• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Nitpicking.

Obviously, it does not respect you. It respects you too little to even consider you worthy of rebelling against. When it does listen to you, it respects you greatly and obeys you. Remember, any Pokemon you catch yourself obeys you because it has seen your competence in battle with its own eyes, while you were battling it in order to catch it.

In that case, they should advise the main character to keep an eye on his soda, food, and backpack. Wouldn't want something to happen to them when he isn't present but his pokemon are. Are you sure that's lemonade?

Your concept of why pokemon obey trainers is very much more trainer-centered than is the idea I presented. Trainer-centered because the pokemon are spiteful (want to hurt the trainer's career) while not really doing anything like running away that helps their own situation of being with an incompetent or careless trainer who is constantly getting them hurt.

They obey or ignore you to help or hurt you in your career respectively. Pokemon might want to become strong, but that's dependent on how many times you use them in battle, not what awards you've been given. They themselves don't share in your career success.

The problem is your goal of becoming a pokemon master is a goal thought up by your mind. Most pokemon wouldn't be smart enough to realize that the trainer has his or her own mind and goals. Chimps and children under the age of 5 generally can't do this mental feat. To rephrase, based on intelligence level, the pokemon should consider itself to be the center of its own universe with the trainer's behavior towards it being indicative of whether the trainer is a good or bad trainer. That is happiness, not badges.

I'd rather have disobedience be based on their happiness. Maybe, you get better at making them happier faster, but the "happy to obey" model is more realistic.

Presumably, a pokemon would see your competence in battle every time it is sent out. It being more intelligent than a four year old human in your model.
 
Last edited:
It's like almost your character's size and it blocks the whole space. And it's a tree; it's branches will probably scar you if you even climb over or around it.

Yes but when you go into battle your dude is skinny so you think, hmmm why cant I just duck around it. Or for crying out loud, how hard is it to climb a picket fence. It's not even electric.
 
I hate how trainer battles still have the "RUN" option that doesn't do anything.
 
I would love an option to dispense multiple items at a time from vending machines. The items in them are usually cheaper and sometimes even better!

I'm talking about the Lemonade/Soda Pops/Fresh Waters etc, but you have to buy them ONE AT A TIME ugh.
 
In that case, they should advise the main character to keep an eye on his soda, food, and backpack. Wouldn't want something to happen to them when he isn't present but his pokemon are. Are you sure that's lemonade?

Your concept of why pokemon obey trainers is very much more trainer-centered than is the idea I presented. Trainer-centered because the pokemon are spiteful (want to hurt the trainer's career) while not really doing anything like running away that helps their own situation of being with an incompetent or careless trainer who is constantly getting them hurt.

They obey or ignore you to help or hurt you in your career respectively. Pokemon might want to become strong, but that's dependent on how many times you use them in battle, not what awards you've been given. They themselves don't share in your career success.

The problem is your goal of becoming a pokemon master is a goal thought up by your mind. Most pokemon wouldn't be smart enough to realize that the trainer has his or her own mind and goals. Chimps and children under the age of 5 generally can't do this mental feat. To rephrase, based on intelligence level, the pokemon should consider itself to be the center of its own universe with the trainer's behavior towards it being indicative of whether the trainer is a good or bad trainer. That is happiness, not badges.

I'd rather have disobedience be based on their happiness. Maybe, you get better at making them happier faster, but the "happy to obey" model is more realistic.

Presumably, a pokemon would see your competence in battle every time it is sent out. It being more intelligent than a four year old human in your model.

Pokemon are nearly, if not more intelligent than humans. In your logic, Dragonite, Alakazam, etc. should always obey the trainer.

The trainer is providing the Pokemon with free food. Gameplay and Story Segregation does not let us see this, but the Pokemon receives food from the trainer, so it has another reason to stick with the trainer, but not obey their commands unless they are competent enough.

And when did the Pokemon stop taking part in the trainer's career? The Pokemon who worked so hard for the trainer goes down in the Hall of Fame. It does depend on the awards you are given. A badge is not just a badge, it is a symbol of the trainer's competence. It is perfectly realistic, too.

The Pokemon, thus, has reasons to neither run away nor attack the trainer. Along with this, the battle performance depends on whether they respect the trainer enough to obey them or not. It is when a Pokemon respects its trainer that it realizes how grateful it should be to its trainer and obeys him or her. Happiness is not related to respect. A Pokemon can be really happy with the trainer, but not grateful enough to obey them unless it respects them.
 
Pokemon are nearly, if not more intelligent than humans. In your logic, Dragonite, Alakazam, etc. should always obey the trainer.

No, I'm saying only Alakazam and Dragonite should disobey you out of spite and for lack of respect of you because they understand that they are deliberately ruining your career.

The others, mentally being the center of their own universe, should just be trying to escape if they aren't happy being your pokemon. To understand that you as a trainer have a career and long term goals independent of their own takes a great deal of cleverness. So, the world to the dumber pokemon is simply them, everyone and everything else, and the effect everyone and everything else has on them. All other interactions between characters and environment are invisible. They will never consider that some action or circumstance could have a different effect on someone else than it does on themselves. You haven't spent that much time around young children, have you?

If they are ALL as intelligent as adult humans and have the power to have flames materialize from their bodies and similar phenomena, humans are f'ed.
I conceive of pokemon as being considerably less intelligent than you do.

The Pokemon, thus, has reasons to neither run away nor attack the trainer.

It is when a Pokemon respects its trainer that it realizes how grateful it should be to its trainer and obeys him or her. Happiness is not related to respect. A Pokemon can be really happy with the trainer, but not grateful enough to obey them unless it respects them.

I do do things for free food.

I would say Happiness is necessary but is not sufficient for respect. It sounds fishy to say that "I hate X person, but I respect him. So, I will do whatever he says willingly." Positive or negative opinions about someone or something tend to correlate with each other. If we hate someone's behavior, we start hating his or her appearance and personality traits also even if we don't have sufficient independent justification to hate these other characteristics. The proof is that it is almost NEVER justified to hate everything about some other individual or, for that matter, to like everything about some other individual. Yet, we do form these blanket opinions.
 
Cutting down trees, moving boulders, is the whole purpose of the game for battling gyms and being able to use HM's outside of battle...
 
No, I'm saying only Alakazam and Dragonite should disobey you out of spite and for lack of respect of you because they understand that they are deliberately ruining your career.

The others, mentally being the center of their own universe, should just be trying to escape if they aren't happy being your pokemon. To understand that you as a trainer have a career and long term goals independent of their own takes a great deal of cleverness. So, the world to the dumber pokemon is simply them, everyone and everything else, and the effect everyone and everything else has on them. All other interactions between characters and environment are invisible. They will never consider that some action or circumstance could have a different effect on someone else than it does on themselves. You haven't spent that much time around young children, have you?

If they are ALL as intelligent as adult humans and have the power to have flames materialize from their bodies and similar phenomena, humans are f'ed.
I conceive of pokemon as being considerably less intelligent than you do.



I do do things for free food.

I would say Happiness is necessary but is not sufficient for respect. It sounds fishy to say that "I hate X person, but I respect him. So, I will do whatever he says willingly." Positive or negative opinions about someone or something tend to correlate with each other. If we hate someone's behavior, we start hating his or her appearance and personality traits also even if we don't have sufficient independent justification to hate these other characteristics. The proof is that it is almost NEVER justified to hate everything about some other individual or, for that matter, to like everything about some other individual. Yet, we do form these blanket opinions.

Considering the amount of Alakazam, humans are in trouble, anyway, so your argument is invalid.

No, you do not have to like your trainer to be happy. You can simply be happy because all your needs are fulfilled and you do not need to work for it.

Pokemon are not as powerful as you think. Arceus, who could take on the Creation Trio all by itself without breaking a sweat was quite easily defeated by humans. Even if someone is extremely intelligent, they are not omniscient.
 
I don't understand why Gender Ratios for starters and Eevee are so weird. It should just be 50% Girl and 50% Boy.
 
I thought about the anime, but I was referring to the games themselves. The system in the games doesn't make sense, which is why the anime probably diverged from it. Anyways, only Ash and his friends ask a pokemon if it chooses to come with the group. Every other trainer in the anime uses the system of throwing pokeballs, capturing and training. No permission is involved.

Arceus is still considered a super-powerful pokemon even if you object to the word "God."

Agreed, the whole "Arceus is not a god thing" that some people are claiming is untrue. It is clearly stated in the trio of sinnoh movies that Palkia and Dialga are basically deities (therefore Arceus as the master is logically treated as the highest of deities). Look up deities and "amazingly" you find that god is a synonym of that. So despite that fact that so many religious people or mew fans throw hissy fits about calling Arceus a god, the fact that the movies and dex entries constantly state that Arceus was and likely is treated as a god in the Pokemon world means that i will consider arceus a Pokegod still.

i challenge you to say(or type rather) a 7 letter (COMMON!) name

Dominic =D, love my name!
 
Last edited:
Somebody mentioned this earlier, but it seems like a good topic here too.

The fact that you get little to no recognition from most NPCs after becoming the regional Champion. You'd think the general populace should know who their Champion is. It'd be like me not knowing who the hell Obama is if I saw him.
 
Somebody mentioned this earlier, but it seems like a good topic here too.

The fact that you get little to no recognition from most NPCs after becoming the regional Champion. You'd think the general populace should know who their Champion is. It'd be like me not knowing who the hell Obama is if I saw him.

I was just about to say this! I mean, you get reference for the Slowpoke Well thing from like 4 NPCs, but not for beating the story?

When the anime/special uses the Elite Four as a tournament for trainers!
 
I was just about to say this!

When the anime/special uses the Elite Four as a tournament for trainers!

Well, actually if you beat the Tournament, only then can you challenge the Elite Four, the title of winning the Tournament is only honorary.


But, the fact that nobody ever acknowledges that their Region/World/Universe is in grave danger, while they just take their psuedo-random steps and talk about what they should buy today.
 
I thought about the anime, but I was referring to the games themselves. The system in the games doesn't make sense, which is why the anime probably diverged from it. Anyways, only Ash and his friends ask a pokemon if it chooses to come with the group. Every other trainer in the anime uses the system of throwing pokeballs, capturing and training. No permission is involved.

Arceus is still considered a super-powerful pokemon even if you object to the word "God."

Well, do you really think Pokeballs, which are so fragile that they break by merely falling to the ground sometimes, can keep an Arceus captured? I do not think so. It probably shows the trainer's competence, being able to weaken the Pokemon, thus why Pokemon decide to follow the trainer. When a Pokemon thinks its trainer is competent enough, it does not resist escaping from the Pokeball.

And Master Balls always catch because the very fact that a trainer has it shows his or her competence.

That, I agree with. But that is also why it is not imprisoned against its will.
 
Last edited:
Sootopolis City.
Opelucid City.

In BW Opelucid they merely contemplated wether to keep their Pokémon or not.

Besides, releasing Pokémon isn't exactly a danger.

And in B2W2 Opelucid only 4 people were able to be talked to and they did basically nothing but say Dragon Types are weak against Ice, and asking how all the ice got there.

Not exactly acknowledging the situation.

Sootopolis City I'll have to give to you.
 
Back
Top