• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Frozen: Thought?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bulba the Great!

We Do Not Sow
Hey guys,

So Frozen's been out for a while now. I saw it and loved it so much I immediately saw it again.

Now my friends seem to be split pretty evenly between LOVING it and absolutely hating every second of it. I'm curious to know everyone's thoughts on the film? Pros/cons?
 
Eh. Thought it was just alright. Kinda cheesy, although that's expected of a movie like this.

I will say, however, I thought the animation was amazing.
 
Hoo boy, here we go. You want my thoughts? You got them.

I make no plans to see this movie--at least in theaters. I love Disney to death, but what was going on during this movie's production was a bit ridiculous, in my opinion. The fact they changed their minds to make Frozen 3D instead of 2D was one of them. Just because Princess and the Frog and Winnie the Pooh didn't do well because of poor timing doesn't mean a company should forsake its roots of traditional animation which is where the Disney magic lies. Hopefully when the economy (eventually) picks itself back up, they'll reopen that department because there's still a market for 2D films.

One of the later problems came from the douchebag head animator, Lino DiSalvo, who said, "Historically speaking, animating female characters are really, really difficult, because they have to go through these range of emotions, but you have to keep them pretty and they’re very sensitive to — you can get them off a model very quickly." (Link to the article.) B'awwwwwwwww, female characters have to be pretty, so we have to take special care to make sure they're perfect Barbies for our little girls to look up to. Allow me to play for you a sad song on the world's smallest violin. Oh, and here's a counterargument from a female animator.

That was what really did it for me (next to Olaf, he's such a fugly-looking character who being marketed from hell and back because he'll appeal to the kids and being a silly side-kick). Also, the official trailer says "experience the greatest Disney animated event since The Lion King" thus raising expectations that the movie will be just as awesome (or overrated) as their biggest hit The Lion King. Why did they toot their own horn, you don't do that.

And since people are either in the love it or hate it category, something tells me people's expectations weren't exactly met. Good job, Disney. This will be the first time I'm actually renting one of your movies to see if I like it enough to give you my money. And I'm not sure how good those odds are, to be honest, especially since I thought the animation looked a bit off in the trailers.

By the way, OP, you did not say we had to have already seen the movie to talk about it. These are just my thoughts on it right now after all that has happened. And considering I've chosen to spoil myself on what goes on in the movie, yeah, what I spoiled myself on I wasn't that happy about anyway. I dunno, maybe that'll change once I actually watch the film eventually, but maybe it's just because I'm that picky after Wreck-It Ralph. I'll come back to you in a few months' time on that.
 
^ Disney always does that. Say "so-and-so movie is the best since The Lion King," I mean. I definitely recall them doing that with The Princess and the Frog, at the very least.

Disney sucks at marketing, and most Americans don't take animation as seriously as they should. Until both change, that's how all Disney movies are going to be marketed (focus on the comedic aspects/sidekick/anything that's "edgy" i.e. the focus on the video game cameos for Wreck-it Ralph - I saw it get a lot of criticism for that, at least).

http://www.serebiiforums.com/showthread.php?536959-The-last-movie-you-saw&p=16704776#post16704776

^ My thoughts.

Though having a few more days to think about it, I have to say, I take back what I said about the movie having a weak villain. I don't think it's so much that the villain is a bad character; quite the contrary, actually, now that I've had more time to think about it. I just thought didn't like the execution of the villain. It felt very forced to me.

Also forgot to mention the movie had quite a few plot holes and things that could have been explained more (like where Elsa's powers come from and maybe have some more development between Anna and Kristoff - a lot of the scenes they had together felt a bit rushed to me), not to mention some characters I didn't really care for (I mentioned Sven the reindeer - he was more or less your typical "big animal acting like a dog", and he wasn't nearly as funny as Maximus from Tangled. I also thought the Duke of Wesselton was an unnecessary and rather unfunny character, and the trolls were kind of just "there").

But I should mention a few other things I liked about the movie I forgot to mention earlier. I like how it subverts a lot of common Disney princess tropes, although they were a bit on the nose (too obvious) with it sometimes. And while I mentioned that I liked the relationship between the sisters, I especially loved Elsa as a character. She's a very tragic, complex, and even relatable character. Probably my favorite Disney princess ever.

If this doesn't beat out the Academy's Pixar bias, nothing will.
 
Last edited:
Hoo boy, here we go. You want my thoughts? You got them.

I make no plans to see this movie--at least in theaters. I love Disney to death, but what was going on during this movie's production was a bit ridiculous, in my opinion. The fact they changed their minds to make Frozen 3D instead of 2D was one of them. Just because Princess and the Frog and Winnie the Pooh didn't do well because of poor timing doesn't mean a company should forsake its roots of traditional animation which is where the Disney magic lies. Hopefully when the economy (eventually) picks itself back up, they'll reopen that department because there's still a market for 2D films.

One of the later problems came from the douchebag head animator, Lino DiSalvo, who said, "Historically speaking, animating female characters are really, really difficult, because they have to go through these range of emotions, but you have to keep them pretty and they’re very sensitive to — you can get them off a model very quickly." (Link to the article.) B'awwwwwwwww, female characters have to be pretty, so we have to take special care to make sure they're perfect Barbies for our little girls to look up to. Allow me to play for you a sad song on the world's smallest violin. Oh, and here's a counterargument from a female animator.

That was what really did it for me (next to Olaf, he's such a fugly-looking character who being marketed from hell and back because he'll appeal to the kids and being a silly side-kick). Also, the official trailer says "experience the greatest Disney animated event since The Lion King" thus raising expectations that the movie will be just as awesome (or overrated) as their biggest hit The Lion King. Why did they toot their own horn, you don't do that.

And since people are either in the love it or hate it category, something tells me people's expectations weren't exactly met. Good job, Disney. This will be the first time I'm actually renting one of your movies to see if I like it enough to give you my money. And I'm not sure how good those odds are, to be honest, especially since I thought the animation looked a bit off in the trailers.

By the way, OP, you did not say we had to have already seen the movie to talk about it. These are just my thoughts on it right now after all that has happened. And considering I've chosen to spoil myself on what goes on in the movie, yeah, what I spoiled myself on I wasn't that happy about anyway. I dunno, maybe that'll change once I actually watch the film eventually, but maybe it's just because I'm that picky after Wreck-It Ralph. I'll come back to you in a few months' time on that.

I completely understand your views. It's funny - I actually went into the movie with zero expectations. I knew nothing about it, hadn't read anything about it, hadn't seen any trailers. I certainly have since read all of the arguments about flaws with the film, but I think I just came out grinning and having been so impressed by many of the things Golden_Latias mentioned that I forgive the flaws.

It also seems very odd that there have been so many angry articles about how the film is 'anti-feminist'. It's...not like this is new for Disney. The whole Disney trope of the Disney Princess has been that there is the basic formula of the princess finding her prince, and if anything this film finally subverted this - A) By making Anna's true love not a prince at all, and B) Making the love a sub-plot, one where you THINK it's gonna be the main focus but it turns out it's the sisterly love that truly matters in the end.

Something I've been learning recently is that it really is true that no matter how good or bad a film is, opinions are like belly buttons - everyone has them, some 'in', some 'out', but they're all different. And that's beautiful.

And while I mentioned that I liked the relationship between the sisters, I especially loved Elsa as a character. She's a very tragic, complex, and even relatable character. Probably my favorite Disney princess ever.

I agree full-heartedly with this. I fell head-over-heels for Elsa. What a character. And Let it Go is possibly the best animation set-to-a-song Disney has done since the title song from BatB.

I thought the twist with the villain was very clever, completely unexpected. And I thought Kristoff's relationship with Sven was adorable - although it took me a double take to realize the boy running around with the ice in the beginning, with the throwaway line from the troll "I'm gonna keep you", was in fact Kristoff.
 
The fact they changed their minds to make Frozen 3D instead of 2D was one of them. Just because Princess and the Frog and Winnie the Pooh didn't do well because of poor timing doesn't mean a company should forsake its roots of traditional animation which is where the Disney magic lies. Hopefully when the economy (eventually) picks itself back up, they'll reopen that department because there's still a market for 2D films.

The fact that Tangled did phenomenally and Princess and the Frog did not tells a very different story to the Disney Company. It's best to stop hoping for 2D animation because you're just going to get disappointed. Princess and the Frog was poorly timed? It was a holiday season movie, how's that poorly timed for children's films? I hear more argument that the Princess and the Frog didn't do well because of racism than timing, but that's another debate for another thread. (althoguh I'd like to believe it's because Tangled was a phenomenal movie, and Princess and the Frog was... not)

The point is, Disney doesn't see a 2D market and, for whatever reason, the box office numbers are on their side. So don't get your expectations up for something that's never gonna happen
 
Princess and the Frog was poorly timed? It was a holiday season movie, how's that poorly timed for children's films?

Christmas of 2009, Avatar was released a week after, and the economy was beginning to tank at that point. Winnie the Pooh was released at the same time as Harry Potter and Smurfs.

I hear more argument that the Princess and the Frog didn't do well because of racism than timing, but that's another debate for another thread.

If that was the reason, it's a stupid reason. I have of yet to see Princess and the Frog outside of clips (and those clips were awesome to watch), but I've heard more praise about it than not. And while I think Tangled is a good movie, I don't see how it's a special movie.

The point is, Disney doesn't see a 2D market and, for whatever reason, the box office numbers are on their side. So don't get your expectations up for something that's never gonna happen

DreamWorks thought the same thing. They did well with their 2D films, up-to-par with Disney's animation (if not better), but 3D seems to be their specialty, and I'm okay with that. (They are making a movie that will have both 3D and 2D animation, though it depends on if production goes well that it'll be released as planned.) And I know I shouldn't, but I still hope that if Disney doesn't reopen their traditional animation department (or at least doesn't make a movie in the style of Paperman), someone else will to show that 2D animation still has relevance in Hollywood and not just for Saturday mornings *coughRalphBaksicough*. Really, I find 2D animation much more captivating than 3D animation. A lot of hard work goes into both fields, but 3D animation has computers involved the whole way. Sure, these days the same can be said for 2D animation as digital art (Flash is great, but its animation is recognizable), but the animator is still doing it by hand, and it involves a bit more work. And it's rather magical how a single animator can pull off the illusion of moving, 2D frames in an amount of time.

That's why I keep my hopes up for 2D animation to remain alive a while longer. Not that I don't like 3D movies, there are some movies that I felt could not work in 2D (Wreck-It Ralph I felt would not have worked as well as a 2D film), but I would like to see variety sometimes. You know? I mean, heck, Pixar could probably pull off a 2D film. That Day & Night short was amazing. They can do it, and those were most likely interns who animated it. Your Friend the Rat also had 2D animation in it, and it's a joy to watch (the whole short is a joy to watch, I love it). So there is a spark there for 2D films, someone just has to step up to break the mold. Even if it's for one time, that would be great.

Now a question: did anyone see Frozen in 3D? If so, did they take advantage of that 3D mechanics? The last movie I saw in 3D was Tangled, and the only thing that was "worth" seeing it in 3D were the lanterns, but that was it. It was otherwise pointless to have see it in 3D. Yes, you could see Rapunzel's hair clearly, but you can still see it fine regularly. There were no moments that stuck out to me about her hair in 3D that made me go, "This was worth the ten bucks."
 
My mom wants to see it. I might go with her one day to see it.
 
Frozen has Catching Fire to compete with, and it seems to be doing just fine.

I didn't see it in 3D, but I can think of a few scenes that would look amazing in 3D (like the aforementioned "Let it Go" score), but I don't think it's worth the extra money.

Although come to think of it, I would think the "Get a Horse" short before the movie would look pretty dang impressive in 3D.
 
Frozen has Catching Fire to compete with, and it seems to be doing just fine.

Is it more popular with audiences than Harry Potter, though?

Although come to think of it, I would think the "Get a Horse" short before the movie would look pretty dang impressive in 3D.

I heard about a Mickey Mouse cartoon, but didn't know what it was about until my friend told me about it when he was talking about the movie. (I told him to go ahead and explain the entire film to me as I had already spoiled myself anyway, and I was curious about his thoughts since he resented what was going on with the movie a lot.) He missed the beginning of it, but he enjoyed the short very much. Said Mickey basically was similar to the model used in Epic Mickey, and I'm going "Awesooooome".

I suppose that would be one thing to look forward to when I rent the film. It's been a long time since Mickey had a cartoon short attached to a movie, and I looked it up a bit to see what it was about. According to what I found, it was an unfinished cartoon from the late '20s they spent years trying to get the studio to approve of so they could work on it (similar to Frozen's original concept being planned as early as the '40s). They also used archived voice clips of Walt Disney for Mickey's lines. The studio must have some really good restoration techniques for audio given the time period of when his voice was recorded.
 
I did go see Catching Fire the day before it came out (I love early screenings), but I haven't made it to see Frozen yet. Previews make it look like such a fun, cute Disney movie, and my family, friends, and I all want to see it! I hope I can make it to see it soon for sure! :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top