which game should I buy?

[PDL]

alright, there are 3 games which I really want to by, the problem is that I can currently only get 1 at this time.

1. Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door

Pros:
-really fun game
-rented alot

Cons:
-played so much that my current game is 98% complete, I only need to finish the last 10 levels of the Pit of 100 trials and kill Bonetail

2. Pokemon XD

Pros:
-fun
-rented only once

Cons:
-I'd only really want it for Lugia
-I've already used most of the pokemon the game offers

3. Legend of Zelda: the Twilight Princess

Pros:
-regarded as the greatest thing since sliced bread

Cons:
-not out yet D:

so? which one would be best right now?

 

[MaskedManAbsolkid]

Not Zelda, get it when it comes out. Are you bored with Paper mario? Of so, Pokemon XD. If not, Paper Mario.

 

[Joe]

Paper Mario is the best of the 2 out now, but if you've completed it, get Pokemon XD.

 

[Kasaioni]

Zelda, if you like a really challeging game ^^

 

[Puffs]

Zelda, I'm saving for it myself.

But the other ones, either's fine. You could buy XD, and rent Paper Mario again and beat it.

 

[Chris]

Which game you should buy? Zelda. Just rent Paper Mario to complete what little % you have left. Rent XD just to get Lugia. o_o Plus you're given time to save up for Zelda, what with the delays.

 

[Kabuto]

Surely you can manage to save 50 bucks to get Twilight Princess after you purchase a game. If, not wait for TP because it'll be the best game ever. Out of those two, I'd probably go with Mario unless I wanted rare pokemon from XD.

 

[Orion-Sama]

If you can wait for a while, stand still until Zelda is released.

If you want a game now... I'd say XD. Unless Paper Mario has some other side quest after you're done with it, XD will provide a bit more benefits overall. No need to tell you anything else. You should know which benefits I'm talking about.

In your situation, I'd wait for Zelda unless you need a game now...

 

[MidnightScott]

Rent Paper Mario

Pokémon XD is worth it and is already out.

I'm sure you can manage to get $50 by the time Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess comes out...April 1st

~Scott;229;

 

[Zerodius]

Paper Mario 2 hammer Pokemon XD into the ground on every level. It is quite simple: I consider it one of the best RPGs ever.

Truly, get this game. Unless you are one of those players that beat one game and then never replay them again (SHAME ON YOU!), Paper Mario 2 will reveal itself to be FAR better than Pokemon XD.

As for Zelda Twilight Princess... well, you said it yourself: not out yet.

If you want a game now, get Paper Mario 2.

Pokemon XD is a mediocre upgrade to a not-so-great Pokemon game. It just cannot compete with Paper Mario 2.

NOTE about Paper Mario 2: If you have beaten the game already... then you have already overcame the biggest challenge the game has to offer. Bonetail is actually easier than the last bosses ; what is hard is getting to him in one piece since the last ten floors are rock hard, each floor offering battles that could pretty well qualify as boss fights (read: enemies with upward of 15 HPs, with upward of 5 attack, and that got defense points to boot). If you can beat those floors, Bonetail shouldn't pose you any problems ; he is far too slow, predictable, and actually dish out LESS damage than the final boss each turn (he only attack once unlike the final boss who attacked three times per turn).

 

[Chris]

Note how he stated he's almost finished with Paper Mario and that his only interest in XD is in getting Lugia. Simply a waste of money there to get either one at those points.

 

[MidnightScott]

Well oh well - 'tis true - considering I didnt even have to pay for XD, I won it along with a Platinum GC in a Contest at the dead site Pokédream.

Buy some DS Games then and manage to save $50 for TP ^_^

~Scott;229;

 

[El Cool]

Save up for Zelda, rent Paper Mario to complete what little you have left to do and rent XD and nab Lugia off the disc.

 

[Prelude]

Don't really care if you rent, but save your stuff for Twilight Princess...not as good as sliced bread, but it is gonna be a pretty cool game...if you've seen the trailers, then you'll want it.