• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Nitpicking.

Janice Quatlane

helloooo ladies
What are some teensy, tiny little things in Pokémon, that you somehow noticed, and now you notice everywhere? Small things, that maybe no one else has even heard of? Just things like that. Post them here, and discuss.


For me, the only one that I can remember is a surfing one. Y'know the scene, cruising along on your Empoleon, surfing, all casual, when BAM! Trainer! Oh no problem, I'll just get out my Pokeball and send out- Empoleon....
 
This one has been pointed out before, but I don't get why some Pokémon that are perfectly capable of flight can't learn fly...
 
Just that you can lock a god pokemon into a ball and have it obey you.

You take away the free will of a pokemon, forcing it to come with you. Yet, if the pokemon is too high level for the number of badges you have, it doesn't need to obey you. At the same time, the only consequence of the too-high level rebellion is that it won't follow your orders in battle. The pokemon neither turns and attacks you nor runs off to go home and continue with its life as a free pokemon. For that matter, it will use its HMs out of battle even if it refuses to do so in battle.
 
Why can't Scyther learn Fly?! like even if it evolves into scizor it should still be able to fly!

Gyarados can't learn any flying type moves and yet almost EVERY pokemon can? almost every pokemon in OU i have noticed can learn Arial ace, and if not arial ace Acrobatics!
 
Just that you can lock a god pokemon into a ball and have it obey you.

You take away the free will of a pokemon, forcing it to come with you. Yet, if the pokemon is too high level for the number of badges you have, it doesn't need to obey you. At the same time, the only consequence of the too-high level rebellion is that it won't follow your orders in battle. The pokemon neither turns and attacks you nor runs off to go home and continue with its life as a free pokemon. For that matter, it will use its HMs out of battle even if it refuses to do so in battle.

That's because... wait for it... Pokèmon is a game for all ages! It's not supposed to be like that, because Nintendo wants it child-friendly, and they at least tried to come up with a logical explanation.
 
When HP gets 0 you just can't catch it. Logically sending a Pokéball to a Pokémon which has 0HP is equal to sending a Masterball to a full HP Mewtwo.
 
When HP gets 0 you just can't catch it. Logically sending a Pokéball to a Pokémon which has 0HP is equal to sending a Masterball to a full HP Mewtwo.

I agree kinda, I think low level pokemon you should need to make them faint to get a x2 or 3 chance or something but only once, maybe 5x for legendary or something or not for legendarys at all
 
Just that you can lock a god pokemon into a ball and have it obey you.

You take away the free will of a pokemon, forcing it to come with you. Yet, if the pokemon is too high level for the number of badges you have, it doesn't need to obey you. At the same time, the only consequence of the too-high level rebellion is that it won't follow your orders in battle. The pokemon neither turns and attacks you nor runs off to go home and continue with its life as a free pokemon. For that matter, it will use its HMs out of battle even if it refuses to do so in battle.

For the love of God, Arceus is not a God!

Nope, the Pokemon can CHOOSE. It can even dodge the Pokeball's beam to not go into the Pokeball, as shown with Ash's Phanpy and also come out at will, Like May's Skitty. It does not obey you because it does not respect you, like Ash's Charizard. When you catch it and have enough badges, it respects you and listens to you.
 
Last edited:
Why can't Scyther learn Fly?! like even if it evolves into scizor it should still be able to fly!

Gyarados can't learn any flying type moves and yet almost EVERY pokemon can? almost every pokemon in OU i have noticed can learn Arial ace, and if not arial ace Acrobatics!

The fact that barely any Pokemon run Aerial Ace or Acrobatics... yeah. I have no idea how this has anything to do with competitive tiers though...

Gyarados is strong enough, and can fly, yet can't learn Fly or any Flying-type moves for that matter.

It can learn Bounce. That's the main problem, Gyarados is strong. It can bounce but it can't fly. It's like humans in a way. We can jump but we can't fly... without some kind of help.
 
Why can't Scyther learn Fly?! like even if it evolves into scizor it should still be able to fly!

Gyarados can't learn any flying type moves and yet almost EVERY pokemon can? almost every pokemon in OU i have noticed can learn Arial ace, and if not arial ace Acrobatics!

It is probably not strong enough to lift the trainer up?

Although Yanmega is said to, even though it cannot learn Fly. That said, the Pokedex is mostly fantasy...

And Gyarados has even been shown to fly in the Anime. -_-
 
It is probably not strong enough to lift the trainer up?

Although Yanmega is said to, even though it cannot learn Fly. That said, the Pokedex is mostly fantasy...

And Gyarados has even been shown to fly in the Anime. -_-

You mean when it comes to strength... Pidgey > Scyther?

We may as well face it, its Pokelogic. Meaning no real logic can understand it.
 
Since we're already picking on Gyarados. It's been bothering me since gen 1. I could never wrap my head around the idea of Gyarados being Water/Flying instead of Water/Dragon. Dragon typing would be more appropriate from both visual and cultural reference points of view. I'm not even sure if Gyarados was ever portrayed as flying instead of swimming (with the exception of few games where all water Pokemon float anyway). After all these years, I still believe it was a mistake made in the first game that was never corrected for the sake of consistency.
 
You mean when it comes to strength... Pidgey > Scyther?

We may as well face it, its Pokelogic. Meaning no real logic can understand it.


Possibly, yes.

Perhaps physics do not work in the Pokemon world as they do here, perhaps due to some disturbance in nature on a scale covering the whole world?
 
Since we're already picking on Gyarados. It's been bothering me since gen 1. I could never wrap my head around the idea of Gyarados being Water/Flying instead of Water/Dragon. Dragon typing would be more appropriate from both visual and cultural reference points of view. I'm not even sure if Gyarados was ever portrayed as flying instead of swimming (with the exception of few games where all water Pokemon float anyway). After all these years, I still believe it was a mistake made in the first game that was never corrected for the sake of consistency.

Gyarados isn't Water/Dragon because of balance - in basically every game it is common and available very early, so it would not be fair to have a Dragon so early. Having said this, it is still a Dragon despite not being of the type.

AWildMew said:
Possibly, yes.

Perhaps physics do not work in the Pokemon world as
they do here, perhaps due to some disturbance in
nature on a scale covering the whole world?

Come on you can't be serious. Scyther is taller and weighs more, meaning that it should be able to lift the player.
Pidgey is 1 foot tall and weighs 4lb, if the player tries to fly on it, it will be crushed.
 
Gyarados isn't Water/Dragon because of balance - in basically every game it is common and available very early, so it would not be fair to have a Dragon so early. Having said this, it is still a Dragon despite not being of the type.
Which would be my next nitpick. Why is that Dragon type is supposed to be some kind of superior type that should not be accessible early in the game? Guess GF thought the same when they came up with Fairy type.
 
Which would be my next nitpick. Why is that Dragon type is supposed to be some kind of superior type that should not be accessible early in the game? Guess GF thought the same when they came up with Fairy type.

Most Dragon-types have extraordinary stats and brilliant movepools, so they are a bit op for the beginning of every game. On top of this, Dragons typing is quite good (upto Gen V anyway) with just two weaknesses and plenty of resilience. Ice and Dragon themselves are rare at the start, so the start should be easy with a dragon.
 
Back
Top