• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Hunter J's death

Status
Not open for further replies.

matt0044

Well-Known Member
Even now, that scene bugs the heck out of me.

Okay, I give the TV show props for show actual on-screen death with little ambiguity and no resurrections of any kind and I'm surprised even the dub left it untouched (then again, it's not done by 4kids who would've said everyone was transported to Azelf's dimension in the whirlpool).

However, the problem is that it happens... and that's it. No follow-up, no future consequence, she just shows up, gets the Lake Trio and *BOOM* dead. It feels like the writers just threw up their hands and said, "let's just kill her off for the hell of it."

And the real kicker is that they could've at least given her a proper send off in a future episode (in place of one of the fillers ahead) where Ash manages to defeat her and help bring her to justice. She was a darn great villain. Why the heck did they just drop her in the trash like some dirty rag?

I don't hate it, I don't love it. It's just... confusing.

Thoughts?
 
I think the general idea behind what happened was that Hunter J was so irredeemable that the only befitting punishment was death.

This was a character who showed no regard for human or Pokemon life. Who stole countless Pokemon for financial gain. Who at times showed willingness to destroy whatever was in her way, living or not, without a hint of hesitation. Her lack of empathy made her very good at what she did, and she never showed any remorse for her actions even in the face of death. Prison would not have changed her. If anything, she would've come out of it feeling bitter and resentful like nonredeemable villains in other media.
 
I applaud the decision to legitimately kill her off, except I wish it wasn't as abrupt and featured Ash and co doing something to take her out.
I guess for some reason the writers felt that her and her crew getting killed off generically in an underwater abyss is less violent and inappropriate than straight up being killed by ash. Also the whole fact that we have seen team rocket blown up, electricuted, drowned, burnt, crushed, etc since the very beginning and that same thing happening to hunter except her actuallt dying instead would seem inconsistent.
 
I thought Hunter J's death scene was near perfect to be honest. She wasn't needed anymore, so it made sense for the writers to get rid of her before she got bland and became redundant like Team Rocket imo. I loved her though.
 
Prison would not have changed her.

When did I say I wanted THAT?

I thought Hunter J's death scene was near perfect to be honest. She wasn't needed anymore, so it made sense for the writers to get rid of her before she got bland and became redundant like Team Rocket imo. I loved her though.

I just wish it didn't seem so... shoehorned into the Team Galactic finale. Like... you could literally cut that scene out with little to no consequences. It just... happens and we move on. I'm sorry but you DON'T just kill off a character like that with zero-impact on the story.
 
Last edited:
She wasn't "dropped in the trash like some dirty rag."

The way she went out was the logical conclusion to her story arc. She spent the entirety of DP proving herself as the most violent, immoral, irredeemable villain the anime had ever come up with outside of the movies. All those Pokemon she caught were sold and would never get back to where she stole them, they were stuck being experimented on or whatever happened to them. She burned down that forest and tried repeatedly to kill Ash just for that one Riolu. She destroyed a sacred history site and nearly an entire city to capture Regigigas, and had every intention of outright murdering Brandon by leaving him there out of spite after shooting him with her laser. Then she nuked a lake and beat up not one, not two, but three Legendary Pokemon.

J got exactly what she deserved in the end. She got back all the brutality she carried out. She was on such a different page compared to all previous villains that prison was too good for her. Either she had to die or she would have to come back again in a future arc and never face any kind of punishment for her actions.
 
When did I say I wanted THAT?
where Ash manages to defeat her and help bring her to justice

... and I said that even putting her in jail wouldn't really bring her to " justice ". It'd just make her bitter, angry, and vengeful towards Ash whenever she gets out of prison because goodness knows the Pokemon World has a shoddy legal system.

Hunter J's biggest crime was against Pokemon, so ultimately it was the Pokemon who punished her.

Hunter J was completely Evil, and the only way you stop evil is by dest4roying it. So they did.

Her punishment was justified and quite honestly had more of a lasting impact.
 
Pretty much agree with most of you, death was a fitting punishment.

Her simply going to prison or being locked up would have felt undeserving.
 
She just felt so... shoehorned into the TG finale. You could have Saturn, Jupiter and Mars do the job and you'd never think, "Hmmm, know what this needs? Hunter J randomly written in."
 
I thought Hunter J's death scene was near perfect to be honest. She wasn't needed anymore, so it made sense for the writers to get rid of her before she got bland and became redundant like Team Rocket imo. I loved her though.

I agree, it was nice to see a villain go out on a high note for once. I think it was the best way to write her off.
 
I agree, it was nice to see a villain go out on a high note for once. I think it was the best way to write her off.

I won't say that this kind of death wasn't good and I'll admit that it's cool as hell, animation-wise especially. I just really don't like the way it was placed in the TG finale and then she's gone (sorry but I fail to see how she's coming back). The Galactic Commanders could've taken her place easily and none would be the wiser. As a writer (of Fanfiction, yes but I take my craft seriously), it really bugs me. No matter what the excuse or apology meta-wise, it just wreaks of, "let's kill this character off for shock value. YAY!" Even Best Wishes's Trip got a better send-off. FRICKIN' TRIP!
 
Last edited:
I think her getting killed off was well deserved, I just wish it was done a bit different.

All those Ash V.S Hunter J fights and he wasn't the one to do the job in the end, I was so disappointed with that :(
 
I applaud the decision to legitimately kill her off, except I wish it wasn't as abrupt and featured Ash and co doing something to take her out.

Are you sure she is dead? For all we know she could be making a reappearance in a future season or movie.
 
Are you sure she is dead? For all we know she could be making a reappearance in a future season or movie.

I think her death was written to be left up to fan speculation. As Dawn+Serena Fan said there's no reason to bring her back. I'd love to see it happen as she's my favourite character but I highly doubt she'll appear again as almost all recurring characters only appear in the series the debuted in, not counting flashbacks and the like.
 
Maybe they will have a hunter j zombie appear and her goal would be to infect all pokemon as zombiemon.
 
Maybe they will have a hunter j zombie appear and her goal would be to infect all pokemon as zombiemon.

That... would be so crazy that it'd be the best episode ever to air.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top