Caluminousdugtrio
class on my back
I never denied that. But tell me... why exactly should the fine line between "a Pokémon weak enough to be OU" and "a Pokémon strong enough to be Über" be drawn between Terrakion (probably the best OU Pokémon currently) and Manaphy (probably the worst current Über)? Do you not think that this line is drawn at a completely arbitrary point?
Übers is a banlist consisting of the Pokémon that are considered to be too powerful for the OU metagame, and thus causing imbalance and overcentralization in it, but if the OU metagame can be balanced after only Arceus is banned from it (and as someone who is extremely experienced with the Übers metagame, I can tell you that that would indeed be the case), then why should the Übers tier consist of any Pokémon besides Arceus? The fine line between "a Pokémon weak enough to be OU" and "a Pokémon strong enough to be Über" should be drawn between the Pokémon that are capable of being balanced in a certain metagame, and a Pokémon which cannot be balanced in any metagame.
Read this post, which explains in detail exactly what I am getting at.
No one ever denied that Reshiram, Dialga, Mewtwo, and Soul Dew Latias and Latios would be overpowered and overcentralizing if they, and they alone were to be moved to the current OU metagame. But just because the Pokémon that are currently Über would be overpowered and overcentralizing if just one, or even a few of them were to be moved to OU, does not mean that any of them would be overpowered or overcentralizing if all of them except for Arceus were to be moved to OU at once, since all of them existing in the same metagame creates a situation such that no particular Pokémon would be significantly more powerful or dominant than most of the other commonly-used Pokémon in the metagame. Once again, read this post to see exactly what I am talking about here.
Basically, imagine that the OU metagame begins with no initial banlist, and then, through suspect testing, things get banned from it over time as they prove themselves to be broken. At the very first instant, with as few things banned as possible when the OU metagame reaches a state in which it is balanced, then suspecting testing and subsequent banning should stop. I believe that an OU metagame that begins with no initial banlist would reach said state of balance after only Arceus is suspect tested and subsequently banned from it.
"If you have a problem with their decisions, then get over there and become good enough to actually make them. It's not exactly hard to get people to listen to you if you make valid points and support them." does not make any sense. There is no causal relationship whatsoever between being good/having valid and supported points and being able to make decisions and be listened to on Smogon, as evident from the fact that, despite possessing a level of skill and knowledge about the Übers metagame far exceeding that of even those who are widely considered to be the best Übers battlers on Smogon, given that I have never lost to Hugendugen or Furai (who are widely regarded to be the joint best Übers battler on Smogon and the runner-up for that title respectively in 2012), and have also reached #1 on eighteen different Generation V Übers ladders across six different servers between Pokémon Online and Pokémon Showdown! (I did not take a screenshot of three of those ladder peaks), all I have ever been met with by the Smogon community is blindness to the truth, having my application for the Smogon Ubers Council disrespectfully deleted by an Administrator for no good reason at all, and being unable to vote even once in all four of the Übers suspect tests so far, despite having gained voting requirements for all of them (well, I actually did vote for the Moody Clause test, but Furai deleted my vote after he later found out who I was).
And judging by the fact that Smogon is a community whose moderators and Administrators are capable of kicking and banning people from their forums, IRC channels and online Pokémon battling simulator servers, as well as deleting people's posts and changing their avatars and signatures while taking away their ability to edit them back for absolutely no reason at all, I would not want to give them any of the wisdom and thus-far secret knowledge about Pokémon that serve as the basis of the Greatness of my Pokémon Mastery anyway.
Um, guys, this person here is ands SASHA the Master are probably two of the greatest Uber players I've ever seen...
Lets not get into some heated arguments here. This thread is meant for exchanging strategies and sets, not bashing each other. Everyone has their own opinions.