• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

A problem

Deadly.Braviary

Well-Known Member
Background of my problem

I have a Kaiju fanfic (as in, Godzilla etc.) up on FF.net (I'm considering bringing it here). You can read it here. I'm trying to decide whether Character A (Gigan, for those familiar with Kaiju) or B (Biollante) should appear in my second story arc's finale as a new female villain.

Now, I've got something special planned for the third story arc. Char A will eventually lead into this story, so technically, she's the obvious choice for the villain. Thus, until a while ago, she was my choice of villain. HOWEVER, one day, I chanced upon Char B's page on a certain kaiju wiki and grew curious. I even dreamt an origin story for her.

My problem:

I'm frickin confused which kaiju I should choose. Char A, as I said before, is the obvious choice as she advances the story. Char B, however, seems equally interesting to write, and, if I don't include her now, I won't be able to use her until the fourth story arc, which could be 15-20 chapters away.

My solution:

I could a contest to determine which one should appear. Good idea, isn't it, to let my story's fans decide which character will appear?

The problem with my solution:

I'm afraid that I won't get enough votes to decide which one will appear. So, please guys, provide me a with a backup solution.
 
Last edited:
You, as the writer, are the only one who should control your story. The readers "voting" is not a good idea. You could lose your plot, your characters, your themes, and so on if YOU alone don't try to have them all reach their full potential. This doesn't seem to be some minor character there for comedy relief that we're voting on. It sounds like an important character who will, as you said, advance your plot. So... the voting is a huge no no, in my opinion.

I don't know much about your story or fandom, but I would personally go with Char A. As you said, Char A will advance the plot, and, when you say it's the "obvious choice," it tells me that Char A is who you REALLY want if you want to reach that full potential for all aspects of your fic. Even if Char B is 15-20 chapters away, at least it will give you something to look forward to writing (which is important if you want to stay motivated), and then you'll be using both characters instead of just one.
 
As diamondpearl876 said, leaving it to a vote isn't really the best way to go. A lot of writers think it's a "good idea" to let readers decide these kinds of things, but it simply isn't the case, except in "choose your own adventure" stories. Stories are yours to write, ans when you write you should do what works best for the story, not based on a short popularity contest.

Anyhow, it's hard to judge what character fits better since we really don't know a single thing about them. You do seem more confident about character A, however, so that sounds like a stronger choice. If the only reason you want to use character B now is because you'll have to wait to use them otherwise, that doesn't really make them sound that important/good of a choice. If you can still use them later, you could just wait until later.

~Psychic
 
Even if Char B is 15-20 chapters away, at least it will give you something to look forward to writing (which is important if you want to stay motivated), and then you'll be using both characters instead of just one.

Wow, hadn't thought of it that way. Thanks!


You do seem more confident about character A, however, so that sounds like a stronger choice. If the only reason you want to use character B now is because you'll have to wait to use them otherwise, that doesn't really make them sound that important/good of a choice. If you can still use them later, you could just wait until later.

I guess I do, so thanks guys, for helping me make up my mind!
 
Back
Top