While I don't want to comment on all of Scammel's points, I want to say as a gay man I'm genuinely more afraid of your typical MAGA/Trump supporter than I am of your typical American Muslim--and, to clarify, I'm not afraid of the latter.
Honestly, there's something disturbing--perhaps homophobic is the word--when the right seems to only care about me as a victim of supposed Islam extremism. The Pulse night club shooting is almost impossible not to mention, but the narrative 'Muslim man kills gay people because Islamism' was accepted very uncritically--but the right happily used that narrative as a beacon of Islamphobia. Go look back at Trump's RNC speech and the only time he mentions LGBT people is in that context--and he's surprised that his base actually cared that queer people died. I don't know what instigated the Pulse night club shooting, but I'm sure as hell it's far nuanced than that simple Islamism narrative. But more to the point, that same administration just a week or two ago allowed and encouraged doctors to refuse medical treatment to queer people and the federal judges being nominated to positions is very anti-queer--and I'm supposed to believe they actually care about me? I'm sorry, but most of the time I see people relying on us queer folks as justification for Islamophobia, I can't see it as anything else other than being used.
And yes, I'm aware there's a rather high correlation between anti-gay laws and Muslim majority countries, but lest we forget American didn't shed its anti-gay laws until 15 years ago--so I'm not sure how different it really is from here. I'm honestly out of my league here, but the origins of anti-LGBT laws in Muslim majority countries seems complicated at best (e.g. why are so many of these laws relatively recent?), and while Islam may play a role it's probably one of many interlinking factors.