1. We have moved to a new forum system. All your posts and data should have transferred over. Welcome, to the new Serebii Forums. Details here
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
    Dismiss Notice
  3. If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders
    Dismiss Notice

The Battle Corporation Vs Skies of the Phoenix

Discussion in 'Guild Wars' started by Scubasteve23, Nov 24, 2012.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Kyro13

    Kyro13 Banned

    Lost 0-1 to ala gg
     
  2. ala

    ala dat ash

    won in a tight one, gg
     
  3. Skarm™

    Skarm™ Light It Up

    WOOHOO I knew ala would win! Thanks bro you da best and good try Assassin 1-0 was extremely close. Kidogo and Steve are gonna battle soon too so stay tuned to see the current 1-1 tiebreaker
     
  4. Dragonicwari

    Dragonicwari Artistically angry

    Good luck guys!

    And keep up the good work
     
  5. McDanger

    McDanger Well-Known Member

    sietse your arbok has a derp face, js
    nice try PA
     
  6. TherianForm

    TherianForm King of TM87

    Good luck both sides!
    Skies of Phoenix, we can win this!
     
  7. Nachos

    Nachos 42/f/zimbabwe

    Activity post. Malekpi...come out and face me.
     
  8. Blackacer

    Blackacer ~Artist~

    Good luck to both sides
     
  9. Sceptrigon

    Sceptrigon Armored Guardian

    Sorry that I haven't been very active here. Good luck on the war, guys.
     
  10. Sorry for not informing sooner guys but I won't have Internet (typing on my phone) until Sunday. Please sub someone in or me. Good luck to both clans and whoever gets subbed in.
     
  11. 00swms

    00swms Chaos Theory

    Well, Pie really there no need for a sub. Two reason the other guys can get there battles done. Lastly we have two weeks.
     
  12. Eliteknight

    Eliteknight S.L.Y.

    GO TBC nice to see i go away for 4 days and we are at war :D
     
  13. Cosmic Fury

    Cosmic Fury Evil Overlord

    Will my opponent please contact me for a battle. Thank you.
     
  14. Pathfinder

    Pathfinder Well-Known Member

    It was reported that Nachos was not an official member of the clan and hadn't signed up in your clan thread prior to the war topic being approved , so I'm sorry but hes not eligible to battle for you because the war lineup(this includes subs list and etc) isn't allowed to be changed once the topic is approved =/ . That goes for any other members with a similar situation as well.
     
  15. Skarm™

    Skarm™ Light It Up

    To be precise, he did apply, and filled out all the forms and everything, just not in the clan thread. He sent the form to Instinct. somehow, I think it was via PS, PO, or PM, so technically he is in, and he's ready to battle. But no matter, I'll tell him to apply on the thread too. Problem solved :)
     
    Last edited: Nov 28, 2012
  16. Instinct.

    Instinct. New Member

    Hi, nowhere in the rules does it state that all clan members are forced to post in a clan thread. They state that clans "may only accept official members." All of the people in my OP are officially accepted into SotP. I did not list people without their consent that they would join. I do not care about whether they actually post in a thread or not as the ultimate purpose of a clan is a group of people that ultimately get along. No specific "thread" or "xat room" can be constrained as a measure of determining who is actually in or not a clan. Certainly, they help as a record, but that's all it is.

    Reporting that Nachos is "not an official member of the clan because he hadn't posted in the clan thread" is terrible reasoning, as nowhere in the Rules does it state that "an official member must post in the clan thread in order to officially sign up." I had my members post in the thread as proof that they are legitimate users and NOT as alts.

    Nachos is someone who has been on Serebii Forums for a while, so I didn't pay much attention as to whether or not he actually posted, as he had expressed his interest in joining, and as far as I was concerned, was one of two members that had expressed interest in joining this clan as I had notified him and another user when I was contacted by skarmory7.

    I understand that what I define as "official member" may not constitute this website's definition of being an "official member," but nowhere does it state the definition for that term. I had read the global rules, and if this issue at hand does not relate to anything covered by the rules relevant to this subforum, then it is not right to force me to sub one of my players out for something that isn't listed in the rules as I followed the rules. I reference the rules explicitly stated as this is the one place that's transparent to everyone so that everyone is clear on what is and isn't allowed. Adding a rule on exact sign-up method is fine, but comparing this event with rules that were written after the event it happens in is illogical.

    tl;dr I dispute the claim that "Nachos is not an official member of SotP" as not only the reasoning behind the claim itself is flawed, but so is the conclusion.
     
  17. Pathfinder

    Pathfinder Well-Known Member

    When the rule was written about clans only using official members , there were alot of clans using what was called "On-Call Members" or "Honorary Members". They basically were good battlers that only participated in wars and had no real involvement in the clan itself and that was something that the competitive mods wished to avoid. As long as he applied to your clan in someway before the war was posted I have no problem with it to be honest. From the information that I was given it looked like he was just an honorary member of your clan or something and not apart of your active roster.

    Anyways thanks for clearing that up , Carry on.
     
    Last edited: Nov 29, 2012
  18. Skarm™

    Skarm™ Light It Up

    Thanks for clearing that up Instinct. and Archangel.
     
  19. Instinct.

    Instinct. New Member

    Thank you for your response and decision Archangel.
     
  20. Cosmic Fury

    Cosmic Fury Evil Overlord

    That was... unusual.

    But aside from that, my opponent contacted me and mentioned that he'd be able to battle over the next few days. I'll be on xat often probably around the same time as you, so if you see me on my clan's xat, then I'd be able to battle you on the spot.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page