• Hi all. We have had reports of member's signatures being edited to include malicious content. You can rest assured this wasn't done by staff and we can find no indication that the forums themselves have been compromised.

    However, remember to keep your passwords secure. If you use similar logins on multiple sites, people and even bots may be able to access your account.

    We always recommend using unique passwords and enable two-factor authentication if possible. Make sure you are secure.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

The Pokemon HeartGold and SoulSilver Club!!

Status
Not open for further replies.

Illusione-Tempus

Well-Known Member
What are your favorite places in HeartGold and SoulSilver?
Em, the biggest city in Pokemon World so far... GOLDENROD!

What do you think the biggest accomplishment of HeartGold and SoulSilver was?
Everything expect for the sprites.

What is the main reason you like HeartGold and SoulSilver?
The Apricorns... and the return of Johto

What's one feature that you think HGSS are lacking?
What Chimchar15 said is true
 

gelo-c00ts

Dragon Emperor
What other characters would you have liked to see in HGSS?
I want to see Drake of the hoenn elite and Lance the Champion tag team
 

Torpoleon

Well-Known Member
gelo-c00ts, rather than answering one topic and having a short ost, can you have a slightly longer and meaningful post. Oh and when you answer/make a topic, can you but the topic in bold?

What do you think of the slightly changed Team Rocket plot?
I think it is great, of course!

What's one feature that you think HGSS are lacking?
Hmm. Probably what Chimchar15 said.

What other characters would you have liked to see in HGSS?
Well, we do have some Hoenn and Sinnoh characters so it is good.
 

Illusione-Tempus

Well-Known Member
Ok, I lost my DS Lite yesterday and just found it today. Guess what time is it when I started to play?

10 October 2009, 10:10:10 a.m

Ok, if this year is 2010, then I'll be saying: Oh... me... gosh!

New topic:
What Pokemon would you like to add in HGSS?
I'll be answering this later

By the way, do we have to add trainers in the fan-art if we want to enter the contest? I'm just wondering about it... cause I can't draw people well...
 

Torpoleon

Well-Known Member
My club is already losing popularity?!

Cool, Mystic, about the time you played your DS lite. Well, let's not worry about Fan Art contests until November. (Not that there will be a fan art contest in November!)

What Pokemon would you like to add in HGSS?
Hmm. The Pokemon in there seem good.
 

Chimchar15

Well-Known Member
What Pokemon would you like to add in HGSS?
The only one I would put is an In-game Celebi, as I really want to do that Giovanni event without having to wait for an event.

New Topics:
Do you think the leaders gave out good TMs for their gyms?
Yes I do as all of them are unique and haven't been done by other gyms. Also they suit each leader very well.

Which TM do you think was the best one that you received from a gym leader?
I haven't played the games yet but I would say that Pryce giving out Hail is one really smart choice. I mean Glacia of the Hoenn elite four, Lorelei of the Kanto elite four, and Candice Snowpoint gym leader in Sinnoh all had pokemon the could use Hail and/or had pokemon with the ability Snowstorm. It's an severely underrated move. It does damage but slowly, so that gets annoying and has all these other great effects that go with it.
 
Last edited:

Torpoleon

Well-Known Member
Do you think the leaders gave out good TMs for their gyms?
Yep. The TMs the gym leaders give in HGSS seem fine.

Which TM do you think was the best one that you received from a gym leader?
Well, uh...I don't know.

REMINDER:On Tuesday, Oct. 20, 2009 is the HGSS Club's one month anniversary. Also, submit your one shots in between Nov. 1, 2009 and Nov. 15, 2009. No earlier and no later.
 

arceus7

Arcane Of The Wild
my favorite johto pokes are raikou and totodile

Im getting both games

My teams will be feraligator garchomp t-tar lucario hm slave bidoof staraptor

can I join?
 

Torpoleon

Well-Known Member
You can join, but elaborate on your posts next time and use proper grammar, like capitals and periods in the right spots. I don't like when people use abbreviations either. Don't post in my club like you're texting. (Even if you are posting in my club from your phone.) If you have not, please read my club's rules, but you are still in. Be sure to answer/make topics.

Rules updated! As always, look at the rules. It is not optional. It is mandatory that you guys look at the updated rules.
 

Imagine

ɪᴍᴀɢɪɴᴇ ᴜᴛᴏᴘɪᴀ
Wow, there sure are a lot of topics to answer. How did we ever come up with so many?

What HG/SS event is the best for you? and why
The Pikachu-coloured Pichu & Notched-Ear Pichu event. They just go so well with each other, not to mention Pichu's also one of my favourite Pokemon. xD

What is the main reason you like HeartGold and SoulSilver?
I like it because I liked the G/S/C games. The entire region, Pokemon, & characters won me over. It's also pretty cool that you get to travel to Kanto later on in the game.

What do you think the biggest accomplishment of HeartGold and SoulSilver was?
The music, the extra sounds, Gyms' features, I don't know. Everything seems so awesome that it's hard to pick the best one.

What are your favorite places in HeartGold and SoulSilver?
That would be Ilex Forest & Viridian Forest. I love forests. o_o

What other characters would you have liked to see in HGSS?
They have all the Champions in it. What more could I wish for? xD

What's one feature that you think HGSS are lacking?
I'm not sure about it yet. Until I finally get my hands on the game, I won't know for sure.

What do you think of the slightly changed Team Rocket plot?
It's a good change. If the plot was exactly the same as before, it might be a kind of boring to have to go through it again so I think it was a good idea to change it. Even if just a little bit.

What Pokemon would you like to add in HGSS?
Everything seems fine as they are. As long as all the original Johto Pokemon are in it I really don't mind.

Do you think the leaders gave out good TMs for their gyms?
Yup. They all match the theme of the Gym & the type of Pokemon the Gym Leader uses.

Which TM do you think was the best one that you received from a gym leader?
Hm...Earthquake, maybe?
 

Chimchar15

Well-Known Member
New Topic:
Which character from HeartGold and SoulSilver would you say you relate to most?
I guess I would say Blaine as he has a fiery yet cool personality.
 

gelo-c00ts

Dragon Emperor
What Pokemon would you like to add in HGSS?
there's nothing more to add I guess :D

Do you think the leaders gave out good TMs for their gyms?
Yup. some the TMs they gave me I used it :D

Which TM do you think was the best one that you received from a gym leader?
Dragon Pulse from Claire :D
 

Illusione-Tempus

Well-Known Member
What Pokemon would you like to add in HGSS?
Ooh, I have to agree with Chimchar15... PUT CELEBI IN HGSS!!!

Do you think the leaders gave out good TMs for their gyms?
Well they gave out pretty decent TMs (despite I couldn't decipher Japanese)

Which TM do you think was the best one that you received from a gym leader?
I rarely use TMs, so I have no comments about this.
 

Torpoleon

Well-Known Member
To RinSakurai: Yeah. Lots of topics for you to answer.
To Chimchar15: Thanks for making lots of topics! Although, can you also just form a discussion. I know there might not be that much to discuss right now so yeah.

Which character from HeartGold and SoulSilver would you say you relate to most?
Gold because he is starting his Johto journey and I just think I relate to him.
 

Chimchar15

Well-Known Member
To RinSakurai: Yeah. Lots of topics for you to answer.
To Chimchar15: Thanks for making lots of topics! Although, can you also just form a discussion. I know there might not be that much to discuss right now so yeah.

Which character from HeartGold and SoulSilver would you say you relate to most?
Gold because he is starting his Johto journey and I just think I relate to him.

You're very welcome, just happy to help.

Here are some topics I haven't given my opinion on yet
Which of the three Legendary Dogs do you like the most?
I love Entei because he is strong, wise, ferocious. He's also a fire type which is pretty cool.

Do you like the new in-game trades?
I love the new in-game trades as I feel like I'm able to interact more with the characters in-game.
 

Torpoleon

Well-Known Member
To Chimchar15: Yeah. But just try and make your post not just involve topics. Like, if you are doing my club's One Shot Contest, you can post a brief summary of it.

Just thought that I'd make new topics:

Do you think that Entei and Raikou knowing Roar is kind of unfair?
Yes, but it would make it challenging which is good. At least it is possible to get one of the dogs. (Suicune)

Do you think they should have put the Regis in HGSS?
They probably could have squeezed the Regis in somewhere. Besides, it is hard to get them in Platinum and RSE(if you don't have the guide)

So, is anyone entering the HGSS One Shot Contest? If so, you guys can post your summaries. You can also ask me questions about the contest over VM/PM.
 

Illusione-Tempus

Well-Known Member
@Torp, I might be entering the One-shot... as soon as I thought of one...

Do you think that Entei and Raikou knowing Roar is kind of unfair?
Nope, because I don't want to Mean Look/Block/Etc. But maybe it's because I can catch them both with Fast balls? :3

Do you think they should have put the Regis in HGSS?
At least provide an additional place for them rather than placing them into the Platinum event. Platinum's got Birds already, yet Regis are accessible through event. Why not make the Birds the event and the Regis available? ._.
 

Torpoleon

Well-Known Member
To Mystic: Cool! Good to hear! For me, there is a slim chance that I might do it. It would probably involve the Johto Starters or something. Although my description SUPPOSEDLY is not that good.

ABOUT THE ONE SHOT CONTEST: To prevent there from being flame wars, you're votes will be sent to me over PM, with any comments about each one shot. I don't want there to be flame wars, ok? Does this make sense to you guys? (I'll copy and paste this onto the first post as soon as possible)
 

arceus7

Arcane Of The Wild
Do you like all the new features in HGSS?
I love them all

Will you be choosing the boy character or the girl character and what will you name him/her?
Boy. The Name will be umm I have a whole list of names but I will probably name him Cloud or Axel
Anything you would have changed/added to the re-makes?
I would like a celebi event and I would change Clair’s team

Are you going to do anything different from the Original Gold and Silver?
Lots of things I will do differently but I can’t post all of them

Anything you would have changed/added to the re-makes?
I would like more gym leaders from other regions have more of a role in the game

What starters will you pick other than the original Johto starters?

Do you plan to play competitively in these games?
Definitely I will be shifting between HGSS and Platinum

What Pokémon would you like to see following you?
Lucario Totodile and Palkia

Do you think HeartGold and SoulSilver could have had better names?
No

What do you think of the sprites for the first 251 Pokemon in HGSS?
Most of them are Awesome

Do you think that the HGSS sprites are better than the DPPt/Platinum ones?
Somewhat

What did you name your Rival/will name him?
Zero or one of the names from my list

Will you preorder HGSS when you are able to?
Definitely

What Pokemon do you think should've been in the Safari Zone?
Seviper and a safari zone Deoxys event where a meteor falls in the safari zone

Considering that the only non-event legendaries from the first 3 gens missing are the Regis, how would you incorporate them into the game?
Safari Zone area caves

Will you SR for a shiny starter when you get the game?
Probably I always like for my true starter to have an egg move

The Bug-Catching Contest. What are your thoughts on this?
It’s improved a bit

What Legendary are you most excited to get?
Raikou mainly maybe Suicune definitely lugia and ho-oh

ApriShakes or Poffins?
Aprishakes

The Shining Leaf. Will you spend hours looking for 5 of these just for an extra star on your Trainer Card?
Yes you get treated like a king by the PC Clinic People

Should Red have this dramatic opening like Gym Leaders do?
Yes he is the top trainer in the game of course he should have a dramatic opening I believe the Ai for him should be the best out of all the trainers

What were your first thoughts when you first heard that HG and SS would be released?
I thought these games better be good.

Do you think that HGSS are the best Pokemon games, in your mind?
Yes so far only Platinum matches them but I think platinum could have been better

Which one do you think will be more popular? HeartGold or SoulSilver?
I think Soul Silver might be a little more popular since it has Lugia and a lot of people say it sounds cooler.

Where and when will you use the Poke Radar?
They have a pokeradar in this game?

What do you think of Silver as the rival?
Silver is a little dumb and emo but then again I like emo’s. He reminds me a bit of the reverse of Sasuke from Naruto going from bad to somewhat ok.

People are comparing Kotone to Kris and Super Mario. What do you think the reason behind this is?
It’s all in the hat and in their dumb bias and love for the poorly dressed Kris.

When will you use the Poke Walker?
I will use it while I’m doing school work and shaking my leg and moving it up and down.

Do you think it's unfair that only those in Japan can get movie-exclusive Pokemon?
Yes I have only gotten events through Wi-Fi and Serebii now.

Commemorative Photos are a waste of time? Or a way to capture memorable moments within the game?
I wish that the Amount of photo’s you could take were unlimited because I want to take pictures with all gym leaders. Platinum is the game that took me longest to beat the E4 and I want HGSS to take me even longer so I get to enjoy the games to the fullest the pictures will help me remember those good moments

What will be the first think you did/do when you get/got HG and SS?
Hmm see if I have a shiny starter since when you’re looking at the Pokémon to choose you can actually see if it’s shiny

Which Pokemon MUST you have on your team?
Feraligator HM Slave Bibarel Staraptor or Salamence Lucario and Tyranitar or Garchomp

Which Gym Leader are you looking forward to facing?
I’m looking forward to fighting Pryce Clair Jasmine and Green

Do you prefer the Poketch or the PokeGear?
I prefer the PokeGear. I like the Poketch because some of the apps are nice. The PokeGear I like better because of its functionalities and you can register two items now

Which of the three Legendary Dogs do you like the most?
I like Raikou the most. A double battle with raikou and suicune is awesome

Will you SR for a shiny Legendary in the games?
Probably not because I takes too much time. Some of them look ugly too.

Besides the whole Celebi thing, do you think Giovanni will make much of an appearance?
Not really Giovanni is sort of sick


Are you going to try and get Rayquaza in-game by getting both games?
Yes! Two level 50 Rayquaza’s. Are you kidding me there is no way I would pass that up and the chance to get a shiny is good too. I’m going to try and get a palkia and a giratina using the arceus event on HGSS

What do you think of having to go on separate little "quests" to get a rematch with the Johto/Kanto Gym Leaders?
I think it’s mainly a time waster to make you take longer to finish the game

Are there any features from any of the older games that you think should have been carried on to HGSS?
Um nothing I can think of now

Do you like the new in-game trades?
Yes but an onix and a steelix is a bit too much

Do you think that Moltres, Articuno and Zapdos should have just stayed in Platinum?
Yes and add other legendaries. I find it weird how Blaine and Articuno are in the same place

Do you think there are way too many legendaries in HGSS?
No not really

Do you think Silver should have had his Sneasel evolve into Weavile in the game?
Yes definitely more EVs for me

Pokethlon, do you find it time wasting or useful?
I think it’s useful.

What is your favorite Johto legendary?
My favorite Johto legendary is Mew if it counts if not its Raikou and Lugia

From listening to some of the music in HGSS, what would have to be your favorite Town/City/Route/Cave music?
City music

Would you change any of the Johto Gym Leader Pokemon for the remake?
Yes Clairs.

If you got the GB player, will you switch it on at all times for nostalgia purposes?
No

Which of your Pokémon you want it shiny, I mean in your Future team?
Garchomp

What do you think of the money saving feature returning from G/S/C?
It great

Do you think they should've put in a new battle tower or an old battle frontier?
It’s the same Battle Frontier it’s a part of Sinnoh’s map see here you have it. The Arceus event hints Johto and Sinnoh are close to each other since they made the Shinto ruins and Sinnoh is an Island that means where the rocks stop at the bottom of the water way in Johto leads to Sinnoh.


Do you think they should have put room decorations in?
Nope

Do you think that they should have added any more legendaries into HGSS, if so, who?
Yes Deoxys

What is your favorite Johto Pokemon?
Totodile

Were you expecting HeartGold and SoulSilver?
Yes

Apricorn Trees are now dotted all across Johto. Will you try to note all their locations or prefer the old game locations?
Note all locations is what I will do

What were you looking forward to most in HeartGold and SoulSilver?
EVs New game interface and a better AI

Would you play HGSS on you DS Lite and not a DSi just because of the Pal Park?
My DS Lite is sort of funny looking

What would be a better name for Soul, in your eyes?
Who do you mean Kotone? Soul= Gold Heart=Kotone I like the names just fine

What HG/SS event is the best for you? And why?
Pokewalker events get me lots of Pokémon

If you could only choose one, what feature of HGSS would you say makes it a great game?
The Pokegear upgrades. Oh the aesthetics the noise you make when you walk and such plus the AI.

What do you think of the new Safari Zone?
It’s the best one yet

What do you think of the added aesthetic changes to these games?

Do you think Prof. Elm should have been the one to start you off in the intro to these games instead of Prof. Oak?
Elm didn’t go since he is scatter brained

What are your favorite places in HeartGold and SoulSilver?
The dragons den Mount Silver Kanto battling house

What do you think the biggest accomplishment of HeartGold and SoulSilver was?
AI upgrade

What is the main reason you like HeartGold and SoulSilver?
Because its Johto Revamped

What do you think of the slightly changed Team Rocket plot?
I like it

What's one feature that you think HGSS are lacking?


What other characters would you have liked to see in HGSS?
The character from platinum

What Pokemon would you like to add in HGSS?
None except for Events

Do you think the leaders gave out good TMs for their gyms?
I definitely think so

Which TM do you think was the best one that you received from a gym leader?
Hmm Bugsy’s u-turn and Clair’s dragon pulse

Which character from HeartGold and SoulSilver would you say you relate to most?
Soul/Gold and Lance.

Do you think that Entei and Raikou knowing Roar is kind of unfair?
Oh yeah the scare you away when trying to catch them

Do you think they should have put the Regis in HGSS?
No not really it’s really superfluous

I answered all questions ^
 

Torpoleon

Well-Known Member
To arceus7: When you answer make a topic, can you put it in bold, please? Are you going to be entering the one shot contest. More details are on the first post.

I will start to plan an HGSS One Shot myself. Remember guys, one shots don't have prologues or chapters. It is a short (not too short) story. I know I said that I wasn't going to enter, but I will. I'll still accept votes and stuff. DON'T VOTE FOR YOUR OWN ONE SHOT!!

MUST READ: In Dec. 2009, we will have our first annual HGSS Fan Art Contest. The way it goes is that fan art must be submitted no later tahn Dec. 15, 2009 and no earlier than Dec. 1, 2009. Voting for your best (votes sent to me by PM) will start from Dec. 16, 2009 and end on Dec. 30, 2009. The winner will be announced on Dec. 31, 2009. I was thinking that we could have a fan fic contest in Nov. 2010. Sounds like a good day for everyone? I'll put this on the first post. For now, worry about the one shot contest.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top