her story(goal) being followed with focus in chronicles and cameos in AG with people finding character enjoyable again.
Unfortunately, the combination of Misty and maturity sucked.. Her fiery personality at the start is what I remember her for, that was the character I loved.
Shame that changed really, because truthfully if they hadn't left it so long, her character could've easily been rescued instead of replaced.
I dont think it sucked.Misty was still fiery after maturity,but she was also enriched with some new aspects with her other interesting persona traits being explored more.Development provided Misty with more substance (as i explained above).Character development is never a bad thing because it gives more depth to someone enriching his personality making someone more deep and realistic adding to his appeal.Misty as we get to see in hosos and Hoenn was still quirky,flamboyant and vivid character which got some solid development growing in more mature and level headed character over time.
Just like Ash matured in Hoenn or May at end of BF.
She had personality in Johto as well still being fun when given focus,but often being in second plan didnt allowed her to interact or display personality properly,with same thing happening with Brock and even Ash.Too many fillers which didnt advanced plot didnt allowed said characters to flourish and develop properly.
Also im not sure what do you mean by rescued because Misty was already saved as character with writers starting to get her back on right track by time Johto came to end,but given how decision to remove her has already been set there was no going back.?As mr,.Shudo stated they were opting between replacing TR or Misty at that time in end replacing Misty because ex head writer was in favor of their stay.Writers could have fix mistakes thy did with Misty character keeping her in show having potential,prominent personality and popularity being possible to increase her involvement within anime increasing role but since mr,Shudo never cared much for said character advocating for leaving it happened what happened.
I still like pre-Johto Misty when she was a fun character, its just that she was on the show at the wrong time.
Except Misty was fun character in Johto and AG as well.
And if you look at Brock, if Misty stayed that doesn't mean her character would get any more focus. Brock stayed after Johto and the writers barely did anything with him.
Logical fallacy.Problem is that Brock his goal of breeder was very passive and you cant do much with something which isnt about battling and entering competitions.Initial issues with breeding aspect is that you cant measure much progress of someone whose carer is about taking care of pokemon and raising them to be in good shape.With Misty she always received more than Brock did(even in era where writers were inexperienced the most).With her goal it was showed how it involves battling,training,exploring as well entering tournaments being more active than Brock was warranting more screen time and exposure.
Misty cant be compared with Brock because we all know there is huge difference between their careers and personally.Using Brock as indicator to determine how would other characters be treated dosnt hold any water.Otherwise Cilan who is intended to be his replacement wouldnt receive as much focus like its case in BW.Sam gos for Iris.
If Misty stayed she would probably be treated same like its case with Iris or Cilan with her goal being better defined,more focus and emphasize being out on development of her pokemon along with possibly receiving some rivals(like current sidekicks did).Since writing improved compared to Johto days,writers realized what they were doing wrong with Misty being required to increase character role to justify further stay if TR was gone instead,and since her goal and story was more active compared to Brock she would more than likely received better treatment in AG compared to Johto days.