Yu-Gi-Oh Mafia

[Aquanova]

Since the game is now over I'll say what I wanted to say. First, this had to be the worst game Ive ever been in. I didnt understand how my role was supposed to be played at all which is why i didnt last long. Ive never seen YuGiOh GX or 5Ds thats probably why. The game want exciting it was really boring. The Mafia games i play on another site which is in my signature if you care to look( not the link) often have twists funnyness and general insanity. Ive become accustomed to that style of play.

The no roleclaiming rule is bad. Roleclaiming is one of those things that goes with Mafia. If you ban it you take like half the game away. This game could have been good, im hoping if you do Star Wars Mafia, that it'll be a little more exciting. I know this seems harsh but thats exactly how I feel about this game.

 

[Lbsweet96]

Inactivity ruined this. Also the no outing rule. Also the "all roles are cops" thing.

Also, sorry Mitch. Should have been less vague with your hints =P

 

[Houndude619]

When i next get holidays i am going to do a basic mafia (think assassin) with role claiming.

 

[Lbsweet96]

Good luck fixing inactivity though

 

[Aquanova]

for inactivity id suggest enforcing a rule that states if you dont post or send actions for a certain amount of time, you'll replace them, but nudge first.

 

[Sigh!]

I wasn't vague I was basically screaming my role! Didn't you see my questions about how many goods died or if Chazz counted as a townie kill?

 

[brandyjay]

You do realise the Chazz thing also applied to Rex, the last mafia so it did look a bit like you were outsing yourself as him without meaning to.

 

[Houndude619]

I had the inactivity role thing i just didnt have any extra sign ups for people to be replaced with.