I don't think you gave them enough pokeblocks. Kelpsy right? You need to feed them until their luster is full. (1 full circle of stars) Don't know/care what you were saying in the Slaking part. And PKRS/Brace does not affect pokeblocks.
-sheen being full just means they won't eat anymore pokeblocks
-I have a bunch of those really good berries and i was using watmel to raise cute on my igglybuff, but watmel pokeblocks (with three ppl making them) raises cute and cool so i saved after every pokeblock i made and used, (watmel take forever to grow i dont wanna waste them), and the last pokeblock I fed it only raised cool so it was full on the cute part.
-the guy in slateport that gives your pokemon the scarf for a maxed out stat gave it a pink scarf(which i used in the contest)(this actually happened with all 5 pokemon in all 5 contests master rank only though)
-but what you said about the sheen is true, it will still eat more pokeblocks, just not to raise cute, I'll try feeding until it gets full and get back to you on that
-the igglybuff in question didnt like that color of pokeblocks BUT that's kind of irrelevant because my absol liked the cool/smart pokeblocks i was giving it but still got only one heart over ppls heads, the only result of it liking was it got 6 sheen stars around it's pic, instead of seven, cuz i fed it less pokeblocks to get it to full luster in that stat
-for my contest pokemon I use belue for cool, durin for smart, watmel for cute, pamtre for tough, and spelon for beauty, those are the highest i know of that go in pokeblocks unless you have an e-reader, so there has to be some other explanation...
-If crudent comes back, are kelpsy blocks really good, like should I switch to them instead?
-BTW luster is how much the individual stat is raised and sheen is how much they will still eat