• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

gender differences

AquaJet

Member
Generation IV introduced the pokemon world to sexual dimorphism and so I was thinking that Pokemon should just bite the bullet and make Nidoran (F/M) into a single species. It always bugged me that Nidoran's name is followed by the symbols for gender. It's not like a male Nidoran says "Nidoran Male!" when released from it's pokeball.

Coupled with this, I think it would be appropriate for Nidorina and Nidoqueen to breed. The offspring would have a fifty-fifty chance of being female or male Nidoran. I know that this would be a big change to the Pokemon world but I believe it makes a lot of sense. Discuss.
 
I get what you mean about this subject but I disagree about the combining the two species. Their movesets slightly differ and it would just be screwed up... Like if the Gen 5 games were compatible with the gen 4 games it would just cause confusion. I would rather have it that the Male and female nido family be able to breed with each other.
 
Generation IV introduced the pokemon world to sexual dimorphism and so I was thinking that Pokemon should just bite the bullet and make Nidoran (F/M) into a single species. It always bugged me that Nidoran's name is followed by the symbols for gender. It's not like a male Nidoran says "Nidoran Male!" when released from it's pokeball.

Coupled with this, I think it would be appropriate for Nidorina and Nidoqueen to breed. The offspring would have a fifty-fifty chance of being female or male Nidoran. I know that this would be a big change to the Pokemon world but I believe it makes a lot of sense. Discuss.

It's too late now to combine Nidoran (M) and Nidroran (F). Plus, they have different stats & movesets.

Making Nidorina & Nidoqueen breedable makes sense, but I guess it's just one of those quirks in Pokémon.
 
-1, +1

Generation IV introduced the pokemon world to sexual dimorphism and so I was thinking that Pokemon should just bite the bullet and make Nidoran (F/M) into a single species. It always bugged me that Nidoran's name is followed by the symbols for gender. It's not like a male Nidoran says "Nidoran Male!" when released from it's pokeball.

Coupled with this, I think it would be appropriate for Nidorina and Nidoqueen to breed. The offspring would have a fifty-fifty chance of being female or male Nidoran. I know that this would be a big change to the Pokemon world but I believe it makes a lot of sense. Discuss.

INCREDIBLE! I had the same idea myself about making the two one species! I also think Game Freak should give us an extra Pokemon in the original 151. It would be extremely odd, but perhaps they could make Missingno an actual Pokemon with a cool movie and everything! (Just an odd thought.)
 
It's crazy

^ missigno a pokemon? are u being crazy or what.
Pardon me, but what kind of question is that? Of course I'm being crazy!

Can't you picture it? A movie about a Pokemon so foreign from the usual Pokemon world that it actually duplicates items, distorts space, and might not be caught in a Master Ball. What could be crazier?
 
I was thinking that Game Freak also should have done this, but then it came to mind that maybe the differences between the two genders of that species is so great that they're considered different Pokemon by the Dex.

Either that or when Pokemon were being "discovered" and added to the Pokedex one-by-one, they came across the male after the female Nidoran, but by that point it was too late to make the change to the Dex.

Just my own two theories. =/
 
lol about the missingno. sounds good for a movie, could also include how it was a mistake in being created.. but then again, like the other person said, are you crazy?? :p
I can see where you are going with it though.
 
No way will they merge Nidoran together. It would mess up the whole pokedex and tbh it's just not worth the bother for Game Freak.
 
It would be a great idea, but it just can't be done. The entire pokédex would get screwed up.
 
To both the two above me: It would not mess up the whole Pokedex if they made a new one! It's just that simple. Remember, 151-1+1=151.

It's too late now to combine Nidoran (M) and Nidroran (F). Plus, they have different stats & movesets.

Making Nidorina & Nidoqueen breedable makes sense, but I guess it's just one of those quirks in Pokémon.
The fact that the two have different movesets makes absolutely no difference. Wormadam has three different forms with not only different movesets, but also different types!
 
Well, I guess I get what you're getting at, but then you're going to have to face other Pokemon in the same situation like Glalie/Froslass or Gardevoir/Gallade. Both examples involve Pokemon of different genders with different names, a different physiognomy, different stats, moves, and even different types.

Going by the logic you have presented, wouldn't we have to unite them as one species as well? The Nidoran male/female divide essentially presents the same differences between them (excluding the fact that both species have the same type).
 
I think the Nido lines will stay seperated, but I do think that Nidorina and Nidoqueen need to be able to breed. Make the male/female birth rate 50%.

However, in the future it would be cool to see some pokemon get gender specific variations for movepool like the Nidos. And maybe more dramatic differences in their sprites as well. Sort of like how so many bird species look completely different based on gender.
 
what about tauros and miltank? they are supposed to be the opposite gender of the same poke or something right? haha, that ****** up
 
Well, I guess I get what you're getting at, but then you're going to have to face other Pokemon in the same situation like Glalie/Froslass or Gardevoir/Gallade. Both examples involve Pokemon of different genders with different names, a different physiognomy, different stats, moves, and even different types.

Going by the logic you have presented, wouldn't we have to unite them as one species as well? The Nidoran male/female divide essentially presents the same differences between them (excluding the fact that both species have the same type).
No, Glalie/Froslass and Gardevoir/Gallade are entirely different. First off, they actually have different names. Nidoran (male and female) simply have male and female symbols, not a different name.

Second, Glalie and Gardevoir can both be either male or female. There are female Glalie and female Froslass. In other words, neither Glalie/Froslass nor Gardevoir/Gallade is a clear-cut gender based split. They do not need to be united in one species.

Another big difference is that Nidoran (male and female) are actually the first stages in their evolutionary lines. If the designers decided to unite these two into one species (and Dex number), they would parallel Gardevoir/Gallade and Glalie/Froslass even more closely.

Also: If Missingno appeared in a movie, I know what its weakness should be! What else has never before been seen in the Pokemon world (except by the game-hackers)? The answer can be nothing but ??? Arceus! (And before anyone asks, yes, this is a crazy idea! But it would be awesome! ;493; [???] VS ;000;)
 
Last edited:
No, Glalie/Froslass and Gardevoir/Gallade are entirely different. First off, they actually have different names. Nidoran (male and female) simply have male and female symbols, not a different name.

Second, Glalie and Gardevoir can both be either male or female. There are female Glalie and female Froslass. In other words, neither Glalie/Froslass nor Gardevoir/Gallade is a clear-cut gender based split. They do not need to be united in one species.

Another big difference is that Nidoran (male and female) are actually the first stages in their evolutionary lines. If the designers decided to unite these two into one species (and Dex number), they would parallel Gardevoir/Gallade and Glalie/Froslass even more closely.

Also: If Missingno appeared in a movie, I know what its weakness should be! What else has never before been seen in the Pokemon world (except by the game-hackers)? The answer can be nothing but ??? Arceus! (And before anyone asks, yes, this is a crazy idea! But it would be awesome! ;493; [???] VS ;000;)
i think in another post they figured out that if you gave arceus a sky plate, it would be a pure flying, and then if it roosted, it would lose the flying type and become a ??? type.. but i dont think it can learn roost, sooooooo... who cares.
 
Back
Top