• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Multiple Viewpoints

Gelatino95

Not a tool
I have an idea for a fic that I'm planning to write once I'm finished with my current one. I plan to write it from the point of view of different characters in the story, much like The Poisonwood Bible, if anyone else is familiar with the book. However, I also want to make it so that it's in the format of a novel written by the main character after all the events have taken place.

My question: is there a practical way to combine these two ideas? Would it make sense for my main character to try interpreting the viewpoint of other characters in his novel? I know it wouldn't make sense for each character to be writing a separate novel about the story, since some of the main characters are pokemon, and everybody knows that pokemon can't write. That would be just silly.

On the other hand, I could also just drop the novel idea and simply have each of the characters reflecting on the events of the story. What are your thoughts?
 
If you're willing to experiment with formatting a little, there's a practical way. For example, you could have two different timelines going with two different presents: the first present (told by the main character after the fact) and the second present (told by the other characters in turn). Once you've got those two down, you could alternate between them the same way you would if you were alternating between the viewpoints of the second present.

An alternate is doing what The Poisonwood Bible actually did by narrating the first half of the book from a single viewpoint (the first present, perhaps) and then going into the second half of the book (the alternating viewpoints of the second present). This works particularly if the main character knows the gist of the story but not how it actually happened. Alternatively, it could function as a very effective frame device (a little like Rocky Horror Picture Show, where the entire movie is actually being told by an investigator who knows what actually happened).

The main trick is trying to find a reason to alternate, really. As in, you don't want the first present to reveal too much about the story of the second, but you want it to make sense that the first present exists, if you follow me. Or to put it simply, it can work, but you have to make it clear that it needs to work like that.

Hope that helps a bit!
 
If you're willing to experiment with formatting a little, there's a practical way. For example, you could have two different timelines going with two different presents: the first present (told by the main character after the fact) and the second present (told by the other characters in turn). Once you've got those two down, you could alternate between them the same way you would if you were alternating between the viewpoints of the second present.

I'm not sure if I follow you here; I don't want more than one version of the story, I simply want it told by different people so they can each put in their own insights on the situations in the story. Like the Poisonwood Bible, it will be one continuous story that is just shifted between different speakers per chapter.

An alternate is doing what The Poisonwood Bible actually did by narrating the first half of the book from a single viewpoint (the first present, perhaps) and then going into the second half of the book (the alternating viewpoints of the second present). This works particularly if the main character knows the gist of the story but not how it actually happened. Alternatively, it could function as a very effective frame device (a little like Rocky Horror Picture Show, where the entire movie is actually being told by an investigator who knows what actually happened).

I'll be honest here and say that I didn't read the entire Poisonwood Bible for school (still got a good grade on the essay, though. Jumping through grade hoops is easier than it seems) so I wasn't really aware that the form changed halfway through the story. I always assumed that is was one story with speakers that changed each chapter as the story progressed.

This works particularly if the main character knows the gist of the story but not how it actually happened.

All the characters in my planned story, for the most part, will be experiencing these events firsthand. I know it'll be easier to understand once I actually post the fic.

The main trick is trying to find a reason to alternate, really. As in, you don't want the first present to reveal too much about the story of the second, but you want it to make sense that the first present exists, if you follow me. Or to put it simply, it can work, but you have to make it clear that it needs to work like that.

So, I need to have a good reason that the story should be told from the viewpoints of multiple people rather than just writing the whole thing third-person? Never really thought about that before.
 
I'm not sure if I follow you here; I don't want more than one version of the story, I simply want it told by different people so they can each put in their own insights on the situations in the story. Like the Poisonwood Bible, it will be one continuous story that is just shifted between different speakers per chapter.

Oh, I know. The suggestion was to have one version of the story told through multiple timelines.

Think of a story like bracelets made out of string, basically. If you have one timeline, it's just a string. If you have three, it's a braid. It's still a bracelet, just with three different strings woven into it.

That's the same thing with the suggestion I was going for. The timelines are basically just perspectives. The first timeline might contain your main character looking back on the story; the second might contain your other characters looking at it as they're experiencing it (or from a time point that's different from your main).

I guess for examples to this, you could look at my own one-shot Braid, wherein there's three different narrators: an unnamed character advising someone who's going into Ilex Forest in the future, an unnamed character describing every action you (the character in the present) are taking, and an unnamed narrator relating a fairy tale about the forest in the past. They're all the same story; it's just that they're all telling different parts of it.

At the moment, I'm trying to come up with a comparable printed work besides The Poisonwood Bible that you could look at to get what I mean, but my mind's drawing a blank. So... yeah, sorry about the egotistical example.

I'll be honest here and say that I didn't read the entire Poisonwood Bible for school (still got a good grade on the essay, though. Jumping through grade hoops is easier than it seems) so I wasn't really aware that the form changed halfway through the story.

Haha, high five. As I understand it, the first half is told by one person, whereas the second takes on alternating viewpoints. But I sort of didn't read it entirely myself (*whistles innocently for similar reasons*), so I'm not sure if I'm correct there.

All the characters in my planned story, for the most part, will be experiencing these events firsthand. I know it'll be easier to understand once I actually post the fic.

Sure. Looking forward to it. I always like reading fic that plays around with different ways of telling a story.

So, I need to have a good reason that the story should be told from the viewpoints of multiple people rather than just writing the whole thing third-person? Never really thought about that before.

Oh yeah. In my view, everything you do in a story goes into its overall meaning. (I guess you could say I took that one piece of advice from Poe a little too seriously.) Even the different modes and points of view have different meanings. For example, if you want to tell a story in first person, it's usually because you want to get into the mind of a character, right? First person point of view is more effective at doing that than even third person omniscient because you get across the character's voice. On the other hand, first person isn't as effective in portraying multiple characters because everything is colored by the narrator's opinions. (Assuming it's well-written first person POV, anyway.) That's something third person omniscient can do that first person can't. It's actually really interesting to think about all the different things just changing the POV can bring to a story.

When it comes to multiple viewpoints, that usually just means that you're alternating getting into those particular characters. Every person views things a little differently, so alternating POVs between two or more different people means you're aiming to show a reader how those viewpoints differ in more ways than just who saw what happening and who didn't, if that makes sense. I guess you could just say that if two completely different people told the exact same story about what they did on any given day, chances are that the story they tell won't be exactly the same. That's a lot of what I mean by having a reason for doing it -- just that it's a good way of bringing out the personalities of each of your characters and that you should absolutely take the opportunity to do it to take full advantage of a pretty cool system.
 
As for my purpose in making multiple viewpoints: I've been reading Ender's Game recently, where you get to see into the mind of this cynical, genius kid who can pretty much tell what the motives and intentions of other people are. I always wanted to see what other people thought of Ender, though, since the story doesn't really go into that very much. For the most part, the story focuses on Ender's perception and other characters, even plot-centric characters, are included sparingly, except for a select few like his sister, Valentine.

I don't plan for my main character to be exactly like Ender, though, but I want things to be told from his point of view, and then we can hear another character's side of the story in order to get an in-depth view of how the main character is seen by others. The characters that serve as speakers will vary in personality so that I can get differing opinions, too.

As for the Poisonwood Bible, I think the speaker changes every chapter, even from the beginning of the book. It starts with the viewpoint of Orleanna, then switches off to her daughters. (Shockingly enough, they never show the point of view of the evil male chauvinist, Nathan)
 
Oh, Ender's Game. There's a book I haven't read in forever.

Anyway, if you want to go with third person limited (what Ender is told in), that's okay. Third person limited has the advantage of narrowing the narration's viewpoint while at the same time divorcing the audience from the character. We don't get that character's voice, but we do feel as if we know him because we see the world the way he does. In a way, you could say that third person limited is the viewpoint in which the narrator attempts to force us to become a little like the characters it focuses on because we read the narration as if it's our own commentary on the cast and their thought processes. (It differs in that sense from first person because first person has us listening to the characters instead.) In the end, we feel a sense of detachment, but at the same time, we can understand how Ender feels because we're just as shocked as he is over the revelations he encounters.

It's really one of my favorite POVs for exactly that reason. I personally feel that it's a lot easier to connect a reader to the story and keep them guessing by having the story focus on one character at a time and occasionally switch focuses to some other character. Tunnel vision, in other words.

The point is, though, whatever mode you want to do is completely up to you. In fact, you could argue that any of the modes can be workable on one way or another. (It would be just as easy to tell the story in first person and capture your main character's thoughts before switching to a first-person rendition of another character's.) Just remember to make it clear within the story that whatever you choose makes sense and adds something to what you're saying. Like I said, you don't quite get the same effect if you tell a story in first person compared to what would happen if you told it in third (limited, omniscient, or other), so be careful about which one you choose and be sure to make your intent clear within the story.

That in mind, actually, that non-egotistical example that I was struggling to remember finally came to me if you're interested: Mindscape by Andrea Hairston. It looks like three different stories on the surface, but actually, they're all closely interconnected and flesh out the world around the characters on a deep level. It's also a story that plays mix-and-match with POVs, with part of the story being told as a first person narrative, part of it being told in third person limited, another being told through memos from one character to another, and so forth. It's pretty well-crafted, with each of the modes largely succeeding in capturing the characters' mindsets, although it's occasionally difficult to get into. So... there's that for another example. *nod*
 
Back
Top