• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Standardize Testing Thread

U.N. Owen

In Brightest Day, In Blackest Night ...
I live in the United States, a country where standardize testing is synonymous with many things around the children I tutor: crying, resent, and hatred for the people who make them.

It has me wondering if these tests like the ACT, SAT, FCAT, TCAP, MCAT, or any other tests are accurate, have value, or are harmful to these children. What are your thoughts?
 
This issue is less the test and more about the overall funding. The school systems that perform the best get the funding, and they need a way to judge that, so we get standardized tests. With less and less being spent on education from the government there's a bigger focus about doing well on the tests rather than learn anything. I'm someone who thinks education should be a right and funding for education should be much higher than it is in America, and it's a bigger issue than the testing.

For the ACT and SAT it's less important, because colleges will take most people with a passable GPA if they pay now. For profit education is bad like that.
 
The state standardize test I took (TAAS/TAKS) were very pointless tests to me.

1. The teachers had to interrupt their curriculum in order to teach you how to past this test. The test asks you basic questions for the most part.
2. You don't really learn anything for or from the test. You take it for "assessment".
3. They say the test is too see if the teachers taught you right, but you get it as a test grade.
4. Some standardize test are frustrating and counter-intuitive making them inaccurate for some students to actually handle.

I'm not going into detail right now, but certain tests were very confusing to me. I once took a test to find out which books were on my reading level (you had to point collect for books you read [AR], but I didn't get the test, so I ended up with a crippling low reading level, which was not thoroughly assessed.
 
A friend of mine was a proctor for a standardize test. When he read through the instructions, there was a small section dedicated to what actions to take if a student vomits on this test. At first, I thought he was joking. He wasn't. The fact that we have expect students to get so stressed and vomit says many things about our testing system.

Also, standardize testing supports the mentality of "teaching to the test" rather than teaching skill. Back in the day, I made a 28 on the ACT Math through strategies I found in a book.
 
Last edited:
Standardized testing, in my opinion, is pointless. These tests provide little in terms of proof of knowledge, (the general busywork given in school does that), nor do they educated further. It's a nice, simple way of getting a number, which, when high, makes people think this country is smart.
SATS, ACTs, etc, aren't a viable marker for education, and simply drive off interest in certain fields.
 
In the best situation, we would be able to hold a class to a college standard.

This is not to rush students, but to give them a grasp of what college and university topics would be like.

Even if a student wouldn't go to a college level class, I at least think that critical thinking is important.

With the advent of false knowledge being spread throughout the Internet (esp. Facebook), we could use some of that.
 
I believe there is professional obsession with standardized testing surrounding the Public Education system here in the US, so much so that I believe it creates a stagnant atmosphere within the classroom. I believe the issue to be 'learning environments' that have a mapped out an academic test in mind for the student instead of life itself. Doing your taxes, learning how to grow your own food, start a fire, etcetera; those are things I personally find to be more important goals to have in mind than most of what American academia indoctrinates teaches.

The standardized testing format has become an end rather than a means to an end. What is learned? Or rather, what is retained? How do these stressful 'milestones' assist the student in their occupational future, let alone their collegiate one?
 
One thing I've noticed is how this emphasis on testing has strained the arts. Rooms that were once used for art supplies are now used for ACT/SAT prep classes or testing rooms. In other words, we're sterilizing creativity and replacing it with circles on a page. Instead of fostering the human imagination so ideas for new inventions can be made, we're killing it to create some kind of formulaic world.
 
Standardized exams are necessary, but they become an issue when schools/programs place too much emphasis on test results, and not on the other facets (school grades, ECs, personal statements) that have shaped who you are as a person.
 
Standardized exam is good and probably required. It is a life skill to memorize a certain concept or formula and apply them to problems. It is also a quick, easy and cost effective way to rank the schools, although it's legitimacy is questionable. Problem is most schools tend to be too caught up on it to a point where it is pushing aside other factors. I live in Canada, so I don't know what is going on in the states, but over here the standardized tests are really strict and high-stake, even though it really shouldn't be. I understand you need to make the test count for something, otherwise nobody would study for it and the accuracy of the data goes poof, but really? I took this test in Junior High, and the result of this test determines if I get into a certain class in High School, which basically I'm screwed in Uni if I don't take this class? This is Junior High for crying out loud, what is the point of stressing out the students this much early on? The course also has to be adjusted to match the test, and a lot of valuable class time has to be wasted in order to prep for these. If it was treated like a regular final exam, then I think it would be just fine, but for some reason these tests need special treatment.
 
Back
Top