And well about the World Tournament, to be completely honest I don't think it contributes too much to the overall plot of B2W2. I think the reason everyone wants the PWT is because they want a dexholder reunion. But in my opinion, I don't think a dexholder reunion would make much sense after Generation IV.
As we know, Kusaka likes to emulate the gameplay of the series in the manga. The World Tournament is obligatory to proceed in the story in the games. I know you only fight Hue, Cheren and Achroma (Corless) in the main story, but the main point of the World Tournament is the crossover. Even the anime is/will be doing this. Not putting the World Tournament in the manga would be unusual of him (I think), and putting the World Tournament without a reunion would be
unexcusable.
It would get WAY too repetitive and Generation V is the perfect place to stop dexholder reunions because it was supposed to be a "fresh new start". The Generation I dexholders are adults at that point, and I think displaying the seniors as adults would sorta ruin the earlier chapters. If the dexholders are in their 20's then I think that's the age point where some of them start to realize their feelings for each other and become couples...and this manga is not centered around shipping so that again would ruin the earlier chapters.
From what I heard, Gen III was also advertised as a "fresh new start", and look at what we got. Plus, it's not like they need to focus so much on the shipping, they could just put a single mention about it and nothing more. It's not like this manga has never had shipping/ship-tease before. Look:
-Iris teased Black about White (can't remember which month, but it's somewhere in the forum).
-Ruby and Sapphire are
literally that, and that thing about Ruby's amnesia after the final battle (you know, about him forgetting Sapphire's confession)
NEEDS to be solved at some point.
-Red and Yellow had their pinkies connected by that wire in the end of the Yellow arc.
Though the last one is a
very subtle hint/nuance of Kusaka's part, and you need to know Japanese culture to understand. Just in case you don't know I will explain, in Japan it's said that soulmates have their pinkies connected by a red wire. This legend comes from the fact that there's an artery connecting the pinky to the heart. During the Meiji era (I think), some women cut their pinkies off and gave them to men as a promise of eternal love.
But again, a dexholder reunion is not the point. The point I'm trying to make is how will Sird appearing in the PWT tie in with the plot that's going on at the current time? The plot at the time will probably be about neo-Team Plasma and Ghetsis's desire to freeze over Unova with Kyurem's forms. The only way to tie Sird in to the PWT is if Kusaka uses her desire for Pokedexes to tie her in to the PWT and even then there are a few flaws with that: first, that is an ENTIRELY different plot than the neo-Team Plasma and the Plasma plot is definitely a better plot there as that is the thing going on in the games and the manga's job is to advertise the games anyway.
Well, Achroma participates in the World Tournament in the games. Does the game explain his reasons for this? If not, Kusaka can create a reason there.
There are great new villains in the new Generation V so why on earth should Kusaka keep a decade-old washed up villain like Sird when he could be doing so much better with newer villains from Team Plasma? The only instances where a villain from several chapters ago reappears is when the game version of that chapter has that villain and even then, the villain isn't even evil at that point (or at least playing the role of the main antagonist). Giovanni's intentions in FRLG were anything but evil as he was trying to find his long-lost son and see him one last time before he dies (so I guess his role there is an anti-villain?) and Lance (and Pryce now) are not playing the roles of villains in the current HGSS chapter. Sird isn't even a character in the games so there is little to no reason to have her in B2W2 or any future chapter. It's been said by several posters in the earlier part of this thread but I'll say it again: why keep old washed-up Sird when there are great new villains and plots to utilize from here on out? In my opinion, I would actually have the whole Sird plot ditched and left inconclusive rather than have her appear in any chapter beyond Generation IV.
The same thing could be said for Platinum arc. Why use Saque there when there's Team Galactic? Also, your statement about villains only reappearing in new arcs when they appear in the game version is false, Sakaki (Giovanni) appeared at the end of R/S arc.
Yeah tbt if Volume 43 is really ending HGSS (and if BW is really a part of it meaning the volume is not even all HGSS) then sadly I don't see a full-on plot of Sird's final battle and defeat. I have to disagree on your Platinum claim though. I don't really see Sird taking over for Galactic. If my theory is true, then Sird wouldn't have had anything more to do with Galactic which is why she left. And Platinum was three volumes, just like all non-main version pair chapters which all have three or four volumes so I don't think it was rushed.
Dude, Kusaka has to deal with multiple arcs at the same time,
of course the non-main pair arcs are rushed. Specially in Generation IV, as HGSS
hadn't even started when the BW games were going to be released.
Well, at this point if there really are a few rounds left for HGSS then I have to conclude that maybe Sird was never meant to have some ultimate showdown. (and I don't see her appearance in Gen V as a possibility) Maybe she was behind the Rocket general's Arceus plot but her real intent was to use the legendaries to open up a portal to a dimension where she was really from, just locked out after some chaos that blew her out. And so she wanted the legendaries to go back to her home dimension which was her real reason for joining Galactic and wanting the Creation trio. If something like that happens, then it wouldn't take up too much rounds. I know this is one of the most corniest ending to a villain in manga history and it would bring on the full-scale rage of fans but if Kusaka wishes to end Sird in the little time he has left (and again, Sird has no place in any future chapters) then a corny ending where Sird turns out to not be evil after all and doesn't need to be killed to have her story wrapped up is the only way to end her. But then again, it's Kusaka who can come up with anything to satisfy his fans.
Interesting theory. If this were
Digimon, it could happen, as they have Millenniumon (and it's Evolutions), Chronmon, and Quartzmon. But this is
Pokémon, a franchise that
doesn't care about the multiverse. While the anime, games, and multiple manga would count as separte universes, composing a multiverse, the franchise itself
doesn't care about this, as the main series games,
the main canon, all happen in the same universe. Although, theoretically, Dialga and Palkia's combined powers could open doors to other universes, I don't see them this ever being used unless they decide to make a crossover with nother monster franchise.
And what's more, an appearance in HGSS would tie in with all the other seemingly irrelevant appearances in the past. And okay, I'm not Kusaka so I have no idea how this Sird plot will turn out until it does. But what I'm saying is, and it looks like you agree with me based on your last statement, is that Sird has absolutely NO place in the Gen V plot. How on earth will Kusaka tie her in with Plasma? I guess her obsession with the Pokedex will lead her to the PWT but like I said before, that is not relevant to the plot that Kusaka should, and probably will, feature at the time. I highly doubt there will be two separate plots for B2W2 since it wouldn't work out and it is definitely unneeded. All I'm saying is, based on Kusaka's past actions and previous events in the manga, it is not out of his style to do what I'm theorizing. There are still several plotholes left by Sird and the last opportunity to wrap them up is the HGSS chapter. Unless, of course, you count the Red chapter (is it a chapter or a round?)
You could say the same about Generation IV. The only hint of a connection was a character's unfinished line in the end of the last of a Generation. HGSS still hasn't finished, so they could hint a connection in the end of HGSS's final chapter, like they did in Emerald.
About how they will connect her with Team Plasma: N? Masuda explicitly said N's parents are unknown, and I don't think they will ever be brought up in the games, so Kusaka could use this and say Saque is his mother. Just a wild guess, but the only other possibility I can think of right now would be that she's Achroma's sister, but I still haven't read the arcs (I'm still in GSC and I don't have much time to read them), so I'm not an expert in the manga.