• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Soon...

portadisimawru0.jpg


nsblossomqf9.jpg
 
Last edited:
No offence, but it scares me, the art is reallg good. I can't crit though because I'm afraid of blood and pain so I can't really look at it for too long but, other than that, it's good.
;151;
 
Not bad at all. A bit emo for my liking, but whatevs. On to the critiquing.

First thing I noticed was his legs. They're long. Really, really, really, really... really long. Where his knees are now is actually not too far above where his ankles should go. They also appear quite thin, and the length brings that out even more. He also seems to have no hips at all, but the only thing helpful I can say in that regard is to add hips. *shrug*

His neck is also incredibly thin. If you look at your own neck in the mirror, you should see that it's actually about the same width as your head, if not slightly narrower. Granted, you can take some artistic liberties with the style you're using, but you've taken it quite a bit too far.

His chest isn't formed quite right, either. With his arm splayed to the side as it it, the corresponding pectoral muscle is supposed to be stretched and flattened across the body, which would make it so there's less lines to draw. The pec on the other side is a little more right, since that arm is angled downward, causing the muscle to contract and making it slightly more pronounced.

You have a good start with the collarbone, but a good idea would be to try connecting the out edge of the V-shaped muscles to that, and let the nape of the neck be defined by the inner part of the V. Like this:

Code:
      |\  \   /  /|
 ____/__\  \_/  /__\____
/                       \

It's a cruddy diagram, but I hope it conveys my message.

Now, the belly area isn't too bad, but those lines don't really need to define the sides, especially with skinnier guys like him. If they must stay, make them more faint, and have them more like a slight inward slope on each side rather than outward.

His arms are actually done very nicely with the exception of his left hand. It actually appears more mangled than the one on his injured arm. I guess the best advice I have is to look at your own hand for reference, and work from there. Hands are intricate, tricky things to draw due to the very nature of their complexity, so don't get discouraged if it doesn't turn out right the first few times.

The last thing I need to mention is the text. Up top is fine, but due to how busy the flowery bottom half is, the text there is quite hard to read, despite it being outlined. I probably would have put the whole thing together, but sat it over to the guy's side or something. It should probably also be smaller, as the main focus of this is the picture.
 
Not bad at all. A bit emo for my liking, but whatevs. On to the critiquing.

First thing I noticed was his legs. They're long. Really, really, really, really... really long. Where his knees are now is actually not too far above where his ankles should go. They also appear quite thin, and the length brings that out even more. He also seems to have no hips at all, but the only thing helpful I can say in that regard is to add hips. *shrug*

His neck is also incredibly thin. If you look at your own neck in the mirror, you should see that it's actually about the same width as your head, if not slightly narrower. Granted, you can take some artistic liberties with the style you're using, but you've taken it quite a bit too far.

His chest isn't formed quite right, either. With his arm splayed to the side as it it, the corresponding pectoral muscle is supposed to be stretched and flattened across the body, which would make it so there's less lines to draw. The pec on the other side is a little more right, since that arm is angled downward, causing the muscle to contract and making it slightly more pronounced.

You have a good start with the collarbone, but a good idea would be to try connecting the out edge of the V-shaped muscles to that, and let the nape of the neck be defined by the inner part of the V. Like this:


Code:
|\ \ / /|
____/__\ \_/ /__\____
/ \It's a cruddy diagram, but I hope it conveys my message.

Now, the belly area isn't too bad, but those lines don't really need to define the sides, especially with skinnier guys like him. If they must stay, make them more faint, and have them more like a slight inward slope on each side rather than outward.

His arms are actually done very nicely with the exception of his left hand. It actually appears more mangled than the one on his injured arm. I guess the best advice I have is to look at your own hand for reference, and work from there. Hands are intricate, tricky things to draw due to the very nature of their complexity, so don't get discouraged if it doesn't turn out right the first few times.

The last thing I need to mention is the text. Up top is fine, but due to how busy the flowery bottom half is, the text there is quite hard to read, despite it being outlined. I probably would have put the whole thing together, but sat it over to the guy's side or something. It should probably also be smaller, as the main focus of this is the picture.
__________________

Ok, got it, well at least I get an idea of what you mean, but could you post or send me an image of what you mean? Just to have an example an understand fully what you are saying. BTW thanks for the critics that helps quite a lot.
 
I didn't realize a Petal Dance could have such an effect on someone's arm. This is a good reminder to stay away from those nasty sharp flowers.
 
I think what Onyx Tanuki means is that you seem to be trying for accurate human proportions and anatomy but that you're a little bit off on a few parts. I would agree; it makes it look more like "anime for anime's sake" that I am thoroughly sick of.
 
I think what Onyx Tanuki means is that you seem to be trying for accurate human proportions and anatomy but that you're a little bit off on a few parts. I would agree; it makes it look more like "anime for anime's sake" that I am thoroughly sick of.

What do you mean?
 
Okay, I did a quickie sketch for you for reference purposes, but I'll stick it into a spoiler tag so it doesn't clutter up the page. Please, don't mind the craptacular attempt at shading.

torsostudyqm9.jpg

Now my guy seems a little older than yours (who seems to be late teens), so most of the features you see on mine would be softened up slightly to give him that more effeminate shape that anime characters tend to have.

Anyway, if you look at his neck area you'll see what I was talking about. The bands of muscle form a sort of V in the center, while the outsides connect onto the top lines of the collarbones. With both arms back somewhat, the clavicle isn't going to be as apparent, though.

You can see most of the other things I mentioned in that pic too, particularly what I said about the chest, belly, and hips. I didn't sketch the legs, but you should be able to figure them out. There's hundreds of proportion reference charts you can look up on the internet.

As for Ophie's comment, I think that she meant that it seems like you forced the anime style onto the pic rather than letting it come naturally. I don't really agree with that; I just think you got the proportions messed up a bit, not that you were distorting them intentionally to make the pic more "anime." If the latter is the case, though, just keep in mind that you need to know how to do proportions correctly first before knowing how to distort them in a way that's still good-looking.
 
No no, I am still lerning to draw and all I don't handle human shape enough to have the luxury of modify it at my please, is what you said I messed some things.
 
In that case, all you need is more experience. It's the only universal way for anyone to get good at drawing. However, there are some rules of real human proportions that would help if you want to make a convincing "realistic" human.

For example, legs take up about 50% of a person's height. With yours, it took up 60% or 70%, which makes it look weird.
 
Exactly. Another thing to take into account is the head-body ratio. When someone says something is X heads tall, that means it's that many times the size of its own head. For example, the average human adult is seven to eight heads high, meaning that you could take eight of his/her head and stack them one on top of the other, and the stack would be roughly the same height as the person him/herself. That ratio is lower for younger people: infants can be three heads tall, toddlers about four, elementary-schoolers about five to six, younger teenagers six to seven. You also have to take into account that girls tend to be taller than boys between ten and twelve, since their growth spurts hit earlier than boys'.

When the arm is laid flat against the side, one's elbow should be roughly at waist level, and one's fingertips should touch about mid-thigh. Eyes are normally set one eye-width apart, and the nose is normally slightly over an eye-width high (though both can be varied depending on style, and nose length can vary more greatly in nature). As Ophie said, the legs take up about 50% of the body's height, ending at the hips. And the forearm is almost always the exact same length as the foot.

I know that it's all overwhelming, especially if you're just now diving into drawing the human body, but with practice, it'll become second nature. One thing that helps me a lot is drawing out a rough stick figure first with ball-joints and a rough ribcage, then fleshing it out with a nude figure, then adding the clothes on top of that. If that helps you out, then give it a shot.

Like I said, there's plenty of guides for human proportions on the internet, so run a search. Only reason I don't post a link myself is that a lot of them include artistic nudity, and I don't know how old you are, so I'm just going to play it safe so that if you're underaged you can get your folks' permission before looking at something like that. You might also be able to find something at your local library, or get advice from an art teacher or something.

Anyway, enough of my rambling. Don't give up, because you've got a lot of potential. Just practice, and you'll get it.
 
Well, the only criticisms I have have already been covered here. So I just have a question (though I guess you won't give me the answer, since this looks like something secret that you're going to reveal later). What is this Nightshade Blossom thing gonna be? Fanfic, fakegame, something else?
 
Back
Top