• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Characters

Status
Not open for further replies.
Do you guys feel the anime writers have done a good job with the characters in the XY anime?

The anime has always been mostly about the characters. But I feel they could have done more with some characters here. Clemont and Trevor for example are poorly developed and are kind of just there.

What do you think about the character development in Kalos?
 
Imo Serena was the only character with decent character development. Clemont and Bonnie got some, but it wasn't much, and Ash and Team Rocket were pretty much the same throughout the series. I think the rivals weren't handled that great either.
 
Even Serena's is debatable since her accomplishments and independence feel somewhat superficially added. Winning popularity contests you already had an advantage in and curb stomping TR with heavy assistance doesn't equal finding independence.

I don't think development has been the best part of XY, arguably the only cathartic element I found to it was spotlighting how jarring all the stuff Ash (and to a lesser degree Team Rocket) have done to people who have just met them. A refreshing change from Ash being a instant undermined newbie.

The characterisations however are a different matter. While Clemont and Serena and Bonnie haven't been exactly dynamic, they are still rather endearing. Their arcs don't add up to much, and yet they can make some truly great filler episodes from their personalities. Team Rocket were sort of in a 'the best of' state this region, with bits and pieces of nearly every little depth they've gained throughout the series, and while they got formulaic and unnecessary by XYZ, they were at least still amusing. Most of the Pokemon were pretty likeable, most complaints go to the usual 'post evolution blandness' that befalls nearly every regions' roster. The only character I found rather disappointing was Ash. He wasn't awful and all the acknowledgement to his progress throughout the show was appreciated, it's just it would have been much more so if he was still fun as a character. There are just too many times he feels cardboard, especially in the English dub.
 
This is just my opinion...

Ash: while a tad better in XY(Z) than in the best wishes series, he is now a typical main shonnen character & is less interesting than goku or ******. He has no unique characteristics that seperate him from typical main male characters, and is mostly have 'positive' traits & only one time in the anime has he had done something 'wrong' (in which I'd argue with that... but that is besides the point).

Serena: typical female sterotype that has crush on the guy & does girly things. Her focus episodes I personally view as the most boring, stupid, or irratating out the main cast. Her 'development' feels forced for the situation as only her focus episodes is she really 'brave' or strong' and when she isn't focused upon she is in the sidlines letting the others do the work usually.

Clemont: yeah an interesting character!
...only in the beginning. Yeah, he has become good background once Serena got her goal, then even more so after ash got his badge. And for a guy whose goal is 'to be more brave' he surely doesn't look like he's really been going anywhere with that development.

Bonnie:
She is extremely cute. Acts like an actual little girl, except she thinks all Pokemon are cute, and doesn't scare easily. Though lately her marry-my-brother-older-lady gag has becoming much more repetive and annoying. Though it's nice to see the siblings care for each other. Her focus is cute, though she really doesn't develop. It's hard to though when she can't do much.

Sawyer: like that he's learning by listening & taking notes, & each time we see him he's been getting better. Though he came a little late to get development. And besides that, he really isn't much of an interesting character.

Alain: ok, I might get hate for this. But I find him BORING. 'Oh im bing srong 4 da ppl I luv?1!!1!1!!' Why? Oh how original. Very typical anti-hero. Don't hate him, just find him extremely uninteresting.

Marron(sp?): oh typical annoying, be in all business, clumsy character. Hasn't been done before /sarcasm

Trevor, terino, shanna (sp?): the boys just have one personally & that's obsessed with something. Trevor it's taking pictures of pokemon, teirino it's dancing and he he crush on Serena. At least shanna is a bit more, though still just typical kind, outgoing, & bubbly girl. They didn't really show often enough to develop.

Jessie, James, & meowth: personality wise, they recovered a bit from BW. Jessie is again the feared one with the boys who they only help to save them from the wrath of her anger. James is the kind but whimpy one (& they referenced his love for bottle caps again). Meowth is the decpitive brains of the group. Sad thing is, a lot of times they are extremely unnecessary and come & get blasted off almost instantly making their appearance 100% unimportant in some episodes. Say what you well on how annoying they where in DP, but when they did show their face to the group, they at least usally made things more of a struggle to achieve what COtD, ash, and co. want, and not just come in to be blasted off. Development is none, but they are stuck-in villians so I can see that would be a bit hard for them to get development.

Pokemon are good with personality... That is the unevolved pokemon. Not much going for their development unless you want to believe that all personality was taken away from them when evolved, development.

So all in all, I LIKED clemont, Bonnie I like her well enough, Pokemon are mostly cool if unevolved, TRio I'm on the fence, the rest I kinda don't care for.
 
Last edited:
I think they have all been just Meh at best. I do like Serena and Clemont's development the most but its just ok to me.
 
Ash had the best development. Serena was okay but should have focused more on the showcases than on Ash. Clemont needed more episodes for him and his pokemon. Team Rocket should have been the unova version. Bonnie was alright too. All opinions of mine.
 
Let's summarize each character in a single word:

Ash: Hero
Serena: Girly
Bonnie: Background
Clemont: Nonexistent

Tierno: Gimmick
Trevor: Gimmick
Sawyer: Fanclub
Alain: Invincible

Team Rocket: Filler
 
Let's summarize each character in a single word:

Ash: Hero
Serena: Girly
Bonnie: Background
Clemont: Nonexistent

Tierno: Gimmick
Trevor: Gimmick
Sawyer: Fanclub
Alain: Invincible

Team Rocket: Filler
You can do better than that.

Ash: Hero
Serena: Performer
Bonnie: Cute little kid
Clemont: The clever one/Inventor

Tierno: Dancer
Trevor: Photographer
Sawyer: Rookie
Alain: The serious one
 
This is better:

Ash: Hero
Serena: Performer
Bonnie: Little Girl
Clemont: Inventor

Tierno: Dancer
Trevor: Photographer
Sawyer: Rookie
Alain: Dark Hero
 
XY's characters are some of the most forgettable, underused, and badly stereotyped characters the series has ever produced. And I'm saying this as a fan of many of them. I really like Clemont, Serena, and Bonnie. That being said none of them were really used well and some were blatantly made bad to make other characters look better.

Serena's goal was terrible, the only reason I invested in it was because I liked Serena and her Pokemon. If you had taken her and Shauna out of Performances I never would have paid attention to it. Serena literally carried that goal and given how late she got it, how little screentime it got, and how rushed it concluded that just shows me the writers didn't care about Serena at all unless she was doing something Amourshipping. The character deserved so much better. Hard to believe there was a time the female lead got co-star status. I miss those days.

Clemont was entertaining but I saw his fate from day one. A punching bag to make Ash look good and nothing else. Clemont was the underdog in his Gym Battle with Ash and loses. It's laughable to even consider Clemont a threat to Ash, given how strongly they made him in XY. I can't help but wonder what was the point of Clemont's story? He never got a win on Ash and after losing that Gym he's just lingering on the cast with no purpose like Brock before him. Clemont was so cool at the start it's sad to see what his fate was. But again I saw it coming.

Bonnie's cute and entertaining. She's probably my favorite of the cast because her character worked so well in Pokemon but even she had limits. I still think they could have done something with her getting Clemont to catch Pokemon for her. It's not like Clemont was doing anything else when he wasn't jobbing to Ash. Missed chance to make both of them do something.

All the rivals are gimmicky and underused and serve no purpose other then to make the main cast look good. None of them are memorable or good. I'm bias towards Shauna though because she's Shauna. Nobodys even talking about Serena's rivals. I guess that speaks for itself. In short all the rivals were terrible and are so badly treated that they feel like the characters you should be rooting for to beat the main cast.

So basically in XY if you were not Ash, you got screwed over.
 
You can do better than that.

Ash: Hero
Serena: Performer
Bonnie: Cute little kid
Clemont: The clever one/Inventor

Tierno: Dancer
Trevor: Photographer
Sawyer: Rookie
Alain: The serious one
This is better:

Ash: Hero
Serena: Performer
Bonnie: Little Girl
Clemont: Inventor

Tierno: Dancer
Trevor: Photographer
Sawyer: Rookie
Alain: Dark Hero
Actually spelling out the gimmicks, really? That's missing the point!
 
Hmmm well pretty much Ash and Serena have had the best development while Clemont and Bonnie haven't changed much. Out of the rivals, Tierno and Trevor have been kind of weak however and Alain's development has been lacking as well, tho at least he's still important to the plot of XYZ. :]
 
Ash and Serena have had great development throughout. XY and XY&Z have been much more mature (and much better) than any other season. Never before have we seen a character struggle with depression. Never before have we seen the main female companion have an actual confirmed crush on Ash before. Ash is about to win the Kalos League too, so that is new development we haven't seen before. The amount of character development for those two has been a lot and they will continue to develop should the two be in Alola, which I'd say that,assuming Ash doesn't leave the show, is likely.

As for the other characters. Clemont never had too much development, but he was always a somewhat enjoyable character. Bonnie the troll-lord has gotten some development based on her connections to Puni-Chan, but other than that, not much development. I could say her getting a little more development during the TF Arc.

As for rivals, Shauna, Tierno, and Trevor really haven't changed. Only development from the trio is Shauna's performances but that wasn't that much. Obviously, Serena's rivals haven't changed one bit (unless you believe that Miette went from liking Ash to just pushing Serena). Shota/Sawyer got a good amount of development and is a unique character with a stacked team. I'm excited to see him and Ash face off. Alain hasn't developed, but he probably will during TF Arc.
 
I'd got a better one:

Ash: Generic Shounen Hero
Serena: Waifu
Bonnie: Little Sister
Clemont: Stooge

Tierno: Foil
Trevor: Foil
Sawyer: Rival
Alain: former Adult Hero, now Anti Villain

Its funny how everyone over exaggerates Serena's crush on Ash like she's obsessed with him even though in most of the episodes there aren't any hints.
 
Its funny how everyone over exaggerates Serena's crush on Ash like she's obsessed with him even though in most of the episodes there aren't any hints.

I mean it's the first time there's been a canon crush from the main female character to Ash so that's one reason. Secondly, there are a lot of massive moments that have happened that suggest that amourshipping is a big thing and will actually happen. I see no exaggeration on Serena's crush at all. It's a big thing to her character and important to the storyline of XY.
 
Its funny how everyone over exaggerates Serena's crush on Ash like she's obsessed with him even though in most of the episodes there aren't any hints.
I agree. But I can't blame people for thinking that when it was what most people recognized her for from the beginning and the marketing didn't help.

Even from the very debut of her character she's been known as 'Ash's childhood friend' and even on the first XY poster they showed Serena blushing while gazing at Ash thus firmly establishing her as a romance-type of character. Naturally, a lot of people tend to exaggerate when talking about Amour since the ship doesn't get nearly as much focus as people like to pretend it does, it's incredibly marginal when compared to the amount of non-Amour focus Serena was given.
 
I mean it's the first time there's been a canon crush from the main female character to Ash so that's one reason. Secondly, there are a lot of massive moments that have happened that suggest that amourshipping is a big thing and will actually happen. I see no exaggeration on Serena's crush at all. It's a big thing to her character and important to the storyline of XY.

Disagree. Ash is 10 years old so armour doesn't apply to him in the series in my opinion. It is a one sided thing and one of the reasons why Serena doesn't focus on her showcases more.
 
Disagree. Ash is 10 years old so armour doesn't apply to him in the series in my opinion. It is a one sided thing and one of the reasons why Serena doesn't focus on her showcases more.

I disagree with that. Most of the amour hints aren't even a major part of the episodes to really affect any of the Showcases. Like I said it's overexaggerated because of the fanbase and the marketing team.
 
Disagree. Ash is 10 years old so armour doesn't apply to him in the series in my opinion. It is a one sided thing and one of the reasons why Serena doesn't focus on her showcases more.

that's BS when has serena not focused on her showcases because of her crush?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top