• We are currently experiencing a flood of requests from bots scraping the forums. Unfortunately it has gotten to the point where it is negatively impacting the site. As a result the forums may be slow and you may periodically experiance an error message. We are aware of the problem and apologize for the inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

wonder what pokemon would be like if it wasn't dubbed by 4kids

I know pusa owns the anime now but I'm talking about the earlier episodes.you think the anime would get alittle more respect if back then it was dubbed by another companyand if so lets start discussing.
 
I bet the sex scene between Satoshi and Kasumi would have been kept.
 

PDL

disenchanted
Actually, I don't think Pokémon as an entire franchise would have been as successful as it was if it wasn't for the anime, 4kids was actually brilliant in the indigo seasons, it was only when they decided to work on several other anime projects that their work quality slipped.
 

S.Suikun

Thank you, SPPf! :)
You mean all the violence, sex, blood, and gore left in and Ash carried around his shot-gun and killed Team Rocket?
OMG seriously!?! Yet another reason why 4Kids is 100% responsible for Pokemon being viewed as a childish franchise.
 
Actually, I don't think Pokémon as an entire franchise would have been as successful as it was if it wasn't for the anime, 4kids was actually brilliant in the indigo seasons, it was only when they decided to work on several other anime projects that their work quality slipped.

i do aggree on that (it's at least one good thing 4kids ever did) and when you think about it, pokemon lost almost all it's popularity when the movie premeried and everyone hated it. fact is that the movie was the first time that they decited to change all the music and mess up the scripts! you'd think that would tell them that mabey the origonal BGM is the best way to go. but oh well, their loss. anyway as for what it would be like w/o 4kids? first off it depends on who ended up with it, but chances are no matter who got it that it wouldn't have started out quite as overly marketed and popular!
 

Jesse GS the II

I was frozen today!
OMG seriously!?! Yet another reason why 4Kids is 100% responsible for Pokemon being viewed as a childish franchise.

In the immortal words of Charlie Brown, "Don't you know sarcasm when you hear it?"

Questions like this always bring out the inevitable wiseass remarks about how the Japanese version is full of sex and violence (which it isn't, BTW), and there's always one poor schlub who believes 'em.

On topic, I think that another dubbing company would have treated the show with more respect. 4Kids Entertainment has a reputation of not giving half a crap about the quality of their programming, just so long as it makes them billions of dollars, and thus, they really dropped the ball on just about everything they've ever gotten the rights to.
 
Last edited:

Jonouchi

Chibi-cario
I knew it was sarcasm =P

I thought the old anime was fine back in the Indigo season. It probably would have been a little different with another company
 
4Kids was for me a great way into anime and opened up the doors to my Pokemon interest. I will always respect their actors/actresses, and I liked the editing out of Japanese signs ;p.

The music I change is where I didn't agree upon.
 
4Kids was for me a great way into anime and opened up the doors to my Pokemon interest. I will always respect their actors/actresses, and I liked the editing out of Japanese signs ;p.

The music I change is where I didn't agree upon.

Why take away japanese signs when they clearly had japanese refences anyway? Ghost of Maiden Peak anyone? Japanese houses? riceballs? Otashi? LT. SURGE?......Oh wait he's AMERICAN!!...
 

Jesse GS the II

I was frozen today!
Justin is just bent on making 4Kids look like divine gods, and he's convinced that PUSA should be damned to hell for "taking away" the anime from them. I suggest you pay him no heed whatsoever.
 

SOS! Its Not Healthy..

He Say Whaaa...
Its hard to say since there wasn't much dubbing companies that dubbed Japanese anime back around 10 years ago, (might be wrong here), but if it was in a different company, possibilites it could have gone for the better, or it could gone for the worst.

But, its a pity how they made so many unnecessary edits 4 Kids made, and actually the first 2 seasons was great, but then 4 Kids took Pokemon in their own hands editing out even more as everyone all know.
 
Top