Which would you choose?

[Dramatic Melody]

A Shiny pokemon with a bad (hindering) nature...

OR

A Not shiny pokemon with a good nature...

I'm choosing the former...because I'm desperate to have a Shiny

 

[AJ Flibble]

The latter. I don't care about shinies.

 

[Deathskully]

The latter. I don't care about shinies.

Yeah, just what I would say. I don't really care about shinies that much.

 

[Kalosian]

I don't like shineys, so would choose the one with good nature instead.

 

[Mimori Kiryu]

I don't really care about the shiny or the nature, IMO. But if it was a nature that I wanted or was searching for, well obviously, no shiny and a good nature.

 

[Shiney_Hunter_Tauros_Rule]

Shiny with bad nature
My Tauros had the best nature of all my shinies (Adament) but my sister erased them on purpose

 

[taitofan]

Shiny with bad. But only because I don't own a single shiny and I want one... >.>

 

[Tropical Spirit]

Shiny with bad. Why? Because I can breed a good natured pokemon later with an everstone Ditto. >_>;

 

[Blaze Dragon]

Shiny with bad nature. I´m a shiny hunter, not a nature perfecter (I have 14 shinys by now, I had another one, but it crashed)

 

[Divine_Light]

I don't care about natures nor shiney pokemon so Non shiney Pokemon with good nature is my choice

 

[Volteon]

All the shinies I have have a good nature (Adamant Tentacool and I don´t remember Rapidash´s, but I know it´s good for it), but I hate them both.
So I´d prefer a shining pokémon I LIKE with a bad nature than a shining pokémon I hate with a good nature.

But a shining pkémon I like with good IVs and nature is always wanted

Also good natures for a normal pokémon we can always do with emerald´s everstone.

 

[jellsprout]

Shiny with bad nature.

IIRC, there are about 30 natures. A one in thirty chance of getting the correct nature is a whole lot higher than the the 1 in 6000, or something like that, chance to get a shiny.

 

[Vycksta]

*jumps on the "don't care about Natures or shiny Pokemon" bandwagon*

But if I had to pick... shiny with bad, for the exact reason that jellsprout put. Besides, nothing can be worse than my Adamant natured Gardevoir.

 

[/Exiled/]

shinyness dosent matter. I just use them as trade bait.

 

[Dramatic Melody]

Wow, it's a close fight

 

[♥Princess Ketchum♥]

I Would choose either but a good shiny pokemon

 

[Komedic Konservationist]

Natures mean absolutely nothing to me whatsoever; whereas a shiny would be lovely. So naturally, I chose the top option.

 

[MagmaEmperor]

Shiny with bad nature

Cause then i can breed it then get a good nature

Plus i dont care about nature

 

[Chancellor Hivemind.]

Basicly what Komedic Konservationist said.