Which pokemon shouldnt be legendary

["L"]

Like the title says, discuss which pokemon you think shouldnt be legendary.

For me its gotta be Fione and Mewtwo. Fione is the child of a legendary, and is able to breed to make more of itself, so I think it should not be legendary, maybe a pseudo legendary, and as for mewtwo he is a genetically modified clone of mew. He is man made. He should be a pseudo legendary too.

if ya dont know pseuso means false

 

[Team Elecwater]

yeah i agree with fione but Mewtwo is one of a kind and that's usually what also makes a legendary so i disagree for mewtwo. How does a legendary have a baby (manaphy)?!

 

[water_pkmn_fan]

Fione and Sheima(don't know how to spell) Fione is a child of Manaphy so no. Sheima because it just doesn't look legendary material.

 

["L"]

Well if the scientists really wanted to they can always clone more of mewtwo. Mewtwo to me is like a way more powerful Porygon. A creature created by humans

 

[Team Elecwater]

heh why would they want to make more of mewtwo that thing likes to kill people according to some games

 

["L"]

Mewtwo is just a misunderstood soul brought to this world with no purpose, and no one who cared for him....
I'm surprised Mr. Fuji was involved in creating mewtwo (according to the things I read in the mansion and people I talked to in cinabar, and he was the one who saw mew)

Yeah I couldnt believe Sheimi was a legendary, damned that hedgehog!

 

["L"]

Deoxys shouldnt be considered legendary either. Its a space virus from a meteor that was mutated by a lazer. Who knows how many other spaceviruses there are in the poke universe that can end up being a deoxys. I think it should only be classified as Uber, not Uber Legendary.

Hiidoran (steel/Fire legendary) Shold also not be considered legendary, yeah sure it is one off that cant breed, but it has a 50 50 chance of being male or female. I think that there is just a small population of hiidoran on Hard mountain or wherever it is found. I guess in Japan it would be classified as illusionary(like the legendary birds) since it is so rarely seen people mistake it as legendary

 

[miiche~]

I think all the legendary pokemon should stay

especially sheimi, which everyone seems to dislike.
People seem to associate legendaries with being godly.
What about just being like fairy tales? Why can't sheimi just be a cute little garden fairy?

 

["L"]

I dont remember where I read this but I think Japan classifies them as legendary and illusionary

Legendary-Pokemon based on legends
Illusionary-Pokemon so rarely seen people dont believe they exist

It would be easier if we classified them as this so people wont complain at why some pokemon are legendary

Edit: Ha found the legendary/illusionary thing herehttp://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Legendary_Pok%C3%A9mon

 

[Silver Mew]

Fione is a legendary. Like in the Anime episodes, Lugia had a child. So why can't Manaphy have one? Mewtwo is a legendary, because like I said-^ Mewtwo is alike Mew. A hair from Mew made him.

 

["L"]

Yeah but thats anime wise, in game wise legendaries cant have babies and mass produce, Fione can breed in the game and it can mass produce.

Manaphy is just lucky his offspring cant evolve into him or else he would be on my list. Fione is also in the event only section cause he is the child of manaphy

Besides this is a thread to talk about pokemon you think shouldnt be a legendary

 

[Blackjack Gabbiani]

I think the difference there is if it would breed when a human wanted it to, versus out in the wild.

 

["L"]

So? Humans might want to breed ho oh but that'll never happen

 

[random guy]

i dont think sheimi should be legendary and i dont think darkrai should either because it doesnt look legendary it just looks like a normal ghost type

 

[Rai+]

The hedgehog's fine. It probably holds some hidden, magical secret or something. Maybe it can inflict hayfever on its enemies, I dunno...

Now, Areusus shouldn't be. It's said to be a 'God' pokémon right? That's way powerful, it annoys me. Yeah, in that respect it should be a legendary, but why the creators decided to make it - I don't know.

 

["L"]

Yeah Darkrai could just be the last of its kind and it was trapped in a statue. But doesnt arcticuno look like a normal bird pokemon

 

[The guy from Pireas]

Fione and Sheimi.

 

[Francesc]

Mew. It have good stats, but it's not the strongest, either.

 

[Gilgamesh]

If Mewtwo shouldn't be legendary, neither should the regis, as they are manmade aswell.

 

[Kabudoom]

Areusus, as mentioned before, is a Pokemon God. Way too powerful, and I honestly don't think the powers of a god should be handled by a trainer (but that would defeat the purpose of "Gotta Catch'em All").

There are too many psychic Legendaries, fight amung yourselves on who should be cut (Mew shall forever stay, end of discussion).

Moltres and Ho-oh...this game isn't big enough to have two fire/flying pokemon. They are both Pheonix like, so I say keep Ho-oh.

I honestly don't like many of the new legendaries coming out for D/P, but once I read about their info and whatnot, I'll give my opinions on them (Areusus is an exception....since we already know he's a god, and way to powerful to be captured...eventhough it most likely will be).

Once the creators of Pokemon say "This pokemon can not be captured", many fans will be in an uproar and demand some kind of special event. Then you may ask "What's the purpose of an un-captured pokemon?" Maybe it could add into the plot of the storyline.

If Mewtwo shouldn't be legendary, neither should the regis, as they are manmade aswell.

Really? I did not know that. Well add them, Mewtwo, Porygon, and Ditto into the mix (I honestly wouldn't be surprized if Voltorb/Electrode and Magnemite/Magneton are also man-made).