1. We have moved to a new forum system. All your posts and data should have transferred over. Welcome, to the new Serebii Forums. Details here
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
    Dismiss Notice
  3. If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders
    Dismiss Notice

Thoughts on Ash having finally won a Pokemon League.

Discussion in 'Animé Spoilers' started by shoz999, Sep 15, 2019.

  1. 1rkhachatryan

    1rkhachatryan Call me Robert guys

    She loved it, she reacted to it on twitter and even made a video in Ash's voice congratulating Ash.
     
    Joltik-Kid and Dragalge like this.
  2. AuraChannelerChris

    AuraChannelerChris "What are yeh looking at. Gimme my booty back."

    Poor woman really misses her role.

    Dang it, TPCi.

    However, she shall always be Micaiah/Manuela to me.
     
  3. Sham

    Sham On the right road

    I’m sure a lot of people started watching DP and later.
     
    SerGoldenhandtheJust likes this.
  4. Shadao

    Shadao Champion GETTO DA ZE!

    This is going to be a long one:

    I made it clear a long time ago, back in 2016, that the Kalos League set the bar so high that the only acceptable way to follow up that League is to simply break the ceiling and have Ash wins. There was no going back to Top 4s or Top 8s. Heck, even the Runner-Up position was simply not a feasible option for me. I originally had no hope for the Alola League to top the Kalos League, and I thought it would be the anime's best interest to simply not make an Alola League at all. I was not willingly to go through another Kalos League hype and backlash.

    Then I had a epiphany in November 2016. Way too many people have placed their judgment not on character or their actions, but rather on their results in a zero-sum fashion. If you win, you were a winner and the best. If you only make it second place, however, then you were a loser and that's final. No dispute or critique. I realized what was the problem.

    Why do people care so much about the League title and trophy? Do they not see that Ash doesn't need them to prove that he's a master trainer by his own right? The answer I got (several times across different sites and forums) was that, apparently, winning the Pokémon League would make Ash into a Pokémon Master and if Ash becomes a Pokémon Master, the show would end. And then they cite this interview back in 2008 as proof. From cynics to naysayers to even casual fans, the notion was that the League Victory for Ash was the end of his journey.

    The more I thought about it, the more angry I became and the more I wanted the anime to prove this misconception wrong. That interview didn't say "If Ash wins the League, the show is over." The interview stated that "when Ash becomes a Pokemon Master, the show will end." And Ash had made it clear that he never saw the League as the endgame. He saw it as a step to become a Pokémon Master. And I Choose You, Ash stated that a Pokémon Master is far greater than the strongest Pokémon trainer in the world. The League was not the end. It never was. And yet people believed otherwise. So how do you disprove this misconception? You have Ash win the League and still travel to the next region seeking new challenges.

    And thus, when Professor Kukui brought up his plans for a League, I had only one wish: To have see Ash win that League no matter how it's set up or how Ash would get there. Now I often joked about Ash winning the Alola League would send the fandom into shock (which I wanted to see) and that the goalposts would be moved to maintain the tired meme of Ash never winning but deep down, I was serious about seeing Ash win. I wanted him to prove that winning a League would not stop his journey. That's more to being a Pokémon Master than being Champion.

    Now was the Alola League much easier to do? Yes. Was Ash's Alola team not as great as the Kalos team? Yes. Were some of the battles comedic or poorly written? Yes. Was the final battle small and anticlimactic for Ash to win his first League? Yes. But I didn't care. What mattered to me was seeing that tired old "Ash never wins" meme and "League Victory" misconception being buried deep down in the grave. Ash had already proved himself to be worthy to any regional League champion by the end of XY. What SM did was hammer that fact.

    Oh I don't want him replaced (for the time being anyways). I just want Ash to face new challenges that isn't the same old forumla used in the previous series beforehand.
     
  5. Leonhart

    Leonhart Banned

    I don't have much of a reaction in all honesty. I'm somewhat relieved that he won if only because it means that he's guaranteed to battle Kukui-hakase in the exhibition match, but to me Satoshi winning a major League was never really that important, so his recent victory just feels sort of empty to me. I'll be over it by next week most likely.
     
    J.Agera likes this.
  6. J.Agera

    J.Agera We will be surpassing our dreams!

    I don't really feel much. I mean I am happy that he won but at the same time it felt like damage Control for the Kalos League.
    I still think Sinnoh and Kalos were better places for him to win and would feel much more genuine.

    Meh.

    Johto wasn't even that good to begin with. While I agree the buildup was enough to end his character for that time.
     
    Last edited: Sep 16, 2019
    AuraChannelerChris and Leonhart like this.
  7. CPerry

    CPerry New Member

    I have watched the anime since being a child, yes I am the standard 90's baby who loves Pokemon more than anything else. Bought every single game + side-title, watched every film and every episode UNTIL Sun and Moon started. I am furious how dorky and stupid they made my favourite character, it is ridiculous. This series will forever and always be the 'Orange Islands' of modern times. Simply rubbish. This league doesn't count, it's an Archipelago just like the Orange islands, also doesn't involve badges like the battle frontier (which was awesome!). It's a new league with a low level of talent in a holiday destination, doesn't count.

    I really hope the writers and animators step up their game and make the next series worth watching again when I will be back to being fully invested. I don't like how people are saying Ash should move on, why? Because Digimon and Yu-Gi-Oh and a few other animes did? I'd rather see them invest some time and effort into making him likeable again. The Ash from the first first few series and movies is not the same as this clown. They need to fix that.

    Closing thoughts, this league doesn't count; looking forward to a bigger, bolder, proper league in which he does well and develops as a character.
     
    J.Agera likes this.
  8. Please stop complaining that this isn't a real league. If you don't like, don't watch it, don't complain. It isn't so hard. Stop watching the anime, if you can't accept this Ash, because this is pokemon too
     
  9. TTNH03

    TTNH03 Pokemon Researcher

    I have mixed feelings about this.
    On one hand, I'm glad that Ash won the League because he deserves it.

    On the other hand, it's a series that I wasn't invested in and I really don't like the direction that they took with the Sun/Moon series. I'd prefer if he won the League in Sinnoh or Kalos.
     
    AuraChannelerChris, J.Agera and RLC like this.
  10. CPerry

    CPerry New Member

    I said I've stopped watching it. It's not a real league. It's like going on holiday and your family win a football game against some other people on their holiday. Doesn't mean I won the premier league. It's a bad joke.
     
    J.Agera likes this.
  11. Captain Jigglypuff

    Captain Jigglypuff Leader of Jigglypuff Army Staff Member Moderator

    I think that his winning the Orange Island League should count as a win. Yeah it’s not quite an official League but it should still count. I mean Pikachu managed to take out a Dragonite that single handedly KO three of Ash’s Pokemon and had an incredibly strong Hyper Beam. This is the same Dragonite that took out Charizard Who was the strongest Pokémon Ash had at the time with Pikachu being the second. I just don’t understand why people don’t count the Orange League as a win for Ash. He defeated a trainer that was had an unbeatable run until Ash challenged him.
     
  12. Blue Saturday

    Blue Saturday too fly

    Everyone seems to love that he won the league, I literally see celebrities and sports stars taking time out of their days make twitter and social media post congratulating him. Hell, even CNN and a few other news outlets are congratulating. Even my regular people at my gym in real life happened to be talking about how “Ash finally won a league.” in a casual sense! So even people who don’t follow Pokemon super closely are in awe.

    Overall it’s directly the opposite energy of the Kalos League discourse from three years ago. Everyone loves our boy and is showering him with praise, affection, fanart and content. The only negative reception I see is leftovers from XY/Z upset because he didn’t win “their league” but that is what it is. I don’t expect the screeching over the Kalos League to end but I pray these are the last dying yells of Satoshi-Gekkouga, Alan and Lizardon-X nonsense and SWSH/S&M continue to usher forward a more receptive-era for Pokemon anime.
     
    Last edited: Sep 16, 2019
  13. Xuxuba

    Xuxuba Well-Known Member

    I mean, i don't think it is a fake league, but what you said about either "stop complaining or stop watching" is a false dilemma fallacy. Also, the thread literally asked what their opinions were, so it seems counterproductive to ask them to shut up.
     
  14. Dragalge

    Dragalge Naganadel

    CNN really is fake news lol. Their headline says that he finally became a Pokemon Master. B/

    I think my favorite part is Veronica Taylor (or Sarah) congratulating Rica’s work for Ash in the last 22 years. English and Japanese actresses being nice to each other!
     
  15. ash&charizardfan

    ash&charizardfan Humanity's greatest soldier

    Somewhere alain, MCX and ash greninja will be taking a long sigh of relief and thanking heavens that he win otherwise they would have to listen to the hate comments even in the future, atleeast that will stop to some extent.
     
  16. J.Agera

    J.Agera We will be surpassing our dreams!

    I mean the SM fanbase is provoking them so I don't really blame them for lashing out lmao. "SM Ash is superior" just because he won a league meme is all over twitter.
     
    Kaye Cruiser, Ignition and mehmeh1 like this.
  17. Pokegirl Fan~

    Pokegirl Fan~ Tsundere Girl

    This post somewhat reminds me of the Steve Bartman incident from the 2003 Major League Baseball postseason lol
     
    LilligantLewis likes this.
  18. Blue Saturday

    Blue Saturday too fly

    Well personally I think SM and SM!Satoshi are superior but it has to do with more than just winning a league.
     
  19. Xuxuba

    Xuxuba Well-Known Member

    Personally, i think Drake felt more like a threat than anyone in this entire League.
     
    J.Agera likes this.
  20. Sham

    Sham On the right road

    The salt is expected that Ash won this league but I still prefer this league to the other one, sorry. I’m more invested in Ash’s and Gladion’s story and the writers actively tried to convince us to root for Ash. I just wish we got to see at least ONE of his friends see him win he league. Oh well.
     

Share This Page