• Hey all, due to some issues with false DMCA takedown requests, we've had to remove and censor a few things until the situation is resolved. Sorry for any inconvenience.
  • Be sure to join the discussion on our discord at: Discord.gg/serebii
  • If you're still waiting for the e-mail, be sure to check your junk/spam e-mail folders

New johto?

Pink sneasel

Double Trouble Time
Assuming they do come out with a new G/S remake, do you think ash will really go back to johto? I mean he has all of the badges and there isn't really a post leage d/p plot that they can move there like the battle frontier, since the Battle tower is just to small for a whole season. It would be really boring if he kept losing and had to travel around searching for it again like the pyramid.

Everyone just discuss whether or not you think he should go back to johto and the possible reasons for him to go.

All I can think of is Kurt having found out about the GS ball, But then that's why he went there in the first place:rolleyes:

Edit: Rank up
 
It would be quite cool if Ash went back, he could catch some more Johto pokemon like Ledian or somthing, i think there is a chance that he will go back!
 
It would be cool for him to go back, especially considering that Johto isn't that far from the Kanto region. I wouldn't be surprised if he went back for a couple episodes in the future.
 
I think it would be neat if they did that too, they could run into a few of the Jhoto characters Ash meet previously ^^
 
Personally, if there's a remake, yes, they should go in Johto. If there's no remake, then no, they shouldn't go in Johto. It's that simple, to me.
 
That would be awsome, then we could see how everything has changed and maybe give Ash a good reason to give totodile the phanphy treatment. =D
 
I don't really see a reason for him to go back, unless we get a GSC remake with it's very own "Battle Frontier" area.

Which we won't, since the Colluseum games FR/LG were made to get Kanto and Johto Pokemon in RSE, and we have Pal Park and GTS in DP. Not to mention the daily new Pokemon that pops up when you talk to that girl in Sandgem Town.
 
Assuming they do come out with a new G/S remake, do you think ash will really go back to johto? I mean he has all of the badges and there isn't really a post leage d/p plot that they can move there like the battle frontier, since the Battle tower is just to small for a whole season. It would be really boring if he kept losing and had to travel around searching for it again like the pyramid.

Everyone just discuss whether or not you think he should go back to johto and the possible reasons for him to go.

All I can think of is Kurt having found out about the GS ball, But then that's why he went there in the first place:rolleyes:

Edit: Rank up
Well, remember the third fourth gen game has yet to come out, and the Battle Frontier was only introduced in Emerald. There may yet be some new event for Satoshi to compete in after the Shinou league. Hypothetically, if a second gen remake were to come out then I could see them doing something similar to the Battle Frontier and relocating it to Jouto this time. Personally though I'd rather see a completely original region like the Orange Islands.
 
It wouldn't make sense for them not to go to Johto if there was a remake.

I'm sure they'll find something new for Ash to collect when he goes to Johto similar to how they found something new for Ash to collect when he went through Kanto the second time. I only hope that this time they actually stick with the requirements needed to get the items in the games instead of scrapping them like they did in the Battle Frontier. Presumably whatever Ash is made to collect would be from the 3rd in the set of main games rather than the Johto remake itself just like it was in Battle Frontier with symbols from Emerald and location from Fire/Leaf.

The GS Ball should never be mentioned by anyone again. Ever.

I'll be bummed if Dawn goes with Ash. Really.

As for who Ash should bring back for this ... I'd say Totodile and Heracross. Brock should give Crobat and Steelix another go.

Edit: I meant Totodile and Larvitar. Where on earth did Heracross come from?

Oh yeah; a tree.
 
Last edited:
Assuming they do come out with a new G/S remake, do you think ash will really go back to johto? I mean he has all of the badges and there isn't really a post leage d/p plot that they can move there like the battle frontier, since the Battle tower is just to small for a whole season. It would be really boring if he kept losing and had to travel around searching for it again like the pyramid.

Everyone just discuss whether or not you think he should go back to johto and the possible reasons for him to go.

All I can think of is Kurt having found out about the GS ball, But then that's why he went there in the first place:rolleyes:

Edit: Rank up

No. They writers should never go back to Johto. There are already wayyyyyyyy toooooooooo many episodes in Johto, most of those were horrible. If Ash goes to another region go to Sinnnoh Battle Frontier. That would cool. I am sorry I had to endure that region which almost made me stop watching the anime. It was a horrible region when it came for the anime. Pokemon should of evolved, fillers were boring. They didn't evenly space out the gym battles. I believe going to GoldenRod Gym took like 50 episodes (or at least felt like it).
 
Edit: I meant Totodile and Larvitar. Where on earth did Heracross come from?

Oh yeah; a tree.

Yogirasu/Larvitar never actually belonged to Satoshi though, and even if he wanted to go get it, that would be illegal since its in the narture preserve.
 
No. They writers should never go back to Johto. There are already wayyyyyyyy toooooooooo many episodes in Johto, most of those were horrible. If Ash goes to another region go to Sinnnoh Battle Frontier. That would cool. I am sorry I had to endure that region which almost made me stop watching the anime. It was a horrible region when it came for the anime. Pokemon should of evolved, fillers were boring. They didn't evenly space out the gym battles. I believe going to GoldenRod Gym took like 50 episodes (or at least felt like it).

Johto, the region, is actually a cool place. The writing back then messed it up. They thought that Ash, Misty with the leech egg, and Brock, could basically do anything and still be entertaining. They wanted Johto to be the new Kanto, with basically all unevolved Pokemon, and they failed because they failed as writers. I'm sure most of those writers are fired now.

With the current writers, Johto could be an awesome place like it was meant to be. Not just boring **** for the sake of nostalgia.
 
Well, if it does happen, I could see them going there to meet up with May again or something? She DID say she was going to Johto for her contests. I just hope that those dang remakes come out soon D:

When I think about it, maybe they were setting that up? I mean, May goes to Johto.. Ash goes to Sinnoh.. If they had to go back to the Johto region, May would have to be involved somehow. Maybe she could replace Dawn? >_> Doubt it though, since May accompanied Ash through Kanto for the contests, and Dawn would want to go through the contests in Johto. Okay, well, I'm rambling now :D

May would probably introduce something new in the Johto region that's probably battle frontier-esque and Ash would just HAVE to do it and then BANG we get a new and improved Johto Saga :D
 
I know Larvitar didn't belong to him, but that doesn't stop me from wanting him to get it back. Kind of like Pikachu's stubbornness doesn't stop me from wanting Ash to shove a Thunderstone down its throat.

No. They writers should never go back to Johto. There are already wayyyyyyyy toooooooooo many episodes in Johto, most of those were horrible. If Ash goes to another region go to Sinnnoh Battle Frontier. That would cool. I am sorry I had to endure that region which almost made me stop watching the anime. It was a horrible region when it came for the anime. Pokemon should of evolved, fillers were boring. They didn't evenly space out the gym battles. I believe going to GoldenRod Gym took like 50 episodes (or at least felt like it).

Johto was a historical experience.

Somewhere in between how bad Misty was hammered for being utterly useless outside of the Whirl Islands and a handful of other episodes following a pretty much stellar performance for the first half of Kanto and Casey getting the shaft in her own home region the writers learned that change could be a good thing. A regular rotation of the regional rivals and females helps fans to remember them for being good characters during their short runs over good characters gone bad who overstayed their welcome.

Heracross' signature pretty much says what needs to be said about Brock.

The same thing about Pokemon; keeping only the regional team with the region seems to be working well for ensuring that no more Pokemon get the 'Johto Treatment'. That's not to say that our old favorites are gone forever. Bringing old friends back for another go's are what Leagues and filler regions are for.

Speaking of Filler Regions including them along with meaningful archs littered throughout the series ensures that we won't have to put up with generic fillers. The Crowning Achievement's an example of something we'll never have to endure again if we're lucky; an example of an episode where Ash and friends so absolutely nothing but stand around, watch events happen, and then congratulate the character of the day for solving the problem themselves. Sinnoh's already had a handful of stinkers but none like that.

Gym Leaders were pretty hit and miss. I think they handled Claire, Pryce, Morty, and Whitney well. Jasmine was pretty much butchered, and I honestly can't remember anything about Bugsy or Falkner worth remembering except Falkner's team was entirely too strong for a beginning Trainer to ever hope to defeat (Dodrio and Pidgeot!?).

If Johto's done nothing else it's proved to be a pretty good wake up call for the writers in general. They finally geared up to make the series more interesting well past the 3/4s point towards the end of the series, but by them it was too late to fix absolutely everything so they rushed to fix what they could.
 
I think its okay to have a johto MINI arc for like 10 eps, but not even a season. Mabye just to get the GS ball and then they find team rocket doing something in Johto again, but just not an entire season, just 10 ep.
 
Well, remember the third fourth gen game has yet to come out, and the Battle Frontier was only introduced in Emerald. There may yet be some new event for Satoshi to compete in after the Shinou league. Hypothetically, if a second gen remake were to come out then I could see them doing something similar to the Battle Frontier and relocating it to Jouto this time. Personally though I'd rather see a completely original region like the Orange Islands.

I'd love to see them do some type of Orange Islands thing. Ash won that so I don't see him going back there, maybe they could do some thing simular though.
If they did do a Jhoto type thing with the present writers I could see being like a refix for that series. I don't know if Dawn would be with him, if it was a filler saga between Ash gyms than she prob would but if its like a next gen type thing she prob won't be with him.
 
If there was really a renewed Johto saga, they had better worked extremely hard so that all the useless stuff that made the first saga so dang boring is removed completely.
 
We can't assume that Dawn would be along. Remember the May followed Ash back to the Kanto region. But I don't see the writer doing an entire season again in the Johto region. Maybe a large arc of episodes, but not a season.
 
Back
Top