• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Jared's Grave

Status
Not open for further replies.
Trigger Warning: Content includes suicide, suicidal thoughts, depression, talks of mental institutions, self-hatred, and forced medication.

I didn't want to have to do this, but I have no choice. I'm quitting the Pokemon league. It's just too painful to watch him destroy himself out there. People don't love me. My heart's been broken twenty five times, and I get no where fast when I'm in my car listening to a musical show tune. I don't care what anybody thinks of me. I'm such a loser. Nobody's has said anything about my new hair cut. People think I'm a fool. Nobody respects my authority. Nobody has love in their heart for a loser. People don't respect my privacy. They invade my space. I never counted the times I lost a loved one. But I'll start now. I'm getting out of this hospital and back into the real world. Why does nobody respect me? Why must I be treated like vile filth? Nobody has ever told me that they had love in their heart. Nobody respects me. Nobody gave the time of the week to my calendar's heart. I broke the bottle, and drank the beer or a thirsty beverage. I don't know why I started drinking again. I have a bad memory. I think I've really lost my mind. I've been going beserk. I've tried to keep my memory on the down low. I hope I don't go back into a mental instititution. Nobody lets you get physical connections with anybody else. You're not allowed to do anything fun. They don't allow contrabands, and you're on elopement precautions. It's a bad thing. Nobody lets you get off your medicine. They make you take medicine without telling you why you're on it. If you're even a little bit excited, they give you a mood stabilizer to calm you down, even if you're not mentally ill. Misty's got my back. She's the best friend I've ever had. Sayanara, world. I must die.

It's been years since Jared wrote that letter. It gets to me every time. Why did Jared commit suicide? It's the worst thing in the world. Why did he do such a thing? Didn't he have love that couldn't be broken? He was only thirty seven and have you seen the news? I loved Jared. He was the perfect guy. He was so smart, and so strong. He was the greatest man in the world. I loved him with all my heart and soul. I heard he was drunk when he killed himself. That's so scary. Why would he do that? Doesn't he care what we go through? He never even said he loved me back. It hurts me so bad. Why did Jared kill himself? Thinking about telling me another fanfiction story? Because that sucks.

It's true? Why don't you go home, and finish this later?

I have to write an article for the school newspaper. I want to be the president of the Spanish club. I wanted to go to college, and study as an art major. I've got major abs. I don't drink and drive. That's what loser said.

I don't want to be bothered with this sight. Bye.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Alright, firstly, I'd like so say that this is a little hard to read and hard to figure out what's going on because of it. For example, it's hard to tell which words are part of Jared's suicide note and which are part of the person reading it's thoughts. It sounds like the first paragraph is Jared's note and the rest is the person reading it, but then after the second paragraph everything else doesn't really make sense unless either it's more of what Jared's said or the person reading it has chosen to kill themselves as well. I'd probably recommend splitting that first paragraph up to make it easier to read, and putting quotations or speech marks around the parts of the chapter that are part of the suicide note so we can tell what is and what isn't part of it.

Is the person reading it Misty, by the way? Considering this implies that one of your original characters was in a relationship with a canon character, it'd be nice to hear some background about why they met. I'm not sure if Misty's voice is coming across quite well here, since she's quite brash and tomboyish in the games and show, although I could understand her being subdued considering what happened.

Details in general would be quite good. I'm not sure why Jared committed suicide because his letter is a bit of a mess - he complains about heartbreak when what's said later on suggests he has a girlfriend. He's drunk and depressed and doesn't want to go back to a mental institution, but better background on that would be good such as how he got that way. But the rest of it focuses on it being a loser in such a confusing way - it treats invasions of privacy in the same way as not respecting his haircut in a suicide note, the latter of which makes it hard to take seriously, and I can't tell what he means by lacking respect for his authority or invasions of privacy. In particular, the authority line makes him almost sound entitled because we don't know if he actually had a position of authority, so if he was a regular Trainer that line might need to be changed. I'd focus on one or two reasons to drive his suicide rather than throwing in so many undeveloped ones.

I don't know what the 'he's destroying himself out there' line means either; it's part of Jared's note so it doesn't feel like a comment based around his wellbeing due to being in the third person, and there's no mention of anyone else by him whom it could be.

A bit more focus again on the Pokemon Trainer angle would be good. Would the wellbeing of his Pokemon be a concern to him and affect if he'd kill himself? What will happen to them now he is dead? What are their feelings on this? Right now the League angle feels almost incidental to the whole fanfic and as such brings into account a lot of questions.

And again, I think there needs to be a focus on the specifics of why Misty thinks he's perfect, smart and strong. Whether it be specific moments she shared with him (e.g. She thinks she's strong because of the first time they battled) or specific traits of him (e.g. She thinks he's smart because he knew another language, for instance), it would be nice to know beyond the generics.

Also I can't take the 'did he kill himself because he didn't want to tell more fanfics? That sucks'. First of all, I don't buy that writing fanfiction would be a valid reason for someone taking their own life unless thwy were seriously unhappy writing it and had no avenue out. This is not the case for Jared; we don't see fanfic mentioned anywhere else in the story. Also, 'that sucks' is too light-hearted for someone dying. 'That's horrible' or 'that's awful' are a lot closer in tone to what you're looking for.

I don't know what's going on with the last three lines, from 'it's true' to the end. Who is talking, and who are they talking to? What do school papers and Spanish have to do with everything else - is this Jared, or another person talking? Why can't they be bothered with the sight? Is it Misty being interviewed over the suicide? If so, why can't we be told that she's talking to a reporter? Otherwise, those last few lines seem to come out of nowhere.

I appreciate you're trying to handle a tough, very delicate subject, but there's going to be a lot more developing and explaining of your points to get the emotional impact right, and I'd probably recommend reading through and checking the tone of your language and what characters are saying so there isn't as much trivialising language as well. Good luck!
 
Hooo lawdy.

Well, I can’t really argue with Chibi_Muffin’s review (although I will note that, on topic of depression, you can have all kinds of things that should make you happy and still be suicidally depressed because depression is a condition, not an emotion). There were a few issues that made this a bit difficult to read, and the story as a whole seems like it stops just short of giving us much to go on. But we get into that in a moment.

More importantly, though, I’d like to talk about the message behind it. I’ve read this story a couple of times over, and I can’t help but wonder how much of it is personal. A lot of Jared’s note sounds eerily similar to the way a few people I know have spoken, including the descriptions of how a mental institution treats you. If it is personal, I want to say something that’s going to off-set the criticism a bit, and that’s this: it’s okay to use writing as an outlet. If you wrote this to work through your own depression or to keep your own thoughts at bay or to even work through your interactions with someone else so that you can find a way to understand them, that’s okay. Please keep doing it. And don’t get any of our advice wrong because writing is one of those things you have to do a lot of to figure out what not to do, so if people give you negative feedback now, it doesn’t mean you’re not meant to write or anything. Please do use writing as an outlet if that’s what makes you feel a little closer to all right at the end of the day.

Of course, if this is not a personal story or a reflection of your own mentality, then either you’ve done a great job at capturing that feeling of self-defeatism and self-hatred folks who go through depression feel … or you just very accurately captured the voices of people I know. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ On a personal note, it is kinda curious. Like, each time I read that first paragraph, I flash back to multiple folks I’ve met who’ve been through hospital systems. I remember all those nights I’d sit with some of them and just listen to them talk about how no one cares about them and how they’re absolutely terrible people. Sometimes, if you’re suffering through depression, you just get locked in your own head, and nothing anyone will ever say will convince you you’re good enough, even if they’re sitting right beside you or chatting with you every night. So you tear yourself up exactly like Jared does, even if on the outside, according to anyone who observes you, you have a lot going for you. That’s why I kinda said I wonder if this is personal, because this isn’t a thing a lot of people understand without experiencing it first-hand. But if it’s not, then it’s interesting to read something I consider to be a fairly good portrayal of mental health … if, you know, that makes sense. So! I can definitely see you have potential as a writer, either to develop characters or to get your emotions out on paper. Not sure which, but either way, definitely think of that as a good thing.

Now for the not-so-good news. The main issue is we do have a set of rules about the standard of quality for fics around these parts. These standards kinda make sense because when you post to a forum, what you’re doing is attempting to share your fic with other people. So while what you write will always have a part of you in it, it’s also meant to communicate ideas to a reader as well. In this case, it is a little hard to grasp this story, as Chibi_Muffin’s pointed out. Part of that has to do with the formatting and basic structure, yeah, but also, it’s hard to figure out what this story is actually about. Sure, you could say it’s about Misty finding her boyfriend’s suicide note, but that doesn’t quite tell enough of a story on its own. We get a glimpse into Jared’s head but not quite enough to really understand who he is and what he’s about. And while it’s okay to use stories to vent (especially in private), when you cross over to a more public medium, you’re dealing with folks who are going into your work not knowing anything about your characters, their world, or even (and especially) where this story is really coming from. So consequently, this feels like a fragment of a story, rather than a story in its own right, so right off the bat, that kinda clashes with our rules a bit (because you kinda need a story for posting).

On the other hand, it could be part of a larger story—like a prologue or a chapter—but judging by the title, I feel like the whole point was to talk about this one character’s suicide note, which would mean the story’s complete as of right now.

My point is this is kinda awkward to tell you, but I do think you should have the option to vent. And I sincerely hope you do stick around the fan fic forum and work on developing your potential a little more, because I think you do have potential! However, at the same time, my impression is this isn’t so much a story as it is a personal rant with characters kinda applied to give it more of a fanfic-y feel, and because of that, I have to step in and say that this might not be the best place to do that. But please, keep writing and keep developing what you’re doing. Read a lot more and see how others develop their ideas into a story. Then, when you’ve got a full story all set, please don’t hesitate to come back.

Or tl;dr, all that being said, while I do think you have potential, I have to close this on the basis of it not really being a story, but in all, I do encourage you to try again some other time. Also, while I’m here, don’t forget to review the rules about warnings as well. Talks about suicide and mental institutions could be triggers for some people, meaning it could cause folks who might’ve been all right to flash back to their own bad experiences, which in turn could cause them to experience panic attacks or things of the sort. I’ve edited in warnings for you this time around, but next time, definitely keep that in mind when posting your work. We want everyone here to feel safe when participating in the community, be it reading or writing, so we want to make sure everyone knows going into a story what they might expect.

Thanks again for understanding, and good luck with future work!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top