Saw Return to Oz yesterday. Ever since I saw Wicked in February I've had an interest in Oz and so I felt it was time to watch this.
I really liked it! People keep saying it was creepy, however I think the people who think this are just expecting it to be like the MGM movie. There's scary parts, but on the whole I just found it to be a pretty good adventure. I thought the animatronics in this movie look great, way better than the costumes in MGM's movie. It's pretty faithful to the books, even if it is a fusion of two of them rather than a straight adaptation of one. That said, the way they joined up the two plots, while reasonably effective, did not meld them perfectly in my opinion. I liked their portrayal of some of the characters, particularly Tik-Tok and Jack Pumpkinhead, though I did not care for the sofa-moose and felt his expanded role was unneeded.
I've read 7 of the books, saw the MGM movie as a child, and now have seen both this and Wicked. And I have to say, while this movie isn't perfect by any means, it's the only one of the four so far whose flaws aren't one of the main things I associate with it. 8/10