un-catalouged pokemon?

[comp]

well, this is basically a thread about pokemon trainers have that wer only mentioned in the dub, caught and them forgotten, or otherwise said to have been caught on reliable sources. (though most aren't on serebii.)
here's what there is. (that i know of)
ash: the seaking caught in hook, line, and sinker (never seen again or mentioned, it is possible they were not allowed to keep the seaking)

misty: the seaking also caught in hook, line, and sinker (never seen again or mentioned, it is possible they were not allowed to keep the seaking)

brock: the tauros captured in legend of dratini (brocks has yet to re-appear or be mentioned, it is possible brock was just helping ash catch them)

tracey: dodrio (the trainer index on pokesho seems to think he has one, can anyone confirm this? it is possible pokesho may have confused gary's dodrio for tracey's)

may: swablu (she didn't technically own it, but serebii put manafi in her profile, so..)

jessie: ditto (obtained from mondo in a cd drama, not always considered canon)

richie: eevee (acording to bulbapedia, and has been confirmed here, the dub has him mention having an eevee, but the origonal does not.)

casey: magmar and rapidash (also according to bulbapedia, same deal with richie's eevee. needs confirmation.)

yeah, i think thats it. i mainly made this for both discussion and reference. let me know if there are any others i missed.

 

[CyberCubed]

The Seaking competition did not allow competitors to keep their Pokemon. All the Seaking were returned to the lake when the competition ended, it wasn't their Pokemon.

 

[Ranger Registeel]

You forgot Jackson/Vincent's Yanma...or was that Yoshi/Jimmy...it was one of them....it was dub only

 

[Jolty77]

well, this is basically a thread about pokemon trainers have that wer only mentioned in the dub, caught and them forgotten, or otherwise said to have been caught on reliable sources. (though most aren't on serebii.)
here's what there is. (that i know of)
ash: the seaking caught in hook, line, and sinker (never seen again or mentioned)

misty: the seaking also caught in hook, line, and sinker (never seen again or mentioned)

brock: the tauros captured in legend of dratini (brocks has yet to re-appear or be mentioned)

tracey: dodrio (the trainer index on pokesho seems to think he has one, can anyone confirm this?)

may: swablu (she didn't technically own it, but serebii put manafi in her profile, so..)

james: nincada (bulbapedia once said he had one that was caught in petal burg woods, but was never seen or mentioned, though this has been removed, so it was probably just wiki-garbage. needs confirming)

jessie: ditto (obtained from mondo in a cd drama, not always considered canon)

richie: eevee (acording to bulbapedia, and has been confirmed here, the dub has him mention having an eevee, but the origonal does not.)

casey: magmar (also according to bulbapedia, same deal with richie's eevee. the article mentioned something else, too, but i forgot what it was, i'll go check that out. needs confirmation.)

yeah, i think thats it. i mainly made this for both discussion and reference. let me know if there are any others i missed.

On her Chronicle episode about the Electabuzz she mentions that and I think Rapidash.

 

[Chris]

ash: the seaking caught in hook, line, and sinker (never seen again or mentioned)

misty: the seaking also caught in hook, line, and sinker (never seen again or mentioned)

They weren't allowed to keep them.

brock: the tauros captured in legend of dratini (brocks has yet to re-appear or be mentioned)

Biggest misconception people have due to them not actually understanding Japanese. SATOSHI was the one participating. Not Takeshi or Kasumi. They simply helped him out. Because there was a herd of Kentaros, Satoshi could not capture them by himself. Takeshi helped out while Kasumi did the fishing due to it being her specialty.

tracey: dodrio (the trainer index on pokesho seems to think he has one, can anyone confirm this?)

Have not heard of anything of the sort.

may: swablu (she didn't technically own it, but serebii put manafi in her profile, so..)

She only took care of it. She did not hatch it from an egg, she barely raised it as well.

james: nincada (bulbapedia once said he had one that was caught in petal burg woods, but was never seen or mentioned, though this has been removed, so it was probably just wiki-garbage. needs confirming)

False information. Sabonea was his first and only Houen capture at the time.

jessie: ditto (obtained from mondo in a cd drama, not always considered canon)

Because CD dramas tend to be side stories to explain things that occur, they're usually not canon and are simply seen as just explanatory stories. Just like how Musashi's mother is never brought up in the actual anime.

richie: eevee (acording to bulbapedia, and has been confirmed here, the dub has him mention having an eevee, but the origonal does not.)

This is 4Kids pulling crap out of their asses as he NEVER had one in the original, nor was he going to see Orchid for that reason.

casey: magmar (also according to bulbapedia, same deal with richie's eevee. the article mentioned something else, too, but i forgot what it was, i'll go check that out. needs confirmation.)

Watch the episodes rather than relying on Bulbapedia, which had to close off public access because of so much false information being placed it.

You forgot Jackson/Vincent's Yanma...or was that Yoshi/Jimmy...it was one of them....it was dub only

He never had one, nor did the dub mention it. The fansubbers claimed he sent a Yanyanma to give Marina mail, when she really said that he actually called her to let her know when he'd find swarms of Yanyanma around (similar to how trainers called you when groups of the rarer Pokemon were around).

 

[comp]

does anone have proof that they were not allowed to keep the seaking? a qoute? besides, the did still catch them, so i'm still leaving them on.

ok, i'll put th tauros thing on the top post. there's no proof, (unless, once again, i can get a qoute) but misty does fish in that ep, so i'll beleive you.

with tracey's dodrio, i think pokesho may have just confused it with gary's dodrio in the aerodactyl crhonicle, so i'll put that up there.

i know she only took care of it, but manafi is on her profile, so i felt like mentioning it.

thank you, i figured it was, i'll take jame's nincada off.

i know cd drama's aren't canon, that's why i stated that.

i'm aware richie does not have eevee, but it's staying up there.

i would watch, the actual eps, though i don't know if you tube has them. and yes, the other pokemon was rapidash, thank you.

i'm not adding vincent's yanma.

 

[Chris]

I've already told you that Kentaros was caught FOR Satoshi. Might I also add that he's got 30 of them. 30 being the amount of Safari Balls a person is given in the Safari Zone.

Eevee can NOT be counted since we never see it and it does NOT exist in Hiroshi's team.

 

[HoennMaster]

Tracey never mentioned having a Dodrio and James never mentioned or captured a Nincada.

 

[Gravy]

does anone have proof that they were not allowed to keep the seaking?

Surely the fact it's never seen or heard of ever again is proof enough?

Tracey was seen observing a herd of Tauros from a distance whilst riding on a Dodrio in some flashback. I think it was seen during the episode 'The Lost Lapras', during a segment in which either himself or Nurse Joy explained what a Pokémon Watcher actually does.
Of course, considering we never see this Dodrio outside of a still frame that's on screen for little more than 5 or so seconds, it's safe to assume that it was never his to begin with, and was more than likely loaned to him by some trainer or whatever. Lookit me state the obvious.

 

[comp]

I've already told you that Kentaros was caught FOR Satoshi. Might I also add that he's got 30 of them. 30 being the amount of Safari Balls a person is given in the Safari Zone.

Eevee can NOT be counted since we never see it and it does NOT exist in Hiroshi's team.

i will add i put that up there, i know he was catching it for ash, but it was still him who caught it.
i know eevee does not exist, that's why it's up there.
the fact the seaking is never heard of agian is not proof, as that doesn't neccesarily mean they were not allowed to keep them.
thank you for trhe info on tracey's dodrio, i'll put that up there.