dinomagic4life
Ace Trainer
Just got yellow again today. Feels good, man.
I ask you, which do you prefer? Yellow, or its predecessors, red and blue?
I ask you, which do you prefer? Yellow, or its predecessors, red and blue?
-
Hi all. We have had reports of member's signatures being edited to include malicious content. You can rest assured this wasn't done by staff and we can find no indication that the forums themselves have been compromised.
However, remember to keep your passwords secure. If you use similar logins on multiple sites, people and even bots may be able to access your account.
We always recommend using unique passwords and enable two-factor authentication if possible. Make sure you are secure. -
Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
Yellow Version vs. Red and Blue
- Thread starter dinomagic4life
- Start date
- Status
surfer treecko
Highly Explosive
At first I though I prefered Yellow, but after playing it through again I'm not so sure.
Yellow has much weaker trainers then R/B, especially in the case of your Rival. Also, I think the new sprites clash with the style of everything else, even if they are more detailed and colourful then the old sprites.
However, Yellow does let you get all the starters, and has more things avaliable...
Yellow has much weaker trainers then R/B, especially in the case of your Rival. Also, I think the new sprites clash with the style of everything else, even if they are more detailed and colourful then the old sprites.
However, Yellow does let you get all the starters, and has more things avaliable...
deoxysdude94
Meme Historian
I like red and blue. I'm not a big fan of starting with pikachu.
Vipsoccermaster
Well-Known Member
Both, although I prefer Yellow since you can get all the starters.
Sprintking
Well-Known Member
I love my Red version to death, but Yellow was my first version and still my clear favorite. I loved getting Pikachu as a starter, as well as the revamped gym leaders and all the small changes from RB.
deoxysdude94
Meme Historian
I like red and blue better. Mainly because you get good pokemon to start. I know you can get all 3 starters in yellow, but I still don't like starting with pikachu.
sweeney123
Eevee Trainer
tough choice but i like yellow.
The Red Thunder
Backwards thinking?
Not particular about either one, to be perfectly honest. One thing I liked about Yellow was the Pikachu Surfing mini-game.
Misty Lover17
Water Trainer
blue, simply because Water type pokemon are my favorites.
I like Red as welll ^.^
I like Red as welll ^.^
Dark Arceus
Worst. Name. Ever.
I'd say Yellow, due to the imorvements in gym leaders, the ability to easily obtain all 3 starters without trading and the improved graphics. Also, the idea of Pikachu following you around and being able to communicate with it was a neat gimmick. Might not have suited everybody, but it showed the game creators were willing to try something new. Shame they shelved the idea til HG/SS though :/
Volcanic Murk
Stupid Genius
In Yellow, you can get all 3 starters and the graphics are improved. However, you are pretty much forced to use Pikachu, because if you don't you won't have it following you. In Red and Blue, you can pick any pokemon you want without consequences, but the sprites are horrible. *cough* Golbat. *cough*
I'd say Red and Blue, but it's really close.
I'd say Red and Blue, but it's really close.
Tough choice. Yellow felt too....desperate? Like the creators really just wanted to tie in the anime's random events into the Pokemon games so kids would see the connection between the two. I like Red and Blue since they're the original games (outside of Japan, anyway) and they both have this feel of independence. I mean to say, when they came out, the anime hadn't started yet and the games were the only way to really understand the allure of Pokemon and since they were the only way anyone could appreciate Pokemon, they stand alone, at the top of the Pokemon World. At least for me 
- Status