• Hi all. We have had reports of member's signatures being edited to include malicious content. You can rest assured this wasn't done by staff and we can find no indication that the forums themselves have been compromised.

    However, remember to keep your passwords secure. If you use similar logins on multiple sites, people and even bots may be able to access your account.

    We always recommend using unique passwords and enable two-factor authentication if possible. Make sure you are secure.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Which set of starter pokemon you like best?

Which generation of starter Pokemon do you like best?


  • Total voters
    21

Meowth! That's right!

Cat Pokemon Trainer
I still think after 4 generations of starter pokemon... that none are better than the original Squirtle, Bulbasaur and Charmander.

Which do you like best?

1st gen. Bulbasaur ;001; Charmander ;004; and Squirtle ;007;

2nd gen. Chikorita ;152; Cyndaquil ;155; and Totodile ;158;

3rd gen. Treecko ;252; Torchic ;255; and Mudkip ;258;

4th gen. Naetle ;387; Hikozaru ;390; and Pochama ;393;
 

Mse Ownage

Ur Going Down!
first generation all stuff of the first gen for me so im choosing that 1
 
Shinou Starters are the ONLY Set of Starters where I actually like all 3 final forms, and 2 are favorites. The other 3 sets? Only 1 favorite line... :)

So yes. Shinou. Genbu, Goku and... Enpetoru. They're unbeatable. :D

Johto's come in a close second, though.
 

Rainbow★Latias

Better than before!
3rd gen. 2nd gen is close
 

AJ Flibble

Emohawk
Johto's close, but Shinou wins.

Dodiatoise is the coolest starter ever IMO, and I'm warming to the monkey too now.
 

Gravy

Contaminated KFC
I like Kanto because the original is always best. This is the most logical argument in history and is the backbone of modern society as we know it. Therefore, anything that isn't a generic turtle or lizard sucks major booty, and should be frowned upon until all our faces are forced into an eternal expression of discontent.

Charmander >>>>> Flaming butt monkey.

Also, primates suck, for absolutely no reason at all.
 

Juputoru

M-m-m-m-onobear?!
Kanto's nice and all, but the starters aren't all that interesting. Especially the Squirtle line. I *like* Charmeleon, Charizard, Bulbasaur, and Ivysaur, but the first two aren't all that creative(generic lizard/dragon with flame on its tail) and the last two are a tad more creative(badass frog with a plant on its back) but nothing special.
Johto maintains a fairly uniform level of design goodness throughout, although nothing other than the Totodile line and Quilava stand out to me a great deal.
Houen...come on. I'm sure most of you know my opinion on the Treecko line, the Torchic line's good(Torchic being decent, Combusken being great, and Blaziken being fugly), and the Mudkip line's cute for two stages and cool in an ugly way for the last stage.
Shinou...I like the first and last stages of the Naetle line(the first stage mostly due to the anime >>) although I could do without the bore of the second stage; the Hikozaru line's nice and all, but Hikozaru's boring(flaming butt aside), Moukazaru's Charmeleon only a monkey(basically a generic monkey with a flame on its tail, which would be cool if they hadn't DONE IT BEFORE only with a different animal), and Goukazaru looks ugly as sin in sprite form, but it's actually pretty cool in the Sugimori art(why it took the line that long to reach a form that's at all appealing to me, I'll never figure out. I mean, how hard is it to dissapoint with two fire monkey Pokemon?); and the Pocchama line's just awesome. They're cute, decently cool, and fecking awesome. In that order.

Really, I'm torn between Johto and Houen. Mostly because they're consistant with how good the starters and their evos are. I'm sure my opinions of the Shinou starters will mellow out over time and they'll join their previous gen counterparts in that catagory, but for now...
 

Turtloopa

Nintendo!
1st gen, with 3rd close second. Then the 4th and last and least, the 3nd gen. Only problem with 1st gen is charisard (Doesn't deserve even capital letter or z :p). TOO OVERUSED. I heard I leik mudkips
 

Gold_Generation

Johto Champion
Johto have the best pokemon anyway so it is obviously johto who have the best starters. Johto also has the best legendaries, johto is so awesome i am surprised they haven't made a remake just for the sake of getting fans to buy it again (they would make a fortune). 2ND GEN RULE!

Goukazaru looks ugly as sin in sprite form, but it's actually pretty cool in the Sugimori art

I thought that about the final grass evo of shinou (can't remember name). Its sprite does it no favours, but the art makes it look super cool.
 
Last edited:

Alkaide

Scary Faerie♥
I like hoenn and shinou the best. I like all the kanto starters except Charmander. I really don't like charmander, but I love venasaur and blastoise, that is why I like 3rd and 4th gen better. I really like the jhoto region in general, but I hate the starters.
 
Last edited:

Volteon

Back I guess??
IMO...
Shinou >= Jotho > Hoenn > Kanto

Excluding the monkey, Shinou has the most creative last evolutions, in every other gen the starters are just bigger with some added details compared to their last evolutions. Jotho is close second because they got great personalities in anime. Jolly Totodyle is awesome ^^ My favorite starter I guess, Cyndaquil and Pocchama: close second.
Hoenn.. they are cool and powerful but there´s something on them that makes me dislike compared to others ;_; But I like them too ^^ A LOT!
As for Kanto.... ¬_¬ They´re weak and uncreative IMO, the only interesting one for me is Venusaur.
 
hard decision not 1st gen but typhlosion has been a natural fav and 3rd gens final evos are awesome but 4th gen takes the cake
Kanto
;004;;;007; ;001;
;008; ;002;;005;
;003;;006; ;009;
Johto
;155; ;152;;158;
;153; ;156;;159; ;manaphyegg;
;154;;160;;157;
Hoenn
;259; ;255;;252; whose egg is this?
;258; ;256;;253;
;257; ;254;;260;
Shinou
;390; ;387;;393;
;388; ;394;;391;
;389; ;395; ;392;
 
Top