Which of the Pokemon DS games interface did you like best?

[Azureth]

Out of D/P/Pt, HG/SS, B&W and for those who've played it B&W2 which menu interface did you like best?

For me, I really enjoyed B&W. It was easy to navigate and awesome to use.

 

[the3rdH0kage]

Personally I liked always having the Start/X menu always up and just being a tap away from it instead of having to push a button.

 

[Serebii!]

I like HGSS and BW. Is BW2 different to BW?

 

[Dragalge]

BW2 was nice and the mountain wasn't really hard as I thought.

 

[Kalosian]

Definitely BW for me. I like how fast everything flows in the menus compared to D/P/P and HG/SS, I also find the touch screen use much faster and more solid than in HG/SS. I also love the red cross which makes it possible to exit the menu directly no matter what you are doing.

 

[☭Secret_Shocker☭]

ooh BW2. Though I don't have it yet, I know it's 1000x better than BW.

 

[aaron-now]

HGSS. Touch screen based everything. Though I do like the ability to have a large number of quick select items in BW/2. Also the save screen. But yeah, HGSS still take the cake.
Not sure what people are talking about with BW speed though. It wasn't that smooth of a transition from menu to menu.

 

[Ausgirl]

HGSS was nicely organized but a bit slow to use. It's still my favorite though.

 

[(P.O.K.E.M.O.N)]

hg/ss without a doubt, the lack of touchscreen features on bw is quite sad

 

[shinymankey]

I don't own any Gen 5 Games so out of the two choices left, I'm going to with with HG/SS

 

[RealRaymon]

HG / SS, it was easy to navigate

 

[MapleKnight]

I personally likes the interface of HG/SS the most, but then again, I havent played Black/White 2 yet.

 

[EnragedSwalot]

I liked HeartGold and SoulSilver best. I really loved the touch screen controls for the game, and the fact that you could press a button to run. IMO, it was the easiest to navigate.

 

[flyer1228]

I like D/P because those are the ones I own. I feel that BW had a lot of extra movements and I disliked when you fought it would take so much time to portray a move. There were a lot of unused/extra Pokemon in BW too.

 

[Poetry]

I don't like B/W's bag system - there weren't enough pockets and didn't like having my Pokeballs mixing with my stones and repels. Also it was just awkward to navigate and find things imo.
HG/SS all the way for me.

 

[RainDance]

HG/SS definitely. I loved the touch screen.

 

[Izanagi]

I voted for DPPt mostly because the Poketch was quite handy at times more often than not. I will take it over the C-Gear anyday.

 

[Blivsey]

The interface? HG/SS hands-down. Having instant access to the full menu and two shortcut items, as well as a perma-run option and generally being able to operate everything through the touch screen made HG/SS easily the most user-friendly games. The Pokétch was a bit of a novelty and the C-Gear is only occasionally useful at best for most players - neither needed to take up the entire bottom screen all the time.

Of course, I haven't played B2/W2 yet, but their interface looks like it's going to be roughly the same as B/W, so I doubt that it can overtake HG/SS for me.

 

[DeadLion]

HG/SS - A nice throwback to the days of playing pokemon with one hand

 

[Cutty]

Even though it's faster, but B/W version put the pokeballs together with items. I prefer HG/SS one.