Okay, something clearly needs to be addressed here.
The issue is not people wanting to have their Pokemon cloned or not.
The issue is the way shop owners do it. RNGing is a legitimate way to get Pokemon, so that is fine. Using the glitch in Emerald or 4th Gen GTS is fine. Using Action Replay, something that isn't even remotely related to Pokemon in any sense, is not tolerated site-wide. It's not allowed in the SPP WiFi chat, it's not allowed in trading threads, and much less it is not allowed to offer cloning services using it.
Don't get me wrong: I bet all of us wouldn't really mind using an Action Replay. But Serebii Joe has stated in the past that cheating devices are not in the nature of the game, they only cheapen it. As a community, we must respect what the owner wishes in order to have a happy, fun trading experience. Ultimately it is up to him, but judging from that previous statement; Action Replay, PokeSav, PokeGen (If that's even a cheating device), PokeGTS, Gameshark or any other cheating device will never be tolerated.
Cloning is absolutely fine, provided it's done legitimately, whether that'd be RNGing, Emerald or the 4th Gen GTS.