• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Character Development?

interxavier

The Mist Vagrant
I've been a fan of the pokemon franchise since the first generation but has there really been any character development in the anime series?

I think the only development I saw was the transition from the original series to advanced generation. After his Kanto and Johto adventures, Ash really had matured in terms of training and battling. I think this is the reason why they decided to introduce May, so they can have another trainer start from scratch but head to a different route (contests).

I'm not sure about Diamond and Pearl as I only saw one complete season (Sinnoh League Victors). Has any developments occurred after during this generation?

For Black & White, it was a big MEH. It's pretty obvious that they decided to reboot the entire thing just to appeal to the new younger audience. I'm still trying to get used to this series, the same situation I had with the first season of the Diamond and Pearl saga.

Please try to take into account all the main characters, not just Ash.
 
They did not reboot for the younger fans but the older ones. Many people liked the kanto style so they went back after DP was a fail. (Filler wise not story wise) The DP plot was very good except for Dawn.
 
Pokemon as kids Tv show was never expected to be show with deep plot and complex characters who would thriough development go through drastic change.
However that doesn mean characters doesnt receive development with most notable changes happening in episodes focusing mostly on them.For example Ash went through development becoming less naive and reckless when it comes to battles with each passing sagas his battling style being developed and taken to new level aswell becoming more mature which can be noticed in Hoenn region for first time when he was able to take on role of being mentor to May not needing anymore so much help from others like he required whe he was rookie.
May went from girl which didnt liked pokemon to independant and selfconfident girl who knew what she wants realizing how she doesnt need help from others being ready to go on her own abut her career of coordinator.
Misty was in start very explosive girl not having much patience with time starting to learn to be more patient with others becoming more responsible ,overcoming some fears like one from Gyarados,getting over conflict with sisters of feeling "less worthy".

Some development can be noticed for any other character aswell.
Of course we cant expect anything complex or drastic happening with characters in children TV show but some development does happen with some darker and "deep" scenes sometimes slipping under radar.,
So far i must say Team Rocket has richest backgroundstory being more developed than most of characters.

They did not reboot for the younger fans but the older ones. Many people liked the kanto style so they went back after DP was a fail. (Filler wise not story wise) The DP plot was very good except for Dawn.

To be honest if they really wanted to please older fans they would return one of older characters back as main.Judging by petitions and demand online this is what older fans are asking the most,so im not sure about that.

BW so far seem like more of a "new start"than previous sagas but in reality pokemon anime is still treated as one big continuity with older characters and references to past existing.
 
Of course we cant expect anything complex or drastic happening with characters in children TV show

Sure we can, have you seen Avatar: The Last Airbender? That's how you do character development in a kid's show. It's not like it's beyond children to understand how people develop.

The writers of the show are just not very good. When, say, Ash learns something new, he'll only remember that something new if it's important to the plot. Otherwise, he'll more than likely forget about it. I don't think Ash ever used Counter Shield after his battle with Fantina (correct me if I'm wrong) and I know he's "relearned" things that he should have known from before.

It's really annoying but what can you do? This is a poorly-written show. *sigh*
 
Sure we can, have you seen Avatar: The Last Airbender? That's how you do character development in a kid's show. It's not like it's beyond children to understand how people develop.

The writers of the show are just not very good. When, say, Ash learns something new, he'll only remember that something new if it's important to the plot. Otherwise, he'll more than likely forget about it. I don't think Ash ever used Counter Shield after his battle with Fantina (correct me if I'm wrong) and I know he's "relearned" things that he should have known from before.

It's really annoying but what can you do? This is a poorly-written show. *sigh*

Its not poorly written its the fact its been going on for 14 seasons. I do think they should of had Ash be a master by the end of Sinnoh and for BW had Taylor (my nme for the male in Black and White) to have his own time to shine with Oshawott being his Pikachu.
 
Sure we can, have you seen Avatar: The Last Airbender? That's how you do character development in a kid's show. It's not like it's beyond children to understand how people develop.

The writers of the show are just not very good. When, say, Ash learns something new, he'll only remember that something new if it's important to the plot. Otherwise, he'll more than likely forget about it. I don't think Ash ever used Counter Shield after his battle with Fantina (correct me if I'm wrong) and I know he's "relearned" things that he should have known from before.

It's really annoying but what can you do? This is a poorly-written show. *sigh*

Maybe so but pokemon is type of show which exists mainly to serve as tool to promote new games and pokemon being its priority.
Also its not like we dont get some quality character development because you can tell some characters changed and "grow" over the years.

Speaking of Ash he received some character development over the years.Thing is this progress happen slowly and gradually making baby steps forward with each passing saga.
About counter shield again cant remember right now,but this wasnt first time he used to forget about some things.
Partially this can be pertained to being part of Ashs character having tendency to forget about things he knew before when being overly excited.
 
They did not reboot for the younger fans but the older ones. Many people liked the kanto style so they went back after DP was a fail. (Filler wise not story wise) The DP plot was very good except for Dawn.

Best Wishes isn't aimed at older fans from 15 years ago.

For the first time this series really does feel like its aimed at a new generation of kids, hence they rebooted nature of it.
 
In Best Wishes its kind of hard to say since its still early and development usually happens midway or towards the end of the series. The most notable change is Team Rocket, though, who seems to have undergone some sort of overnight transformation to become competent. It seems the writers are still trying to find the best balance between their usual antics and their new role, though.
 
In Best Wishes its kind of hard to say since its still early and development usually happens midway or towards the end of the series. The most notable change is Team Rocket, though, who seems to have undergone some sort of overnight transformation to become competent. It seems the writers are still trying to find the best balance between their usual antics and their new role, though.

It's a bit weird because in the beginning of D&P, I felt all the development Ash got in the advanced generation saga went down the drain. The sinnoh journeys, which had the most seasons, seemed to have more impact in the development of Dawn as a coordinator. For Ash's sake, it seemed more like the development of his Pokemon than himself that happened in sinnoh.

Apparently, the only main character that I've seen with consistent development is May. She really evolved into a skilled coordinator from a naive trainer in the first season of advanced generation.
 
Sure we can, have you seen Avatar: The Last Airbender? That's how you do character development in a kid's show. It's not like it's beyond children to understand how people develop.

The writers of the show are just not very good. When, say, Ash learns something new, he'll only remember that something new if it's important to the plot. Otherwise, he'll more than likely forget about it. I don't think Ash ever used Counter Shield after his battle with Fantina (correct me if I'm wrong) and I know he's "relearned" things that he should have known from before.

It's really annoying but what can you do? This is a poorly-written show. *sigh*

Avatar: The Last Airbender is a great example of a supposed kid's show that can be enjoyed by both the younger and older generations. Really, the only thing holding this show back is the writers. There's so much potential with the Pokemon anime.

Slightly off-topic, but when was the last time there was any romantic development? I can remember, even as a kid, always hoping for certain characters to get together. If BW was supposed to be a fresh start, hire some new writers while you're at it.
 
Slightly off-topic, but when was the last time there was any romantic development? I can remember, even as a kid, always hoping for certain characters to get together. If BW was supposed to be a fresh start, hire some new writers while you're at it.

Didn't the Ash/Misty love stuff end during Orange Islands/early Johto. At least that's what I think, of course 4Kids tried to add in points that added to Pokeshipping that weren't originally there, like Misty's goodbye. Other than that, I don't think love has really been a point... or mentioned :P

But, I do agree with whoever brought up Avatar. That's a great example of a show that had good character development to everyone. Pokemon just seems like a hot mess, it almost seems like we barely get development... I think that's something the writers still need to work on.
 
Slightly off-topic, but when was the last time there was any romantic development? I can remember, even as a kid, always hoping for certain characters to get together. If BW was supposed to be a fresh start, hire some new writers while you're at it.

Besides Pokemon and an occasional COTD falling for another COTD (I think there was some male and female scientist during Johto that fell in love with each oher), absolutely none.
 
Shipping in the first few seasons was only there to give Misty something to do, according to Shudo.

That's actually kind of funny. Either way, it's at least something. I know some of you will hate me for saying this, but hinting at "ships" between characters is a good way to keep people interested.. if done right.

In terms of character development, there hasn't been much in BW. Ash seems to have returned to the same kid he was during Kanto, just not as... serious? The appreciative courage he once had now almost seems like something you would laugh off.
 
In terms of character development, there hasn't been much in BW. Ash seems to have returned to the same kid he was during Kanto, just not as... serious? The appreciative courage he once had now almost seems like something you would laugh off.

Serious? He did very little training in Kanto, and spent all of his time between the 8th badge and the league goofing off.
 
Honestly, if the idea is to cater to a new generation of viewers, they could've switched up main characters for each region quite easily. It's a real shame, the B/W was one I would've love to see adapted into anime. Oh well, there's always Pokemon Special...
 
Honestly, if the idea is to cater to a new generation of viewers, they could've switched up main characters for each region quite easily. It's a real shame, the B/W was one I would've love to see adapted into anime. Oh well, there's always Pokemon Special...

The anime has pretty much established that this is Ash's journey they're following. The other in-game characters come and go, and some get their own little plots. Barry was pretty close to his in-game self, even having a similar personality, sharing at least 3 of his in-game Pokemon team, and his father being revealed as Palmer, the head of the Battle Frontier of Sinnoh.
 
Um, well, Ash did mature a bit towards the end of Sinnoh, but as soon as B/W hit, he was back to being a kid again, as Iris is fond of saying. In the league and his gym battles he planned strategies and manuevers (counter-shield comes to mind). Now, it's "hit 'em with volt tackle again and hope they faint!"
Up until B/W, I got the feeling he actually aged a year with each gen, making him about 15 at the end of sinnoh. But now he's back to a ten year old... sigh.
 
Um, well, Ash did mature a bit towards the end of Sinnoh, but as soon as B/W hit, he was back to being a kid again, as Iris is fond of saying. In the league and his gym battles he planned strategies and manuevers (counter-shield comes to mind). Now, it's "hit 'em with volt tackle again and hope they faint!"

Yeah, Oshawott using his scalesword to repel attacks isn't a unique strategy at all.

Up until B/W, I got the feeling he actually aged a year with each gen, making him about 15 at the end of sinnoh. But now he's back to a ten year old... sigh.

Anyone who has ever watched a cartoon before shouldn't be surprised that time doesn't work the same way it does in the real world.
 
Back
Top