1. We have moved to a new forum system. All your posts and data should have transferred over. Welcome, to the new Serebii Forums. Details here
    Dismiss Notice
  2. Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
    Dismiss Notice
  3. If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders
    Dismiss Notice

Which Generation is Better?

Discussion in 'Poképolls' started by pkmn Trainer Ruby, Mar 23, 2008.

  1. pkmn Trainer Ruby

    pkmn Trainer Ruby NAME CHANGE PLZ!

    Which Generation do you perfer:

    1st Gen(Red Blue Green Yellow)

    2nd Gen(Gold Silver Crystal)

    3rd Gen(Ruby Sapphire Emerald)

    4th Gen(Diamond Pearl)

    My personal fave is EMERALD, the 3rd gen
  2. Warfare

    Warfare liverliverliverliver

    I personally like the third generation.
  3. stu770

    stu770 Soul Trainer

    I really liked the second generation because you get to go back to a previous region.
  4. Narutopokedude

    Narutopokedude ← currently hunting

    I really like Crysatl, and emerald version, also Diamond o_O

    I'm going to go with 2nd gen because in Crystal you could go to kanto and johto :D
  5. Dark Arceus

    Dark Arceus Worst. Name. Ever.

    2nd Gen forever FTW.
  6. Highor

    Highor Well-Known Member

    I like third generation, because you have the remakes and yet another new region. And R/S/E/FR/LG brought to us the best graphics upgrade, since G/S/C is just painting the old ones, and D/P seems to me a bigger R/S/E/FR/LG only.
  7. Emperor Time

    Emperor Time Well-Known Member

    At the moment it would have to be the third generation.
  8. Meg Is Hoenn's Champ

    Meg Is Hoenn's Champ Meg Is Hoenn's Champ

    I personally prefer Pokemon from all of the generations except for Pokemon D/P,To me the Pokemon started looking a bit weird and more based on aliens then mythical creatures or animals...If I had to choose just one I would choose the 3 Gen though.
  9. Krug

    Krug .

    Kanto! Awesome, just awesome, with Blastoise, Mewtwo, and Magmar. Don't forget Missingno.! Can't forget Missingno.
  10. EmeraldLeafBlade

    EmeraldLeafBlade Well-Known Member

    Generation four, defiantly. The games are the best in my opinion. You could go to Kanto in gen 2, but it was way too easy. There's also a wi-fi in D/P, which gives playing after the E4 an actual point.

  11. intergalactic platypus

    intergalactic platypus Only rescues maidens

    Honestly, the only games I really didn't like were R/S/E. But I loved G/S/C so 2nd gen it is
  12. Chibbichan

    Chibbichan i eated a butter...

    1st gen all the way. Classic Pokemon. But 4th gen is also good because we go back to 1st gen as well as 4th gen.
  13. ironknight42

    ironknight42 Well-Known Member

    2nd gen just for old times sake and the 4th gen wasn't bad at all
  14. Drake Pokétrainer

    Drake Pokétrainer Blood of Insanity

    I kinda like them all. But I think I like the 1st and the 2nd the most.
    Well I started with blue so the 1st has always been there. And the 2nd was in the golden age when things improved a lot.
  15. 2nd gen for Johto AND Kanto, and also Meganium.

    3rd gen isn't bad either, with FRLG. I'm nota big fan of Hoenn, though. And I'm not a giant Gen 4 fan because I don't have a DS anyway and it makes me jealous...*sob*
  16. Mr. Mudkip

    Mr. Mudkip Banned

    3rd gen was and will always be the best.
  17. trapezechimpanz

    trapezechimpanz Well-Known Member

    It depends on how you are looking at it. From a graphics and gameplay point of view - it would be either Fourth Generation, or Third Generation. If you are looking at originality, and design First Generation and Second Generation win.

    In my opinion, First Generation is the best. It was original had a nice story, and all the Pokemon in it were spectacular - a lot of my favorites come from there. Second Generation is my all time favorite of the games, but First wins in "best" due the fact of it being amazing all around.
  18. RagTag

    RagTag Shroomin'

    2nd gen hands down
  19. Krug

    Krug .

    Oh yeah, also look at the rivals in each game, in 1st and 2nd, you didn't have those namby pamby rivals you get now. Though our red haired friend from G/S/C didn't keep his personality all the way, he could still be considered mostly a bad person. Gary (Gen. 1) was just sadistic, there were no lessons learned just a guy who wants to beat and make fun of you. He made jokes about death in a graveyard! A GRAVEYARD! Thats how your rival should be not some goody two shoes who gives gifts! I want the sadisticness!
  20. Sprock

    Sprock Well-Known Member

    probably the 1st gen, though the 4th gen was pretty close to matching it.

    2nd gen was the worst imo quality-wise. johto was a boring region, and kanto was totally watered down. I take quality over quantity, thank you.

Share This Page