The Kalos league was the worst decision they'd made since...uh, the previous league, where he actually regressed from SF to QF, and lost 5-on-6 to an idiot (outrageous, and their worst decision to date). Kalos is a very, very close number 2. So IMO, they've got a lot to do to make up for those two disasters. I feel like when he won Alola that was payback for subjecting me to what happened in the final with Alain, but I have not not yet paid back for Unova; however, GOAshT is coming close to making up for it.
I'm ultimately more interested in the bottom line here - Ash winning loads of matches against very credible opponents like Elite Fours. That's what they should be giving me, again, and again, and again, and again, and again.
Given the choice, I'd prefer Ash wins and every battle is absolutely terrific and has like, Ash/Sawyer levels of animation and execution (Ash/Paul is untouchable as the best battle in the show's history, as it requires years of buildup and characterization that Journeys simply can't match with the time remaining, but there's no doubting that Ash/Sawyer looked and felt incredible in a vacuum).
However, since that's not quite happening - there's been some good battles in JN but nothing to match Ash/Sawyer yet - I guess there's two choices left:
-Ash wins, battles are mediocre and could be better
-Ash loses like always, but at least the battles are amazing
I will always take option 1. I totally respect people who disagree, but to me the scoreboard is what counts here. That's why I guess I'm not that pissed about this battle, because in the end Ash beat an Elite 4, and that's great to me - every win like that is a step towards the writers redeeming themselves for Unova and Kalos.