I just wanted to bump this topic back up the slots, because I feel it's a valid point of discussion and none of these "Craft of RPGing" should really get lost amongst the various game discussion threads. First and foremost, the Discussion Forum should be about exploring ideas and concepts relating to RPGing.
Now, to (re)start the discussion, I'll begin by stating how I very recently was confronted with a dilemma pertaining to this topic. A member (unnamed so as not to point fingers - We'll call "him"..."Hugo" for now) inquired about a character in an RPG I'm running (Planeswalkers - Sign up now![/shameless self-promotion]). This was a character that he brought along to every RPG he plays, from what I understand. Now, I can certainly understand the draw there. When designing my characters I often re-use phrases or even whole paragraphs, especially if I'm very fond of the way that paragraph/phrase/overall language served to describe that aspect of my character and it is appropriate for my next one.
For instance, in my now-abandoned "Weapons" RPG, I had a few good phrases in the Appearance and Personality sections for my character Jareth, that would fit quite well in the same sections for my "Planeswalkers" character - Lance. Lance himself was essentially a transplant (personality-wise) of a character I'd developed for my "Armored Core" RPG. The personality I developed for him there fit very well with one of the worlds in Planeswalkers, and with Armored Core finishing before its time, I felt more comfortable bringing Lance into the other RPG. Planeswalkers-Jareth, also, was a bit of a transplant, though that was mainly in name only, as his appearance, personality, and history were radically different from Weapons-Jareth.
So in short: I knew I'd reused and rehashed old concepts and characters between RPGs. Who was I to tell Hugo that he couldn't?
But as we got to talking about how he would adapt his utility-character into the RPG, it started to become apparent that he wasn't really talking about adapting the character to the RPG, but the RPG to the character. Part of it--yes--was because Planeswalkers allows players to create their own backgrounds and worlds and gives a lot of freedom in that regard. But I got the feeling that he was less concerned with making his character fit, and more concerned with making the RPG fit. And I was becoming less and less comfortable with the idea.
So I suggested that maybe he should create a new character, one that wasn't held back and down by preconceptions and preexisting conditions. At this point, Hugo seemed to lose interest. And I suppose that's understandable. I'd been subtly and not-so subtly shooting down ideas and then suggested that he completely change how he RPGs. I don't hold any grudges for that.
In the end, Hugo and I went our separate ways without any sort of animosity...I'm hoping. But my dilemma reminded me of this thread and how important it is for characters to be unique and grow according to the RPG they're in. Characters don't always fit in every RPG, and sometimes it's better not to force them into that position. So with that in mind, I thought back to the question: Who was I to tell Hugo that he couldn't reuse his character in my RPG when I was essentially doing quite a bit of the same?
I was the GM. That's who.
Sometimes reusing the same character, whether it's in name, personality, appearance, or history, or any combination therein; just comes off as lazy. Sometimes an RPG asks you to change so much of what came before, that it just makes more sense to create an entirely new character. Having only one character, or trapping yourself with that character means you're essentially holding yourself hostage to your ideas. And that should never be the case.
If you're going to reuse a character, make the character fit the RPG, not the other way around.
I'll go back to Lance for further examples. A lot of my writing now--be it for my graduate work or my for-fun/fan-work--is focused on the darkness within people. Not "evil," but the selfish need for survival. Lance is the full embodiment of my experimentation with that idea. I don't have to be literary with him, I don't have to constrain myself to believable worlds and plot structures and all that sort of stuff. I can go wild and down and deep and really figure out the extremes of that selfish need. RPGs are the perfect place for that, and Armored Core was probably the perfect fit for him. That was "pure Lance". He was completely (biologically) human, living essentially in our world (just with giant Mecha), and limited by human constraints.
Planeswalker Lance is different. It's the same core idea: the dark, selfish need and hunger, but I take it to a more literal level. Planeswalkers is based in fantasy, and the embodiment of dark hunger in fantasy is the vampire myth. So I brought that into his character. At the same time, there needs to be a counter-point to the dark hunger. A "nobility" that makes Lance somewhat sympathetic. It's the awareness of his darkness and his conflicting feelings towards it that make him so interesting for me. But this was Lance on a much more fantastic scale. More dramatic, more over-the-top. That was just the nature of the RPG. So while I carried the "core" of the character over from Armored Core (get it?) so much of the peripheral had to change that he's really become his own character. His "darkness" isn't the result of some outside tragedy. It's a result of his own doing. He did it (gave it) to himself. For noble reasons? Maybe. On purpose? Probably not. But it adds a whole new layer and side to the character in that he's now dealing with a heap of guilt and regret...or should be, if it weren't for the "voice" of the darkness telling him not to.