• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Solid Champion Poll

Vote for the best entry here!


  • Total voters
    27
  • Poll closed .
ChampBan_01.png

ChampBan_02.png
ChampBan_04.png
ChampBan_06.png

ChampBan_07.png

Another Week, Another Champion​

First of all, thank you all for voting in the initial polls for Week 125! We shall now have our champion poll where the top 4 entries will battle it out!

Remember the theme was "solid" and spriters were told to make a trainer cosplay out of any Rock type Pokémon.

You can only vote for one entry so good luck to the top!

Pokechuppa
http://i52.*******.com/2jaalow.png
Pokemazter3001
iaza18116469873700.gif
Nick Alert
http://i53.*******.com/2i08wvs.png
Proby3
iaza18507237726800.gif
 
I vote for Pokechuppa because I think the Wargle (?) dress really suits the trainer.

But it was hard deciding since the other three were good as well. Pokemazter3001's was very good as well but I chose Pokechuppa's in the end. For Nick Alert's sprite, it had a high quality too but the things on his back would be weird. xD For Proby3's, the pants are weird since it has quite a thick outline and the things on his head are oddly placed. But good nonetheless. :)
 
It seems fair enough now to say that I've lost. Which is totally unfathomable. Here's why;

Pokechuppa-

Well, a lack of originality coupled with some obvious C+P won't be getting you my vote. There were what, four other entries with Archen? Come on. Don't be taking someone's idea from them. It's low, and extremely lame. The tail and tail feathers are obviously straight from the sprite itself, which isn't the goal of a cosplay. There should be no fusing. Just scratch. You didn't even bother to shade the underside feathers on the tail either, and just left it as a solid colour. Why you have nine votes is for one reason only. The voting is done via looks, not quality. This bothers me.

Nick Alert-

I severely underlooked your entry. What originally threw me off was the tentacles, and the lack of shading on the bottom right ones, and how the tentacles and mouth were just copied onto the sprite. What I overlooked however, was the helmet, and what you managed to do with the hair of the original sprite. It was absolutely clever. The ball, I see is part of the shell, but in all retrospect, it could have been forgone.

Proby3-

This is why the WSC sucks ever since the old pro's such as WPS quit entering. Everything is either hardcore C+P, or the voting is wrecked by the "stupid" voters, as they chose via looks, not via quality, effort, and originality. This should have been a race between you and I, with maybe another wildcard. We outdid them, and honestly, it should have been either you or I to win this week. What we did was scratch our costumes, or what we added to the existing sprite, which is the goal of a cosplay. In fact, ours are the only two to natually look like the cosplayed Pokemon. The others don't have that quality. It takes effort to do this, not just a clever idea. Thats what makes them original.

Just to inform those yet to vote, or who didn't chose my vote because of the simplicity, let me clear the air for you.

The main featurette of my cosplay is obviously the head. You look at it, and you can immediately tell that my goal was Rhydon, and so far, mission accomplished. The horn was heavily edited off the pre-existing horn of the HG/SS trainer sprite, but with a custom sprial and shading. The ears, side facial horns were done via scratch, as fusing them is one, illegal, and two, looked horrible. As we move on to the torso, yeah, I crashed a bit here. The body was okay, but just too plain. I could have done more there. Take a look at the hands. You noticed that nothing related to the outline was changed. The shading however, was. When you compare it's original light-source to the reso fot he sprite, they just don't fit. Thus, I changed it up to fit moreso. The legs and tail however, are the final selling point. Did none of you catch the tail details? All that should have been able to sell my cosplay as the immediate or second place winner behind Proby.

I voted Proby3 for quality, effort, and originality. Quit voting for looks or what you think is your favorite. That isn't the goal of these polls. the goal is to display who tried and performed their hardest. It's why spriters such as WPS left. They were being outvoted by horrible sprites. Quit down-grading those who actually deserve to win by voting for those that you think look cool or cute. If this is how you vote, you're an absolute moron.

Quality, effort, originality. Quality, effort, originality.

On that note, and sorry for the wall of text, but either Zadros or Sweet May, I believe it may be in our interest to set up an outside voting pannel like Keckleoshrew had for his contests. It allows for an unbiased opinion on the sprites themselves, and allows for the high-quality sprites to actually come out where they belong. This public voting, if it doesn't improve, needs to stop. I'm disgusted that the copy-and-paste sprites are winning, not those what have had the effort to include scratching, and or proper fusing. Some of the poeple in the WSC HoF do not deserve to be there.
 
My vote goes to Pokechuppa. For me it has the best flow and overall quality of the four, and has the most amount of skill shown.

@Pokemazter: You need to calm down. Obviously you'll think yours is the best, but in reality all you did was drawn some lines, change the colors, and possibly make the horn larger. The polls are used so that anyone, even someone who didn't enter, can vote unbiased, whereas one or two judges might choose a sprite if they're closer friends to them or whatever. It's okay if someone votes on looks, that's something to consider in making spites. Just because you aren't winning doesn't mean you go on a rant about how it's "unfathomable" how you're losing. You can just try again next time.
 
Lol be quite dude. Thanks for the good comments, and the tentacles were actually scratch and the mouth was originally part of the trainer.
Anyways pokechuppa does have the best, in my opinion. It looks great and natural.
Yours, pokemazter, looks good, but the costume was already part of the original trainer. You really didn't do much to change it, all you did was change the shirt and head and recolored. You didn't do much work at all, which is hypocritical to how you said that a lot of other people just copy and pasted. Well you didn't even do that, you took the original sprite, edited a few pixels and called it a day.
I applaud you for being so defensive, and trying to come up with some legit C&C for the others, but your argument is invalid.
 
Wow that is not cool....
Pokemasterz, you are wrong. I thought as soon as I saw yours and the other with your trainer (+ Graveler) I thought it was unoriginal, more then any other entry, I just didn't go an yell it out to everybody. You're terrible. If you had made the top and the pants and perhaps only the hat by yourself, it would have been 200 per cent better already, but you didn't do that, it was all made for you. The stripes on your sprites stumach are not properly done, uneven spacing, and bad shading, where its nearly the only thing you made yourself. I think mine was a lot better then yours, I just didn't made a bible out of my opinions. I scratched a lot of it including the hat and the top of the jacket, just not everything. It can have some amount of fusing or all fusion if it needs be, if it looks good its what voters like, so why not do that. Don't go thinking you're better then anybody else, you're not. You made it to the champion poll man, stop whinning, I didn't, but guess what, I entered the next contest for another chance at it, I didn't panic. Relax.
 
It seems fair enough now to say that I've lost. Which is totally unfathomable. Here's why;

Pokechuppa-

Well, a lack of originality coupled with some obvious C+P won't be getting you my vote. There were what, four other entries with Archen? Come on. Don't be taking someone's idea from them. It's low, and extremely lame. The tail and tail feathers are obviously straight from the sprite itself, which isn't the goal of a cosplay. There should be no fusing. Just scratch. You didn't even bother to shade the underside feathers on the tail either, and just left it as a solid colour. Why you have nine votes is for one reason only. The voting is done via looks, not quality. This bothers me.

I voted Proby3 for quality, effort, and originality. Quit voting for looks or what you think is your favorite. That isn't the goal of these polls. the goal is to display who tried and performed their hardest. It's why spriters such as WPS left. They were being outvoted by horrible sprites. Quit down-grading those who actually deserve to win by voting for those that you think look cool or cute. If this is how you vote, you're an absolute moron.

Quality, effort, originality. Quality, effort, originality.

Some of the poeple in the WSC HoF do not deserve to be there.

Well, I'd just like to point out how over the top and over opinionated your post was. I don't think you should be speaking for the world of Serebiiforums, because you are just one person, with one narrow-minded and biased view. Just because your sprite (that you obviously think is victorious and superior over all,) has actually turned out not as successful as its original intention, doesn't mean you should slate the other entries apart. I don't think anyone asked you to C+C on there sprites, perhaps you could explain why and who you voted for, but there is no need for you to tear the other entries apart, just for your mere self satisfaction and enjoyment. I think your post completely contradicts itself, and just portrays jealousy in its purest form. This is a little sprite competition, I see it as a bit of fun... So should everyone. WSC should be enjoyable... So I suggest that you calm down.

As for the 'obvious C+P', I'm aware of what I took from the original Archen sprite, and what was then added to my trainer. But as you can see it's not just plonked onto the trainer sprite in a random order, there was some work to make each piece fit well with my trainer. I did not copy anyone elses entry for this WSC, I looked through all the appropriate rock type Pokemon as soon as I saw the new WSC post, and picked my favourite. I am pleased with the end result of my sprite, and I will not be criticised for petty C+P comments, I feel my sprite worked well together in total, and I did just as much work on my sprite as your supposedly did on yours.

You rant on about biased voting, and how the public are merely voting for the sprite that looks the best and not the one with the highest quality. Yet I think it's just as important that the quality and effort is just as good as how the sprite looks, as well as how it all works together. You can't have people voting (however much you might want them to) for a sprite, just because the spriter spent alot of time and worked his hardest on it. Especially when the end result is a predictable mash up that doesn't necessarily work as well as some of the other entries.

You obviously worked hard on your entry, based on how victorious you feel you should be, but like the others have said, it was somewhat predictable that someone would use the Pokemaniac sprite since all the cosplaying costume design is practically done for you; It shows little effort and originality. Which you hypocritically accused everyone else in the Champion poll for. I think Lucario9 pretty much summed up what you edited from the original sprite to create your entry.
You need to calm down. Obviously you'll think yours is the best, but in reality all you did was drawn some lines, change the colors, and possibly make the horn larger.

I think your rant just shows jealousy, and I suggest maybe not being so psychotic about WSC, it runs every week, and it's just a bit of fun. So I'd advise that you stop getting so upset about who wins, or who doesn't. The public are voting, and you can't do anything about it, so chill out and deal with it. Stop whinning like a little kid just because you 'didn't win this week'. There's always next week, and the week after, and the week after, etc, etc.

End.
​
 
Last edited:
Alors, it is evaluating time s'il vous plaît! I shall evalute the final 4 contestants and explain why I chose who I chose.

http://i52.*******.com/2jaalow.png
This is a very classy sprite with a vivid taste. The choice of using the feathers for the sleeves is a fashionable thing to do. I am not altogether impressed with this sprite, but it is a solid effort. One person evaluated that you were unoriginal for choosing Archen, but I disagree. As you have said before, my good man, we should choose whatever subject we find best for such a contest. My suggestion would be that you could've scratched the feather on the head to make it more natural and thus giving it a...more professional taste.

My Grade:C

iaza18116469873700.gif

Ah, the well known Pokémaniac. The taste of this sprite is bland like saltine crackers, and yet, it accomplishes its purpose. I see now that yes, you have added your own style to the original sprite by turning it into a Rhydon. You are playing off the features of the original sprite. I do not consider this sprite very original. Even if this sprite had more effort in it, I would only give it a B at most due to the subject matter.

My Grade:C

http://i53.*******.com/2i08wvs.png
This entry is quite unlikely! Its taste is like a foreign dish, augmented by the sharpest of spices. Your subject, an ancient Omastar, was incorporated into the sprite in a pleasing way. I commend you for turning that soccer ball into a fossil, as well. The Omastar emblem on his shirt was a nice touch, and the helmet completes the image! I can tell the tentacles were difficult to scratch for you, but it's alright. We all need to improve. I would've chose this entry if I had two votes.

My Grade:B

iaza18507237726800.gif

By process of elimination, you can see I chose Proby3's Terrakion cosplay. It was a very clever decision to choose Terrakion, and it fits Wake well. I enjoy how you scracthed the crown. Overall, the taste of this sprite is dusty like a well seasoned chicken, but tender due to the dynamic colouring. However, I admit I like your sprite just a little bit more than Nick Alert's. You both put considerable effort intto your sprites, but I expected more out of the competition. You still had my vote, though.

My Grade:B

These were my reasons for choosing the entry I did, and my evaluation! Let's all make the next WSC just as grand!
 
Thankyou for your evaluation Enel, I greatly appreciate the comments you've added.
I can see now that I was somewhat lazy with my sprite, although it seemed popular, I could have done so much more with it. Ho-hum.

I'd just like to add how nice it looks seeing all 4 of the sprites visable together.
Each entry had its good and bad points, and this WSC in particular has a selection of strong entries, and strangely I think they all look really good together.
Perhaps a future Serebii project? Cosplay dex??? ;D​

~ P​
 
Last edited:
Back
Top