• Hi all. We have had reports of member's signatures being edited to include malicious content. You can rest assured this wasn't done by staff and we can find no indication that the forums themselves have been compromised.

    However, remember to keep your passwords secure. If you use similar logins on multiple sites, people and even bots may be able to access your account.

    We always recommend using unique passwords and enable two-factor authentication if possible. Make sure you are secure.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Why did the writers remove Misty?

How do you feel about the writers choice about removing Misty?


  • Total voters
    203
Status
Not open for further replies.
E

Ethereal

Guest
No. She AIN'T returning. There's NOTHING she could do anymore that wasn't done in the past. Plus, they already have two main characters in Ash and May. Why would they add a third and make the show ridiculously cluttered?

Plus, there was already a "big Water Pokemon thing" with Kyogre. She didn't come back fer that. Yer logic fails. 8^)
 
G

General Koffing

Guest
I meant like a Water Pokemon league or something. I don't want to argue with you, as I think you're cool, and I don't want you to hate me. All I'm saying is that we shouldn't rule out the possibility.
 
E

Ethereal

Guest
General Koffing said:
I meant like a Water Pokemon league or something. I don't want to argue with you, as I think you're cool, and I don't want you to hate me. All I'm saying is that we shouldn't rule out the possibility.
Uh...I don't hate anyone. I wish people would quit saying sh*t like that to/about me. -__-

And...Don't you remember the Whirl Cup competition? That's was the Water Pokemon League. So...based on that, she truly has been exhausted as a character.
 

MidnightScott

Super Gamer
Jynxo - who are you to say that it has been confirmed that Misty will not be coming back? She could - it's the writer's decision, not yours.

Anyway, the only reason why Misty has left is because she's a Gym Leader unlike her prissy sisters. If they didn't make Misty leave sometime there would of been no point of her being introduced as a Gym Leader in the first place. So it's only natural that they would make her leave.

Who really know's why they made her leave - but that is the only reason I can think of. If we want confirmed reason's we would have to ask the writer's.

There is also a possibility that they could get rid of Brock again like they did in the Orange Islands or May or Max. Who know's really? Maybe Misty will come back and some new guy will come along and travel with them?

It's all the writer's decision - which I don't really understand why they put the Battle Frontier in Kanto -_-; but oh well - that's the Japanese for you.

~Scott;229;
 
Last edited:
E

Ethereal

Guest
PokémonScott said:
Jynxo - who are you to say that it has been confirmed that Misty will not be coming back? She could - it's the writer's decision, not yours.
She's not coming back. Who gives a damn if I'm not a writer? Based on yer logic, they could bring the Samurai kid from the third or fourth episode back, just because it's the writers' decision. They could also make Richie a main character, just because it's the writers' decision. Point is, there's no purpose for her return. Get over it, folks.
 

MidnightScott

Super Gamer
Exactly - they could bring back one of those Minor Characters from the past. Yes - they could bring anyone back - like Richie or something (he's in Chronicles but that isn't show in the US Anyway) I really could care less if they got rid of Brock - Misty had more of a purpose then Brock ever did.

~Scott;229;
 
E

Ethereal

Guest
Uh-huh....And pray tell, what was Misty's purpose? What did she do to help Ash? Brock cooks and can be a battle referee. Misty pulls Brock's ear. Yeah, SHE'S useful. :rolleyes:
 

Heracross

Custom User Title
At the time Kasumi was dumped neither she nor Takeshi served a purpose any longer. But to say that she never did anything useful isn't true at all. :s
 

Heracross

Custom User Title
Aw, don't make me write it all out at this hour. ;_;

She:
-came up with the plan to get everyone out of the sunken SS Anne.
-sigle-handedly stopped the Menokurage and Dokukurage from destroying that city.
-helped get the pokémon back in the Eievui brothers episode.
-helped to capture the thief with the Kamonegi and get everyone's pokémon back.
-got everyone out of jail after Yamato and Kosaburou framed them.
-figured out Katsura's riddles which ultimately led to Satoshi finding the Guren Gym.
-used her pokémon to keep everyone from drowning in the first movie.
-helped build rafts so that everyone could escape the sinking Kabuto island.
-cured Satoshi and Kenji after they got a face-full of stun spore.
-got Hoho to use foresight on the illusions so that they could safely travel through the forest.
-stalled for time by battling Mi in her fantasy world.
-sent her pokémon to defend Satoshi from the resurrected Kabutops
-probably a couple more things that I can't remember. D:
 
E

Ethereal

Guest
Dude, most (if not all) of the things you mentioned were also done with the help of others. You made it seem like she was some superwoman. Brock did do more than her, though.

The most Misty was was just a cheerleader for Ash, nothing more.

By the way, Hera, your fanboyishness is showing. :p
 

Heracross

Custom User Title
Fanboyishness for Kasumi? o_o I'm just saying that she has been helpful in the past, that's all. Heaven forbid I be classed as a Kasumi fanboy. :s

I do agree that Takeshi did more overall, but without Kasumi's help Satoshi and Takeshi would be dead twice over.
 

ChaosMage

Izit cuz I is black?
They wanted May in, so Misty went out. May is there to advertise RS (and every other game, by the looks of things), contests in particular. And they wanted Misty to become a leader and the bike thing to be resolved. They did the right thing.
 
T

Tifa

Guest
No offense @ Misty Fans, Pokeshippers, Etc Etc, But if they bring back an old character, im going to complain, To who ever will listen ¬______¬
 
Misty is officially a SUPPORTING character right now. The evil egg-thingy drained away all her life force, leaving her as a dull character with no discernable role. Now, we wish it had not happened, but wishing can't shape reality.
 

kukkyou_ooraka

Original Pokeshipper
"In a strange voice" But I love Misty! She will be back, someway or another. The writers just need to make a role that will suit her goals. Some sort of contest maybe. But if they dont for some strange reason, not bring Misty back.....I might not watch Pokemon again.

" Goes to the Misc. Disc thread and says screw pokemon" But only! If that happens. :D
 
T

Tifa

Guest
kukkyou ooraka, Did you listen to no word Sceptile said, she is a SUPPORTING character, just like Tracey is etc, She may pop up, In random episodes, but my Personal opinion, she'll never be back
 

Yamato-san

I own the 5th gen
Heracross, you do realize that most of those situations happened in filler episodes. As for the important things like the Guren gym battle and the St. Anne.... really, if she wasn't there, the writers would've done something else. For instance, why not make Takeshi suddenly seem like the smart one in those scenarios? Don't you find it sad that the Orange Islands wated the perfect opportunity for Kasumi to do anything useful, considering the area has a lot of water and she's a specialist of water Pokemon? Instead, Satoshi's the one handling all the water transportation, and Kenji's given a Mariru who deals with underwater exploration, thus leaving Kasumi to doing nothing more than Rocket battles.

Anyway, as you know, I'm friggin sick of water Pokemon and their over-excessive use of the dull-a** Water Gun technique, so I personally couldn't be happier that the water specialist was ditched. Why the hell even have a character on the show specializing in one particular type is beyond me. But if anyone else says that Kasumi will "most likely/definitely" come back with no conclusive evidence whatsoever, or suggests the pointless idea of the anime having an entire gym-like quest meant entirely for type-specialists to participate in (or another Whirl Island tournament, for that matter), I swear to god, the second that touch simulators are invented (if not already) and widespread among anyone who uses the internet, I will personally b****-slap that poor sap to no end.
 
Last edited:

Shigeru-kun

Property of Jesus
Well last I knew, Pocket Monsters: Advance Generation has been pulling in more ratings (both series and movie wise) than Pocket Monsters did during the Jouto period. Therefore, I think it's pretty dang obvious Kasumi was kicked out to try and get the ratings higher. I mean, they could have very well dumped Takeshi, but didn't for two reasons.

A; Only one girl can be in the group. Sure this isn't officially known, but it just seems how they're gonna keep it.

B; Takeshi had been removed before and people were furious. Better to take off Kasumi then make the mistake by removing Takeshi again.

So the end result was Kasumi. She was kicked and the ratings went back up...so why fix something that isn't broken?
 

kukkyou_ooraka

Original Pokeshipper
Tifa said:
kukkyou ooraka, Did you listen to no word Sceptile said, she is a SUPPORTING character, just like Tracey is etc, She may pop up, In random episodes, but my Personal opinion, she'll never be back

Does it look like I give a **** what Sceptiles Opinion is? He didnt even give a good reason why she is just a supporting character.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top