Its his team,let him use which pokemon he wants Nightcat, Hmm... I usually had a Gardvoir on my team so I could use imprison, it really messes up lunatone and a few other of their pokemon if it has the right moves, but yes you need water attacks,surf,hydro pump,etc. Also you can use your Tropicus with its magicial leaf/bullet seed? Bullet seed isnt that great of an attack but if it can cause decent enough damage to Claydol/Lunatone,Id use it. Even if just for that badge. The Xatu, just zap it with a t-wave first(or zap everything possible with a t wave) then spark or shockwave depending which electrical attacks it has, your team has the abilties to beat them, its just going to take proper timing of when to do what exactly. In example, faint Claydol before sending out your Manetric,just to be safe, then start T waving the enemy pokemon as another surfs, when xatu comes out, or if it was already out when manetric came out, zap it to make it faint,then continue t waving then attacking with both. I believe that strategy should work if deployed properly.
Until Next Time..
Optical Flash - Aaron
The Butterfree and Flareon/Vaporeon/Umbreon Master.