• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

Moral views

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have recently been informed i have low morals

i believe that sending children to coal mines is acceptable yet i was discussing this with someone the other day and their exact words were: dude that is so not right what the **** is wrong with you?.

I do not understand what is wrong with things like that i would like to know what morals consist of and what i am missing
 
Odds are this sucker's gonna get locked, but I'm willing to run with this fairly, given my state of boredom.

Think of it this way. First off, conditions inside of a coal mine are very hazardous, possibly even lethal to anyone. Inhalation of dust and coal creates black lung syndrome, which is a known killer. Second, what if there's a cave-in and the children die? Do you want to be accountable for the deaths of hundreds of children? I know I wouldn't.

Second, children are young. They have yet to witness the joys and happiness of life, and enjoy their youth. Moreover, adults can easily do 100 times the work a child can do (though I would never suggest "coal miner" as a profession to someone), as they have matured into a fully capable adult. Children don't even have the same education or distinction or right and wrong as and adult does, so they can't fully comprehend the situation that they are in. Shouldn't a person be able to know exactly what they're doing and why they're doing it? Little kids can hardly tie their shoe correctly, let alone dig for an aging power resource. It's just a terrible idea.

Morals are the concept of knowing what is right and what is wrong, and usually sticking with the right choice. There are people who will make that wrong choice anyway (as a man who knows the girl he's sleeping with has a boyfriend, yet still does it anyway), but it is their choice. I personally would like to think that most people in the world will make the right choice if given the chance, but that's just my thought on the matter.
 
Yet, children are loyal and need less food than an adult, so there are advantages to having children serve as workers and soldiers. Soldiers especially. The children are nimble allowing them to move into small spaces more easily.

Plus who is better of risking death in a coal mine or war? a kid that took only 7 years to build and has been cheap in the consumption during it's short life,

or an adult that's been in production and learning mode for 20 years and has been expensive due to their consumption of 20 years?

No contest really.

All aboard for the Free-Post-Express!
 
Last edited:
actualy vermehlo from the age 12-18 rougly you need more food then adults
but most likely you talk about kids younger then that I'm against it like every normal person I guese.. :p
satfire let me put it this way: I think it's okay to let you starf to death in a 1M³ but that doesn't mean it's moraly right :P

yeaaah Free-Post Expres (wants window seat :p)
 
Because it's socially unacceptable that children be put in conditions that are tough. Children don't have the life experiences and ability to know what to do at what point. Children are hardly likely to listen during a rundown on safety procedures in a coal mine.
 
Because it's socially unacceptable that children be put in conditions that are tough. Children don't have the life experiences and ability to know what to do at what point. Children are hardly likely to listen during a rundown on safety procedures in a coal mine.

Pfft! Weak you are! with your silly morals and feeble concepts of protecting the weak. Children must serve as miners and soldiers for the benefit of Society! Satfire333 has discovered what is so wrong with our world. Put kiddied to work and in addition to providing cheap if not free labour is that the little shi-tters will be too tired to cause trouble.
 
Because it's socially unacceptable that children be put in conditions that are tough. Children don't have the life experiences and ability to know what to do at what point. Children are hardly likely to listen during a rundown on safety procedures in a coal mine.
Children actually did hard work centuries ago. Especially in the great depression and before the Industrial Revolution. Children in hard labor is nothing new; heck look at China.
 


Pfft! Weak you are! with your silly morals and feeble concepts of protecting the weak. Children must serve as miners and soldiers for the benefit of Society! Satfire333 has discovered what is so wrong with our world. Put kiddied to work and in addition to providing cheap if not free labour is that the little shi-tters will be too tired to cause trouble.

Yeah, I would probably have thought that to be more funny, if it wasn't because I'm still a kid. (I think, Is 13 a kid?) If you look at it the efficient and productive way that you have, Varmehlo_Steele, then yeah, I agree, it would be smarter to sacrifice the little kids. I mean, who doesn't like a good meat shield? But almost everyone would feel intense guilt from setting this kids to work and die, so that is what their morals are. People would feel bad, so to them, it is morally wrong. Morals are pretty much dictated by whatever the majority of humans believe is right and wrong.
 
I have recently been informed i have low morals

i believe that sending children to coal mines is acceptable yet i was discussing this with someone the other day and their exact words were: dude that is so not right what the **** is wrong with you?.

I do not understand what is wrong with things like that i would like to know what morals consist of and what i am missing

Well, I think you need more details for that specific situation. For instance, if children were rounded up against their will and forced to work in coal mines, I'm sure that would not be acceptable. However, if children work in coal mines because of the horrible socio-economic conditions they live in and the extra wages are needed to support their family, it might be a different story, albeit a sad one.

In the general, morality really depends on whether you think there is an ultimate truth or good. If you do not believe that, than morality is really relative.
 
Children actually did hard work centuries ago. Especially in the great depression and before the Industrial Revolution. Children in hard labor is nothing new; heck look at China.

You mean during the Industrial Revolution? Yeah, I remember reading up on that. I also remember reading that the work conditions were horrible, and that children would be used to fit in areas that adults wouldn't fit into, and get paid pretty much squat.

As for the V_S B-S, I'd rather have our children be learning to benefit the society in a different manner rather than putting them out there to die. I may not be a child anymore (Mastavida, I'd put anywhere up to the end of you're teenage years as being a child; I just past that mark one month ago), but it's easily a smarter choice to educate rather than force manual labor upon them. Would you really want a country full of children who didn't know how to read? Or those who didn't know squat about history, couldn't solve a simple Algebra problem, or why our bodies work the way they do? That just seems like a great way to collapse civilization as we know it.

The amount of life a person has can never outweigh the fact that they also have a soul, and should be treated with the same amount of respect as an adult. You may have to teach a child a thing or two along the way, but that's how life works. Lemme finish this with one question: Imagine YOU are that child being sent down to work. You have a higher risk of mortality than you do survival, and in the end you're going to be sent home with a plethora of illnesses in your body. Would you be happy about going down there? I wouldn't think so.
 
Last edited:
Don't worry Satfire. Morals are just abstract ideas. You don't have to agree with them. Most of them are nonsense anyway.

But I do believe it's not very beneficial to destroy your children. They are the future of your nation/country/race. If you kill them, damage them (psychologically or physically), you will have a problem in the future.

It's only a short term solution to use them for heavy labour and combat. But sometimes, it's the only solution you have.

I can't blame a poor mother for selling one child, so she can keep the rest of her children alive. I also can't blame a factory owner for using child labour, if it's all he can afford. Sometimes, you just have to do something that's wrong, in order to survive.
 
Satfire333 if you really do think that sending children to coal mines is a good idea (which I doubt) then you're a sicko.
 
well the true questio is for those supporting sending children to coal mines heres the question what you do as kids (dont be hypocrites here)
 
Objective Morality

Don't worry Satfire. Morals are just abstract ideas. You don't have to agree with them. Most of them are nonsense anyway.
Totally unsound ZarraWolf. You don't have to be an environmentalist to know that nuking whales for the fun of it is objectively wrong. You don't have to be an Amish pacifist to know that slaughtering nations for the thrill of it is evil. This points to the existence of conscience, something inside us that tells us what to do and what not to do.

In the general, morality really depends on
whether you think there is an ultimate truth or good. If you do not believe that, than morality is really relative.
That just about sums it up. If humans had no conscience, people would only be able to oppose actions they disagree with; they could not condemn those actions. We would be left with nothing but conflicting human opinion. And what would happen if an extremely powerful individual had agressive, dangerous opinions? That's right, we could only say that we "don't like" his dangerous agression.

Deep down, we all know that conscience exists. And (buckle your seatbelts) I make no apology for telling someone that his conscience tells him that it is absolutely wrong for any person in any time or place to go on a killing spree for his own enjoyment. Or to steal millions from elderly people. Or to eliminate humans believed to be "unfit". Or to say that all children must work in coal mines.

Our conscience is not just feeling. We don't just feel that these wrong actions are wrong; they actually are wrong in an objective sense.
 
I disagree Fighting Pikachu.

If we all had the same morals and consciences, there would not be any genocide or sport hunting. People DO kill animals for fun, and people do indiscriminately kill one another.

So your theory seems flawed. Because if we all knew it was wrong, it wouldn't happen. Especially not in situations where we have other options. Seeing as genocide and hunting for fun are things that are often done while it is not even directly necessary, I don't think it's as wired into our brains as you would like it to be.
 
Yeah, I would probably have thought that to be more funny, if it wasn't because I'm still a kid. (I think, Is 13 a kid?)

you should be sent to the coal mine

In the general, morality really depends on whether you think there is an ultimate truth or good. If you do not believe that, than morality is really relative

relative to what?

But I do believe it's not very beneficial to destroy your children. They are the future

if they are our future they should be exposed to the real world send them to war and the coal mines, it will give them courage,will power, and exposure to what the world is really like, also their just kids so we don't have to pay them
what you do as kids

i worked my *** off and no that is not the real question its posted above

You don't have to be an environmentalist to know that nuking whales for the fun of it is objectively wrong.
here

Deep down, we all know that conscience exists. And (buckle your seatbelts) I make no apology for telling someone that his conscience tells him that it is absolutely wrong for any person in any time or place to go on a killing spree for his own enjoyment. Or to steal millions from elderly people. Or to eliminate humans believed to be "unfit". Or to say that all children must work in coal mines.

my conscience tells me that children should work in the coal mines (and that the government wants me dead) and actually it does not tell me any of the things you have said all it really does is warn me of those against me
 
Last edited by a moderator:
if they are our future they should be exposed to the real world send them to war and the coal mines, it will give them courage,will power, and exposure to what the world is really like, also their just kids so we don't have to pay them

I agree that children should be exposed to the real world. But, if you don't mind me asking, how many times have you shot a pregnant woman, smashed an infant against the rocks or seen your family get murdered in front of you?

Because those are some of the things child soldiers are commonly confronted with.

Also, they are not really suitable to be used for anything else after that. I knew someone who took care of a couple of child soldiers that were "rescued". They had to be institutionalised for the rest of their lives. And were a threat to anything that moved. The best thing for them would have been euthanasia.

So my point still stands. Not the best thing to do if you want your species to have a future.
 
I agree that children should be exposed to the real world. But, if you don't mind me asking, how many times have you shot a pregnant woman, smashed an infant against the rocks or seen your family get murdered in front of you?

excepting for the last one if i said yes to those i could get thrown in jail that's the only excuse the government would need to make me dissipate

Also, they are not really suitable to be used for anything else after that. I knew someone who took care of a couple of child soldiers that were "rescued". They had to be institutionalised for the rest of their lives. And were a threat to anything that moved. The best thing for them would have been euthanasia.


What else would i want them for? you spelled "institutionalized" wrong

So my point still stands. Not the best thing to do if you want your species to have a future.

Why is that? We would have soldiers that have been fighting their entire lives and are good at it our species would be in an excellent condition even more so than they are now.
 
well look at vietnamm we kindove killed a huge chunk of a generation what happens if all the kids go to a huge war , we well we could lose our younger generations, that and plus be honest your probably no longer a kid have you everfought and would you be happy if someone gave you a gun when you where eight and said hey see those guys over there kill them, war screws with you so badly pshyocologically that sending our children to fight would just and with a genration of horribly demented kids,

last point we are at our type form as a species when we are Eighteen the only reason these kids soldiers worked so well was the fact that we never expected tthem to be soldiers and they where seen as an odaty
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top