• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Human Error

matt0044

Well-Known Member
As the title implies, here we can discuss how characters can make mistakes that are stupid and sometimes fatal but also make sense from a story perspective. Like it doesn't come out of nowhere and fits the character's motives.

Two examples would be like in Dragon Ball Z where Vegeta fights semi-perfect Cell while Krillin attempts to shut down and destory Android #18. Cell convinces Vegeta to let him achieve his perfect form so "he can present a better challenge to Vegeta" as Saiyan live for the thrill of battle and Vegeta wants to defeat Cell at his best. Meanwhile, Krillin tries to shut down #18 but remembers her kiss to him and finds himself in love with her. These errors allow Cell to absorb 18 and give him his perfect form.

Something like that.
 
Didn't you make a thread almost exactly like this a couple of months ago?

There's nothing wrong with characters making mistakes that they would make, but even if all your characters are genuinely too dumb to live, the reader is probably still going to get tired of them making easily foreseeable mistakes, especially if it's plain the plot could have been resolved in five minutes if they had half a brain cell between them.
 
I don't know what thread you're thinking of, but I'm thinking of [thread=568012]this one[/thread], which is worded slightly differently but is basically talking about the same thing as this one as far as I can tell (characters making stupid mistakes that are in character for them).
 
I don't know what thread you're thinking of, but I'm thinking of [thread=568012]this one[/thread], which is worded slightly differently but is basically talking about the same thing as this one as far as I can tell (characters making stupid mistakes that are in character for them).

That's it. Though it's been quite a while that I didn't want to risk bumping it.
 
...but that thread got seventeen replies, which seems to indicate a good number of people already gave you their opinion on this issue (which may be why nobody's replying to this one except me reiterating the point I already made there). What reason was there to bump it or restart the topic now?

Eh, I'll leave this open since it's here in case somebody who has input on it missed the other one, but please don't keep making threads about the same thing.
 
I apologize for the bother.
 
I looked over the original thread and really only have this to add:

Yes, sometimes characters do make stupid mistakes and it can work - if the reason for it makes sense for their character. The examples you used? Vegeta makes mistakes not out of stupidity, but out of pride. He wants to prove himself against a stronger foe and thus allows the foe to power up. Krillin acts out of love for android 18 rather than because he's dumb. These reasons, not "stupidity" are in the forefront. They turn out to be "stupid mistakes" but it makes sense for the characters. It's not "something stupid that you realize was in-character later" but rather "something in-character that later turns out to have been a bad idea."

The only other thing I can add is that I find a story much more engaging when characters struggle despite being competent rather than because they're stupid. It makes the story more interesting if the characters make smart decisions that turn out to be mistakes than if they do something that makes the reader think they're incompetent. It helps raise the threat level of whatever they're struggling against, too, if the reader sees that they're making good decisions that still turn out badly, and causes the reader to feel more for the characters. If the reader thinks that the characters could just get out of the situation if they weren't so stupid, then they don't usually end up feeling the need to root for the characters.
 
Back
Top