This is going to be a long one:
I made it clear a long time ago, back in 2016, that the Kalos League set the bar so high that the only acceptable way to follow up that League is to simply break the ceiling and have Ash wins. There was no going back to Top 4s or Top 8s. Heck, even the Runner-Up position was simply not a feasible option for me. I originally had no hope for the Alola League to top the Kalos League, and I thought it would be the anime's best interest to simply not make an Alola League at all. I was not willingly to go through another Kalos League hype and backlash.
Then I had a epiphany in November 2016. Way too many people have placed their judgment not on character or their actions, but rather on their results in a zero-sum fashion. If you win, you were a winner and the best. If you only make it second place, however, then you were a loser and that's final. No dispute or critique. I realized what was the problem.
Why do people care so much about the League title and trophy? Do they not see that Ash doesn't need them to prove that he's a master trainer by his own right? The answer I got (several times across different sites and forums) was that, apparently, winning the Pokémon League would make Ash into a Pokémon Master and if Ash becomes a Pokémon Master, the show would end. And then they cite
this interview back in 2008 as proof. From cynics to naysayers to even casual fans, the notion was that the League Victory for Ash was the end of his journey.
The more I thought about it, the more angry I became and the more I wanted the anime to prove this misconception wrong. That interview didn't say "If Ash wins the League, the show is over." The interview stated that "
when Ash becomes a Pokemon Master, the show will end." And Ash had made it clear that he never saw the League as the endgame. He saw it as a step to become a Pokémon Master. And
I Choose You, Ash stated that a Pokémon Master is far greater than the strongest Pokémon trainer in the world. The League was not the end. It never was. And yet people believed otherwise. So how do you disprove this misconception? You have Ash win the League and
still travel to the next region seeking new challenges.
And thus, when Professor Kukui brought up his plans for a League, I had only one wish: To see Ash win that League no matter how it's set up or how Ash would get there. Now I often joked about Ash winning the Alola League would send the fandom into shock (which I wanted to see) and that the goalposts would be moved to maintain the tired meme of Ash never winning but deep down, I was serious about seeing Ash win. I wanted him to prove that winning a League would not stop his journey. That's more to being a Pokémon Master than being Champion.
Now was the Alola League much easier to do? Yes. Was Ash's Alola team not as great as the Kalos team? Yes. Were some of the battles comedic or poorly written? Yes. Was the final battle small and anticlimactic for Ash to win his first League? Yes. But I didn't care. What mattered to me was seeing that tired old "Ash never wins" meme and "League Victory" misconception being buried deep down in the grave. Ash had already proved himself to be worthy to any regional League champion by the end of XY. What SM did was hammer that fact.
I know a lot of people out there are expecting Ash to leave now, feeling that because he won a league his journey should be over.
As much as I want him to be replaced, now doesn't feel like that time for me.
he may have won, but I don't feel satisfied with the win, I get that this league can be "excused" because it was the first one, but it was lacking one thing, that most of the previous leagues had.
Intensity, sure we may have gotten some here and there during this, but not enough for it to be fulfilling, and no winning and losing doesn't detract from that factor.
Charizard vs Blaziken
Ash vs Paul
Ash-Greninja vs Mega Sceptile as examples.
Those fights were all intensive, win or lose they drew me in, I want Ash to win a league that is filled with fights of that caliber, and then I will be satisfied enough for him to go. (well deal with TR as well.)
Oh I don't want him replaced (for the time being anyways). I just want Ash to face new challenges that isn't the same old forumla used in the previous series beforehand.